In baseball memorabilia, you wouldn’t collect a bat signed by a pitcher or a glove signed by a designated hitter. Well, some people probably would, but it’s more likely you’d want a baseball that had been autographed by a pitcher like Sandy Koufax or Nolan Ryan, or a bat that’s been signed by sluggers such as Hank Aaron or Willie Mays.

Similarly, the most collectible footballs are signed by the players who touched them the most. That’s why football memorabilia collectors usually look for footballs autographed by quarterbacks such as Joe Namath, John Elway, Joe Montana, and Johnny Unitas, or running backs from Jim Brown to Walter Payton. Receiver signatures are popular, too (Jerry Rice and Mike Wallace are favorites), but how do you account for the popularity of Troy Polamalu’s autograph on footballs? Maybe it’s because footballs rarely get past this exceptionally strong, strong safety.

In general, footballs signed by players of the last quarter century or so are commodities—forgeries and reproductions abound, so make sure yours comes with authentication you can trust. More rare are footballs whose signatures and pebbly pigskin surfaces are both vintage. Nineteenth-century footballs were melon-shaped, harkening to the sport’s lineage in this country from rugby. Spalding claims it manufactured the first American football in 1887, but even these were not as pointed at the ends as footballs are today.

Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

Vintage Football Card Gallery

Vintage Football Card Gallery

This great database of pro and collegiate football cards from the 1950s and 1960s offers scanned images of cards fo… [read review or visit site]

Other Great Reference Sites

Most watched eBay auctions    

Peyton Manning Signed Td Pass Record Duke Football Auto /1000 Fanatic Hologram Tom Brady Signed Wilson Super Bowl Xxxvi Nfl Football Ne Patriots - TristarWalter Payton Signed Official Nfl Wilson Football (sgc Authentic & Psa/dna Coa)Calvin Johnson Detroit Lions Autographed Full Size Football With Coa GaRay Lewis Signed Super Bowl Xlvii Duke Football Auto Jsa Sticker Only RavensPeyton Manning Autograph/signed Denver Broncos Full-size Logo Football-ga CoaBo Jackson Signed Raiders Football (authenticated) Redskins Miami Sean Taylor Signed FootballRichard Sherman Signed Sb Xlviii Duke Football Auto 4417/5000 Mill Creek Coa2012 Chargers Signed Logo Football Philip Rivers Antonio Gates Psa CoaPeyton Manning Autographed Full Size Nfl Football Gai CoaSteelers Hof Terry Bradshaw Signed White Panel Nfl Football Psa CoaPeyton Manning & Eli Manning Autographed Football W/ Coa Nfl Mvp Broncos Giants!Marcus Mariota Signed / Inscribed "heisman 14" Duke Football Steiner Le 50Rob Gronkowski New England Patriots Autographed Full Size Football With Coa GaCalvin Johnson Detroit Lions Autographed Full Size Football W/coa GaSteve Young Signed Full Size Wilson Sb Xxix Football Auto Jsa Coa 49ers HofPeyton Manning Autopgraphed Football With The Sheriff Inscription Gai CoaPercy Harvin Signed Sb Xlviii Duke Football Auto 4978/5000 Mill Creek CoaDan Marino Brett Farve Autographed FootballPeyton Manning Autographed Football With "nfl Td Record 509" Inscription Gai CoaTerrell Davis Marshall Faulk Randall Cunningham Vinny Testeverde Signed FootballBrett Favre Signed Wilson Nfl Football Packers W/coa No ReserveWalter Payton Autographed FootballOfficial Junior Size Nfl Dan Marino Autographed Football #'d To 343 L@@k!!!!Leroy Kelly Full Size Nfl Football Signed Autograph Auto Cleveland Browns JsaPeyton Manning Signed Baseball Auto Fanatics Auth Hologram Only Colts Broncos Antonio Brown Signed Autographed Pittsburgh Steelers Logo Football W/jsa WitnessNavorro Bowman Signed Full Size Duke Football Auto Psa/dna Sticker OnlyJohnny Manziel Autograph/signed Cleveland Browns Full-size Logo Football-ga CoaPaul Hornung Signed Auto Wilson Official Nfl Football Hof 86 Si AutographedLawrence Taylor Signed Full Size Wilson Football Auto Jsa Coa Ny Giants HofRob Gronkowski New England Patriots Autographed Full Size Football W/coa GaRyan Tannehill Autographed Miami Dolphins Logo Football W/coaWillie Mcginest Patriots Browns Signed Replica Football Jsa Holo Coa Psa/dnaAndrew Luck Autographed Full Size Nfl Football Gai CoaAaron Rodgers Signed / Autographed Nfl Football!!! - Green Bay Packers!!! Mvp!!!Colin Kaepernick Sf 49ers Autographed Wilson Nfl Football !!!! Antoine Bethea Auto Autograph Signed San Francisco 49ers Logo Football (b)Colts Adam Vinatieri Signed Autographed Football Kicking Tee 1/1 Superbowl Dan Marino Signed FootballEmmitt Smith Autographed FootballRussell Wilson Signed Superbowl Football W/coa And Custom CaseLeveon Bell Signed Autographed Pittsburgh Steelers Logo Football W/ Jsa WitnessJoe Namath Autographed Football With CoaMarcus Wheaton Signed Autographed Pittsburgh Steelers Logo Football W/ Jsa WitDrew Brees Autographed Nfl Football!!! New Orleans Saints!!! Signed!!! Purdue!!!Roger Staubach #12 Autographed Nfl Wilson Football HologramOfficial Nfl Autographed Football Champ Bailey Denver Broncos Coa L@@k!!!!!Daryle Lamonica Signed Autographed Wilson Nfl Football Psa/dna Oakland RaidersLawrence Taylor/harry Carson Autographed Football Global Certed & Display CaseEagles Autographed Football (signed By The Whole 2001 Team)Drew Brees Autographed FootballBarry Sanders Autographed FootballSuper Bowl Xix Game Football #/1000 - 49ers Dolphins Dan Marino Autograph UdaAwesome Lawrence Taylor & Marshall Faulk & Eric Dickerson Autographed FootballReggie Wayne Signed Nfl Football *colts Wilson Authentic Ball New In Box 2014 Pittsburgh Steelers Team Signed Full Size Super Bowl Champions FootballJimmy Graham Seattle Seahawks Signed Autographed Football Ga Gai CoaTerrell Davis Marshall Faulk Randall Cunningham Vinny Testeverde Signed Football