Share your favorites on Show & Tell

HECKERT AND LOETZ DESIGNS: AN INTRIGUING COMPARISON

In Art Glass > Bohemian Art Glass > Show & Tell and Art Glass > Loetz Art Glass > Show & Tell.
Art Glass6424 of 9471one of the common onesGunnel Sahlin for Kosta Boda ( 1954 - )
13
Love it
0
Like it

LondonloetzlearnerLondonloetzlearner loves this.
forewhalesforewhales loves this.
miKKoChristmas11miKKoChristmas11 loves this.
inkyinky loves this.
ozmartyozmarty loves this.
czechmanczechman loves this.
LoetzBuddiesLoetzBuddies loves this.
AmberRoseAmberRose loves this.
magdalenagirlmagdalenagirl loves this.
bratjddbratjdd loves this.
Slave-to-glassSlave-to-glass loves this.
manddmoirmanddmoir loves this.
vetraio50vetraio50 loves this.
See 11 more
Add to collection

Please create an account, or Log in here

If you don't have an account, create one here.


Create a Show & TellReport as inappropriate



Posted 2 years ago

Email

Alfredo
(507 items)

Long before I knew what my Silberband ribbon bowl was (pic. 1), I was aware of the Loetz Hoffstätter design 351-Phan 3777, that bore a striking similarity to its shape (pic. 2). The actual vase appears in Loetz books, since it was made for the Paris 1900 Exhibition.

I was also conscious that mine appeared in other sizes and other decors, all from the Silberband family, including a version in cobalt blue. As usual, they are marketed as Loetz. It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for market misattributions to be corrected.

Now, however, Stephania Zelenko, the Passau Museum curator, has uncovered a similar design in a Heckert book (pic. 3), which raises all kinds of interesting questions.

Given the level of manufacturing incest among Czech glass companies during this period, it would be foolish to speak of plagiarism or piracy. All I can say is that, except for the lip, to my eyes my bowl looks more like the Loetz design than the Heckert's at least in the elongation of the body. Judge for yourself.

ADDENDUM: I found the Loetz 351 (now pic. 4). PMC IV:30, No lips, no dimples.

Comments

  1. Alfredo Alfredo, 2 years ago
    I can already hear the howls from glass pundits . . . .
  2. manddmoir manddmoir, 2 years ago
    Chances are they both saw the same shape in the British museum. The base on the Loetz drawing looks a lot smaller than the Heckert drawing -for my eye the examples match the Heckert closer. Fascinating. I notice a lot of the Heckert designs come with fancy or plain tops. I guess it was easy to modify the tops after the main shaping. I think we are going to be desperately trying to work out the implications of this Heckert book for some time. Fun!
  3. Alfredo Alfredo, 2 years ago
    OK. What British Museum? Pottery or glass? Yesterday we saw a Dresser design in pottery at the Met that Loetz modified--the quite common twisted vases (I have 5 of them) that look like a woman's squirt. In fact, I bought my very first because it looked like the squirt of a woman in my Bisquit-Lefevre Mucha poster.
  4. Slave-to-glass Slave-to-glass, 2 years ago
    Im still laughing at 'manufacturing incest' :) Good way to describe it LOL
  5. Alfredo Alfredo, 2 years ago
    Check it out: I found the Loetz vase in the PMC and posted it. I like the shape on mine better.
  6. dlfd911 dlfd911, 2 years ago
    I have seen vases that might be considered to look like a woman's "squirt", but the ones you speak of look like a skirt. I think that's what you meant there Al. :)
  7. Alfredo Alfredo, 2 years ago
    Oh God. I've been dealing with research on edible squirts as late as yesterday morning!
  8. Greatsnowyowl Greatsnowyowl, 2 years ago
    Whew, skirts.. I was trying to wrap my head around that.. LOL. I was all, what's he going on about womens squirts for?
  9. dlfd911 dlfd911, 2 years ago
    That would be more like a Rorschach test, no? I love a bit of humor over my first cup of coffee. Thanks Alfredo!
  10. vetraio50 vetraio50, 2 years ago
    The 'Propeller' vase for Ault? I was too late for me here in Oz!
  11. dasullywon dasullywon, 2 years ago
    This is great stuff! Al; does this mean my "blue striped" vase is also Heckert? It is the same one shown on your site (or the other Kralik site, I'm not sure which); and I posted it earlier with the red cardiac vase and the sea urchin (all as "Kralik"). It is similar to the silberband decor. (:No wonder people just call it all "Loetz" and don't bother with the details; what, with all the incest going on who can tell?:)

Want to post a comment?

Create an account or login in order to post a comment.