Share your favorites on Show & Tell

quasi-antique sterling flatware

In Silver > Sterling Silver Flatware > Show & Tell.
Silver2390 of 24021835 R. WallaceMunger Family Antique Silver Tea Service
Love it
Like it

Add to collection

Please create an account, or Log in here

If you don't have an account, create one here.

Create a Show & TellReport as inappropriate

Posted 7 years ago


(1 item)

I need the cash, but I'm clueless about whether this sterling flatware ought to be valued for more than its melt value. I'm told that's the case for but a minority of pieces. I bought these in a low rent antique district in London circa 1980. Botton of stem is different on spoons than on forks; hallmarks are discernable via zoom. Help a body decide?

Unsolved Mystery

Help us close this case. Add your knowledge below.


  1. Savoychina1 Savoychina1, 7 years ago

    This is a great website but it takes some persistence to unravel. The second set of halmarks tells you this was made in Sheffield by M&W. the fact that it is on this website tells me it is sterling and not plate. Let us know what you discover !
  2. donnyork, 7 years ago
    I have the flatware here with me; I posted it here with my own digital photos. Still wondering whether to avoid selling a portion instead of the whole set together for its additional "antique" value.
  3. Savoychina1 Savoychina1, 7 years ago
    I would find a reputable Jeweler in your area and get a scrap price. Since the pieces don't match it isn't a "set".f you watch "Pawn Stars" he generally offers 25% of an appraisal or less. Good luck.

    Also, visit a couple of pawn shops or antique stors to see what the "retail " price is.
  4. Dragonmum Dragonmum, 7 years ago
    Usually best to sell sets by the piece. People rarely want to pay for a set - they are usually looking for a piece or two missing from their old set. and Yes, the value of silver flat wear is higher than meltdown. Replacements might buy it, but they'll only give you a small percent. Have you tried to sell on Craig's list? Once you have a good idea about price, cut it in half & see what happens. Things sell pretty quickly on CL.
  5. flea, 7 years ago
    DM: I haven't had much luck selling on CL.. I agree about selling by the piece. Especially the extras like ladles or cake servers. What city CL do you use?
  6. Dragonmum Dragonmum, 7 years ago
    I live in the Raleigh/Durham NC area. I suggest CL because it's pretty much a no-lose situation. Since it's free, you might as well try. I have some friends who have Bonanzle booths - it's free to list there & tiny selling fee - plus they have a feature for arranging local pick-up. They list on CL with a link back to the booth that allows people to pay with Google Checkout(much lower fees) or Paypal (your preference; I think PP is evil). If people know they have an option to pay with a credit card, it may improve your ability to sell. My shop is on hold right now, so I haven't set up a CL/Bonanzle connection.

    Replacements will look at it, but they'll only pay a fraction of retail.
  7. Lee Sayer, 7 years ago
    You are right on Replacements pricing,I have some Roseville dishes that I talked to them about,they sent me a list of what they would pay.It wouldn't cover the packing material that I would have to use.I didn't expect retail,everyone has to make a profit but needless to say I still have my dishes.

Want to post a comment?

Create an account or login in order to post a comment.