In baseball memorabilia, you wouldn’t collect a bat signed by a pitcher or a glove signed by a designated hitter. Well, some people probably would, but it’s more likely you’d want a baseball that had been autographed by a pitcher like Sandy Koufax or Nolan Ryan, or a bat that’s been signed by sluggers such as Hank Aaron or Willie Mays.

Similarly, the most collectible footballs are signed by the players who touched them the most. That’s why football memorabilia collectors usually look for footballs autographed by quarterbacks such as Joe Namath, John Elway, Joe Montana, and Johnny Unitas, or running backs from Jim Brown to Walter Payton. Receiver signatures are popular, too (Jerry Rice and Mike Wallace are favorites), but how do you account for the popularity of Troy Polamalu’s autograph on footballs? Maybe it’s because footballs rarely get past this exceptionally strong, strong safety.

In general, footballs signed by players of the last quarter century or so are commodities—forgeries and reproductions abound, so make sure yours comes with authentication you can trust. More rare are footballs whose signatures and pebbly pigskin surfaces are both vintage. Nineteenth-century footballs were melon-shaped, harkening to the sport’s lineage in this country from rugby. Spalding claims it manufactured the first American football in 1887, but even these were not as pointed at the ends as footballs are today.

Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

Vintage Football Card Gallery

Vintage Football Card Gallery

This great database of pro and collegiate football cards from the 1950s and 1960s offers scanned images of cards fo… [read review or visit site]

Other Great Reference Sites

Most watched eBay auctions    

Peyton Manning Signed "7 Td's 9-5-13" Duke Football Steiner Le 118Brian Dawkins Philadelphia Eagles Signed Brown Logo Football SiJohnny Manziel #2 Signed Texas A&m Aggies Jersey Size M Psa/dna Coa Auto Cleveland Browns Graham Groza Lavelli Motley Autographed Football W/ Jsa Loa HofBrowns All Time Greats Autographed Football W/ Jsa Loa Brown Gain Kelly MillerBrian Dawkins Philadelphia Eagles Signed White Logo Football SiPeyton Manning - Nfl Legend - Autographed Football Jg & Steiner CoaRay Lewis Autographed Super Bowl Xxxv Game Football W/sb 35 Mvp InscriptionDwight Clark Signed Autographed 49ers Nfl Football W/play Diagram Psa #w34115 Tom Brady Signed Duke Football Nfl New England PatriotsJadeveon Clowney South Carolina Signed Wilson Official-size Football Psa/dnaJack Ham Signed Penn State Nittany Lions Logo Football Hof 90 Jsa ItpDwight Clark Signed Autographed 49ers Nfl Football W/play Diagram Psa #w34116 Riley Cooper Signed Philadelphia Eagles Brown Logo Football Jsa ItpArchie #8, Eli #10 & Peyton #18 Manning Signed Full Size Nfl Football W/case Troy Aikman Signed Football Nfl Official Wilson Super Bowl Xxvii ( 27 ) CowboysWilson Nfl Pro Football Brett Favre Autograph With Excellent Coa Mint ConditionRoger Staubach Dallas Cowboys Signed W/ Hof Insc. Football Holo & Photo CoaPeyton Manning Colts / Denver Broncos Autographed Wilson FootballDeion Sanders 49ers / Cowboys Autographed Wilson FootballMichael Irvin Dallas Cowboys Autographed Wilson Football W/'playmaker' InscJack Ham Signed Pittsburgh Steelers Logo Football Hof 88 Jsa ItpRoger Staubach Hof 85 Autographed Wilson Football HologramRichard Sherman Earl Thoams & Kam Chancellor Sea Seahawks Signed Nfl FootballAutograph Michael Vick Football W/coa !!!!!!! Wow Must Buy!!!!!!!!!!!!Jerome Bettis Pittsburgh Steelers Autographed Wilson Football * SfsSigned Russell Wilson Super Bowl Champ Football2004 Pittsburgh Steelers Autographed Team Football Ben Roethlisberger Rookie Peyton Manning Denver Broncos Autographed Wilson FootballPeyton Manning Rare Indianapolis Colts Autographed Wilson Football * SfsSigned Autograph Nfl The Duke Authentic Football Montana, Elway, Aikman.Rob Gronkowski Autographed New England Patriots White-panel FootballSigned New England Patriots Tom Brady Football Autographed With Coa Nice!Dwight Clark Signed Autographed 49ers Nfl Football W/play Diagram Psa #w34112 Boomer Esiason Single Signed Baseball Auto Psa/dna Coa Jets Bengals Andy Dalton Autographed Nfl Football With Coa From Psa/dna Bengals Tcu FrogsRiley Cooper Signed/autographed Florida Gators White Logo Football SiTeam Signed New England Patriots 9 Autographed Signed Full Size Football W/coaJulian Edelman New England Patriots Autographed Wilson FootballNdamukong Suh Detroit Lions Autographed Signed Full Size Football W/coaAaron Hernandez New England Patriots Autographed Wilson Football W/go Pats InscRoger Staubach Dallas Cowboys Autographed Wilson Football W/hof 85 InscriptionVintage Team Issued Wisconsin Badgers FootballBrett Favre #4 Autographed / Signed Nfl Official Wilson Football ~ Packers ! CoaTedy Bruschi New England Patriots Rare Autographed Wilson FootballDan Marino Miami Dolphins Signed Football Ball Holo & Photo CoaMike Ditka Signed Chicago Bears White Signature Ball W/jsa Coa!!Signed Desean Jackson Redskins Nfl Full Size Football Autographed W/coaJack Lambert Pittsburgh Steelers Autographed Wilson Football W/hof 90 InscAlabama Crimson Tide A.j. Mccarron & Coach Nick Saban/coaWilson Nfl Clay Matthews Signed Football Autographed Green BayBrian Urlacher Chicago Bears Nfl Football Hand Signed Wilson Football €Demaryius Thomas And Julius Thomas Signed Football Autograph BroncosTony Dorsett Dallas Cowboys Autographed Wilson FootballAaron Rodgers Green Bay Packers Signed Nfl FootballChicago Bears Hall Of Famer Gale Sayers Autographed Signed Football Fran Tarkenton Minnesota Vikings Autographed Wilson Football W/hof 86 Insc * SfsJerry Rice Sf San Francisco 49ers Hall Of Fame Mini Helmet Gtsm Dante Lavelli & Lou The Toe Groza Autographed Football Official Nfl Wilson Dan Marino Signed Nfl Full Size Football Auto Psa/dna Sticker Only Dolphins Hof