In the art world, proofs are usually defined as prints made prior to an official production run. The goal of such proofs is to give artist and printer alike a sneak peek at the planned edition so they can fine tune colors, registration, and other crucial details. The resulting imperfect proofs are thus variants of the final product, although they are often collected as enthusiastically as prints in the final signed-and-numbered edition.
With U.S. coins, proofs are roughly the opposite. In fact, proof coins are not even considered a part of a coin’s overall production run since the methods used to create them are completely distinct from those used to make the coins themselves.
To begin, proof coins are struck with dies that have been carefully selected for their perfection. These dies are cleaned and polished throughout the production process. Similarly, the planchets or blanks that the dies strike are usually stamped out of highly polished metal sheets and then hand fed into the press. Proofs are typically struck twice so that their features exhibit sharp relief, from their edges to their portraits, often with mirrorlike surfaces, or fields, in between.
Although some proofs were struck prior to 1856, many of these coins are museum pieces, which is why most collectors focus their attention on proofs minted between 1856 and 1916, 1936 and 1942, 1950 and 1964, and 1968 until the present day. The date of 1936 is significant because that was when the Mint began to actively market proof sets to the public in addition to individual proof coins.
In general, there are three types of proofs. The most desirable kind is known as a frosted or cameo proof. Coins of this type have the classic mirrorlike fields, which are interrupted by portraits and other devices that have a frosted appearance, which makes the contrast within the coin especially dramatic. The surface of matte proofs appears to have been sandblasted, while the so-called “brilliant” proofs have mirrorlike fields and portraits, giving them an overall shiny look.
Of the late-19th-century coins, some proofs are actually less prized than regularly minted coins of comparable grade. Examples of this anomaly include most proof quarters struck in Philadelphia between 1866 and 1891, especially in the earliest years. For most pre-1936 coins, proofs are more sought-after by collectors than their uncirculated counterparts. Matte Buffalo nickels from 1913 to 1916 are a good example of the value placed on proof coins, as are most Barber dimes from 1892 to 1915.
World War I put the brakes on proofs, but it’s unclear why it took Mint officials 20 years to get the program going again. Whatever the reason—some blame bureaucratic inertia, ot...
Another world war halted the release of proof sets until 1950, when the Mint raised the price of a set from $1.89 to $2.10 while more than doubling production. Retail prices for the sets, which included the same five denominations as the 1936-1942 sets and were now packed in Pliofilm, held steady through 1964, but the Mint had noticed how buyers had been snapping up its sets and selling them for a fast profit. So, in 1968, it began to pack its proof sets in plastic holders and raised the price to $5.
Higher prices combined with radically increased productions runs (three million was not uncommon after 1961) conspired to suck the air out of the proof-set market. Especially hard hit were the top-of-the-line Prestige Sets, which in most cases are actually worth less today than what collectors paid for them when issued—the notable exceptions being the 1983S set with an Olympic dollar and the 1990S set missing an S cent. Proof sets that appear to have held their own include the five-piece state quarter sets issued since 1999 (that first set has proved most popular among collectors).
One final bit of terminology to pay attention to is the word prooflike, which describes a regularly minted, uncirculated coin with a mirrorlike surface. Some of the most dramatic examples of prooflike coins are Morgan dollars minted at the end of the 19th century. In some cases, the prooflike coin will have valuations well into five or six figures (the 1894 and 1901 Morgans, respectively), while proof coins from those same years can be picked up for four.
Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)
Legendary Coins and Currency
Society of U.S. Pattern Collectors
Clubs & Associations
- Society of U.S. Pattern Collectors
- American Numismatic Association
- American Numismatic Society
- Numismatic Bibliomania Society
Other Great Reference Sites
Most watched eBay auctions
Recent News: US Proof Coins
Source: Google News
Perth Mint Releases Silver Proof Coins for Anniversaries of WW I & II BattlesCoin Update News, February 8th
The reverse of the 2016 Be Worthy of Them 1 Ounce Silver Proof Coin carries an image of soldiers climbing up from the trenches in France's Somme Valley during the Battle of the Somme. The battle-marked sky is rendered in color, as is a small image of a ...Read more
Eagle cent realizes $15k+: Market Analysis| Coin WorldCoin World, February 8th
This 1858 Flying Eagle, Large Letters cent graded Proof 65 sold for $15,275 at Heritage's FUN auction in Tampa. Original images courtesy of Heritage Auctions. Second of three segments from Steve Roach highlighting Proof coins from the Kling Family ...Read more
Proof 65 half dime sells for $1028: Market Analysis | Coin WorldCoin World, February 6th
6 to 11 auctions held during the Florida United Numismatists show in Tampa included an important collection of these generally gorgeous and low-mintage coins. The Kling Family Collection of Proof coins was put together over many years and here are...Read more
Almost $100k for Morgan dollar: Market Analysis | Coin WorldCoin World, February 5th
In a general sense, the market has cooled recently for 19th century Proof type coins, though key issues remain popular with buyers. Heritage's Jan. 6 to 11 auctions held during the Florida United Numismatists show in Tampa included an important...Read more
Mark Twain Silver Dollar Sales at 43600CoinNews.net, February 4th
The proof with its unique degrees of frosting is outselling the other silver dollar with its standard uncirculated finish by 2.6-to-1, having sales splits of 31,500 and 12,100. Released on Monday, the two commemorative coins are available at...Read more
2016 Mark Twain Silver Dollars LaunchCoinNews.net, February 1st
Earlier today, Feb. 1, the United States Mint started taking orders for 2016 Mark Twain Commemorative Silver Dollars. Available in proof and uncirculated qualities, these collector coins feature imagery emblematic of Samuel Clemens, the famous American ...Read more
2016 Mark Twain Gold Coin Photos, Proof Features 3 Frosting LevelsCoinNews.net, January 29th
Regular proof coins have frosted designs that contrast attractively against mirror-like backgrounds, just like the obverse or heads side of the proof Mark Twain gold coin. The reverse or tails side of this same coin, however, features two additional...Read more
2016 America the Beautiful Quarters Released in Proof SetCoinNews.net, January 11th
CoinNews visited the San Francisco Mint to watch 2016-dated proof coins produced and packaged. We will talk more about their new packaging system in an upcoming article. Earlier, we ran image-centric articles on this year's quarters and included names ...Read more