Share your favorites on Show & Tell

BOHEMIAN EXPORT: RUCKL OR OTHER

In Art Glass > Bohemian Art Glass > Show & Tell.
Art Nouveau1 of 1429Art Nouveau FAIRY LADY French Majolica VaseMy Friend item.....
17
Love it
0
Like it

SEAN68SEAN68 loves this.
czechmanczechman loves this.
charcoalcharcoal loves this.
tom61375tom61375 loves this.
Moonstonelover21Moonstonelover21 loves this.
mikelv85mikelv85 loves this.
epson233epson233 loves this.
AlfredoAlfredo loves this.
JustanoviceJustanovice loves this.
Lisa-lightingLisa-lighting loves this.
ozmartyozmarty loves this.
inkyinky loves this.
scottvezscottvez loves this.
dlfd911dlfd911 loves this.
antiques-in-njantiques-in-nj loves this.
vetraio50vetraio50 loves this.
See 15 more
Add to collection

Please create an account, or Log in here

If you don't have an account, create one here.


Create a Show & TellReport as inappropriate



Posted 1 year ago

Email

LeahGoodwin
(128 items)

After a another year of research, this posting has been revised due to research evolving.

I have come to the conclusion on the Welz and Ruckl debate, that honestly we will NEVER know who made what until proper documentation is available.

The majority of the research that has been done is by taking a documented shape and using the decor to match with other shapes that are not documented.

Unfortunately, I don't believe this research works because we are finding many Bohemian glass companies produced the same thing.

It is important to understand the majority of the research that is done on Ruckl and Welz is EMPIRICAL research which means it's an opinion given and not based on theory or fact.

I was very lucky to have a conversation with Deb Truitt in regards to the Ruckl/Welz debate. She explained, "The problem comes when extrapolating from a known to an unknown piece. We don't have enough documentation yet to differentiate among pieces from different companies. It was a business for the glass makers, and they made what the markets wanted so many pieces are similar. So, yes, call things Bohemian until we have documentation."

My intentions for this post is to help collectors understand if you are going to rely on empirical research, be prepared to change your mind often about attributions.

Please keep in mind, if you take a documented shape and find other shapes in the same matching decor, Welz , Ruckl and Harrach will bump into each other with this type of glass.

As another example: Take a documented Loetz Tango piece in red with a black rim, and match other shapes that are red with the black trim on the rim, collector's will find more than one glass maker was producing the same thing or let's say the collector is not aware Bohemian glass companies were copying off each other, and glass was matched by decor, the collector would think it was produced by one maker which is not true.

Sorry to say... but the Welz, and Ruckl attributions are not 100% correct. So I'm taking the advice I was given by calling it Bohemian and adding Export, because more than one company was producing the same type of glass and there is practically NO documented proof to know who made what when it comes to this type of glass.

HERE IS THE ORIGINAL POSTING:
Same shaped vase in different colors. The Ruckl vase in the center is a 12" and the other two are around 9" tall. All three vases have a design shift in the applied decor at the footed base. No applied riagree on the other two vases as well. Rims are cut and no pontil on the base.

The new Ruckl decor to introduce is yellow marble and is a very common variation to find in many different shapes. The other decor is pink and green aventurine with splashes of oxblood red. If the two vases were taller they would appear longer at the bulbous section of the vase as seen in the 12".

BTW: All three vases have a different colour interior casing. Numbers match by order of photos.

1. Translucent Yellow
2. Opaque Red
3. Opaque White

Please... if anyone has a shape to share, post your example. I would love to see what you have and so would others who have interest on the subject! :) The more decors found in this shape will open doors for the possibilities to be associated with Ruckl. Even other shapes will help further research.

More to follow of same shapes with different decors...

Comments

  1. LeahGoodwin LeahGoodwin, 1 year ago
    Thanks, Sean. I always appreciate your comments and loves. Can't wait to show more. :) Have a great day.
  2. LeahGoodwin LeahGoodwin, 1 year ago
    Thanks, Kevin, Scott B, Dave, Gary and Scott for the loves.
  3. Alfredo Alfredo, 1 year ago
    And in case anyone doubts they are Ruckl. These are all "Victorian" Ruckl, competing with both harrach and Welz for the British market.
  4. LeahGoodwin LeahGoodwin, 1 year ago
    Thanks, Inky - Oz - Lisa - Al and Just a novice for the love... :)
  5. PhilDavidAlexanderMorris PhilDavidAlexanderMorris, 1 year ago
    Really find these fascinating, Love em, and Merry X-mas to you !~Phil.
  6. LeahGoodwin LeahGoodwin, 1 year ago
    Thanks, Phil. Love to hear the nice comments. Very kind.
    Happy Merry-Merry-Merry Christmas to you!!!
  7. epson233 epson233, 1 year ago
    very pretty leah -- thanks for the extra efforts you take to educate us on these items -- have a great weekend
  8. LeahGoodwin LeahGoodwin, 1 year ago
    Thanks, Autumn!!!! :)

Want to post a comment?

Create an account or login in order to post a comment.