In baseball memorabilia, you wouldn’t collect a bat signed by a pitcher or a glove signed by a designated hitter. Well, some people probably would, but it’s more likely you’d want a baseball that had been autographed by a pitcher like Sandy Koufax or Nolan Ryan, or a bat that’s been signed by sluggers such as Hank Aaron or Willie Mays.

Similarly, the most collectible footballs are signed by the players who touched them the most. That’s why football memorabilia collectors usually look for footballs autographed by quarterbacks such as Joe Namath, John Elway, Joe Montana, and Johnny Unitas, or running backs from Jim Brown to Walter Payton. Receiver signatures are popular, too (Jerry Rice and Mike Wallace are favorites), but how do you account for the popularity of Troy Polamalu’s autograph on footballs? Maybe it’s because footballs rarely get past this exceptionally strong, strong safety.

In general, footballs signed by players of the last quarter century or so are commodities—forgeries and reproductions abound, so make sure yours comes with authentication you can trust. More rare are footballs whose signatures and pebbly pigskin surfaces are both vintage. Nineteenth-century footballs were melon-shaped, harkening to the sport’s lineage in this country from rugby. Spalding claims it manufactured the first American football in 1887, but even these were not as pointed at the ends as footballs are today.

Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

Vintage Football Card Gallery

Vintage Football Card Gallery

This great database of pro and collegiate football cards from the 1950s and 1960s offers scanned images of cards fo… [read review or visit site]

Other Great Reference Sites

Most watched eBay auctions    

Walter Payton Signed Wilson Football Certificate Of Authenticity In Glass CaseBarry Sanders/lomas Brown Autographed Nfl Game Ball - Detroit LionsJameis Winston Signed Full Size Football Auto Psa/dna Sticker Only Florida StateJoe Montana San Francisco 49ers Autographed Duke Pro Football -item #4508961Calvin Johnson Jr Autographed Football W/ Coa Detroit Lions Mvp Megatron LegendBarry Sanders Detroit Lions Autographed Duke Pro Football With -item #4219996Packers Aaron Rodgers Signed Official Nfl Football Autographed Practice Used!!Mounted Memories Authentic Dan Marino Autographed Nfl Football In Display CaseOakland Raiders Bo Jackson Autographed Duke Football - Memories - -item #1757933Dan Marino Signed Wilson Football With Coa W/ Display Case Autograph CertificatePeyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed Duke Pro Football -item #21461Johnny Manziel Rc Autographed Signed Ncaa Wilson Football Psa/dna #r15443 BrownsColin Kaepernick San Francisco 49ers Autographed Pro Football -item #3740841John Kuhn Signed Green Bay Packers Logo Football Jsa ItpDenver Broncos Peyton Manning Autographed Wilson Nfl Football -item #3554630Barry Sanders "hof '04" (duke) Autographed Football - Mounted -item #423581Peyton Manning Signed "7 Td's 9-5-13" Duke Football Steiner Le 1182002-03 Oakland Raiders Team Signed Football W/ Al Davis, Madden, Woodson + MoreAlabama Crimson Tide A.j Mccarron & Nick Saban Fullsize Autographed Football/coaAutographed Nfl Peyton Manning Broncos Signed Football - Seller CoaPeyton Manning & Julius Thomas Denver Broncos Dual Autographed -item #4198265Emmitt Smith Dallas Cowboys Autographed Duke Pro Football - -item #24036Emmitt Smith And Tony Dorsett (autographed) Nfl Football Dallas CowboysEmmitt Smith Autographed Football With H.o.f 2010 Inscription - -item #1750549Peyton Manning Denver Broncos Autographed Wilson Pro Football -item #3557890Paul Posluszny Signed Penn State Nittany Lions Logo Football Linebacker U JsaAndrew Luck Indianapolis Colts Autographed Duke Football - -item #3689193Matt Hasselbeck "8" Signed Autographed Wilson Nfl Football Psa/dna Coa In CaseAutographed Nfl Joe Montana 49ers Signed Football - Seller CoaPeyton Manning Denver Broncos Autographed Pro Football With Nfl -item #3967070Makers Mark Bourbon & Nfl Football Dipped In Red Wax Signed By Bill Samuels Jr.Autographed/signed Troy Aikman Cowboys Full Size Wilson Football Uda Coa & HoloSigned Super Bowl Xxx Football 21 Hall Of FamersTexas A&m Aggies #2 Johnny Manziel Full Size Autographed Football With Logo/coaPeyton Manning & Eli Manning Dual Signed Autographed Football CoaPeyton Manning Super Bowl Xli Autographed Pro Football - Memories -item #16193Autographed Nfl Peyton Manning Broncos Signed Football - Mounted Memories CoaNick Foles Philadelphia Eagles Autographed Duke Pro Football With -item #4586134New Orleans Saints #9 Drew Brees Full Size Autographed Football/coaTom Brady Auto Sb Xxxvii Authentic Ball - Tristar - Coa - W CaseTim Brown Autographed 'raider 4 Life' Oakland Raiders Football W/gai CoaJadeveon Clown Signed Full Size South Carolina Football Auto Psa/dna CoaBo Jackson Signed Raiders Football With CoaDrew Brees Autographed Nfl Football W/ Coa New Orleans Saints Super Bowl ChampRudy Ruettiger Signed Notre Dame Full Size Logo Football Jsa ItpJohnny Manziel Autographed Football - Psa/dna - '12 Heisman Inscription - L@@kHof'er Ny Jets Joe Namath Signed Autographed 'nfl' Football Coa/hologramDual Signed John Elway & Peyton Manning Denver Broncos Football - -item #4601968Peyton Manning Denver Broncos 2013 Nfl Mvp Autographed Duke Pro -item #4104339New England Patriots Tom Brady & Rob Gronkowski Autographed Signed Football! CoaJohnny Manziel Autographed Sign Football Texas A&m Jsa Cleveland BrownsheismanPeyton Manning Autograph As Well As Other Colts Players FootballColin Kaepernick San Francisco 49ers Autographed Pro Football -item #3740842Julio Jones Autographed Falcons FootballJoe Montana San Francisco 49ers Autographed Duke Pro Football -item #4508962Deion Sanders Signed Football With CoaAuthentic Randy White #54 Signed Autographed Football Nfl WilsonFranco Harris And Jack Ham Signed Penn State Football With CoaDan Marino Signed Upper Deck FootballJoe Montana San Francisco 49ers Autographed Duke Pro Football -item #4508960