Share your favorites on Show & Tell

Two similar brooches, Arts and Crafts style

In Fine Jewelry > Brooches > Show & Tell.
Brooches390 of 887Shipton or German Arts and Crafts inspired citrine silver brooch.Cased antique micromosaic beetle gold stickpin. Kyratised!
33
Love it
1
Like it

PhilDMorrisPhilDMorris loves this.
MALKEYMALKEY loves this.
HollyhocksHollyhocks loves this.
NewfldNewfld loves this.
Bettyb00Bettyb00 loves this.
SEAN68SEAN68 loves this.
sklo42sklo42 loves this.
antiqueroseantiquerose loves this.
OneGoodFindOneGoodFind loves this.
davyd286davyd286 likes this.
VintageforeverVintageforever loves this.
BudekBudek loves this.
ElisabethanElisabethan loves this.
Rick55Rick55 loves this.
valentino97valentino97 loves this.
pops52pops52 loves this.
bracken3bracken3 loves this.
fleafinderfleafinder loves this.
kivatinitzkivatinitz loves this.
NevadaBladesNevadaBlades loves this.
inkyinky loves this.
vetraio50vetraio50 loves this.
martikamartika loves this.
CaperkidCaperkid loves this.
PostCardCollectorPostCardCollector loves this.
pebblepebble loves this.
Peasejean55Peasejean55 loves this.
freiheitfreiheit loves this.
TassieDevilTassieDevil loves this.
EfesgirlEfesgirl loves this.
melaniejmelaniej loves this.
auraaura loves this.
mikelv85mikelv85 loves this.
jscott0363jscott0363 loves this.
See 32 more
Add to collection

    Please create an account, or Log in here

    If you don't have an account, create one here.


    Create a Show & TellReport as inappropriate


    Posted 5 years ago

    racer4four
    (619 items)

    These two wonderful silver brooches look very similar but in fact have a number of differences.

    Please excuse my descriptions: I'm not on top of the correct terms for jewellery parts and styles yet!

    The green stone brooch (stone unknown) is bezel set, with a patterned ring around the bezel.
    The leaves are on a single small stem with one berry between them.
    It has an upright hinge and simple C catch.
    It has STERLING in tiny letters stamped on the back of the frame but no other stamps.

    The brown stone (chalcedony?) brooch has a prong set stone. The leaves are on individual stems and two small berries on their own stems are between the leaves. It has a flat hinge and safety clasp.
    It has no stamps that I could find but tests as silver.

    I love them both and have worn them alone and together.

    Who made them? Some would say Instone but perhaps these are also from Shipton and Co like my blue ring. Perhaps someone else.

    I'm happy to hear any comments or directions thanks friends and jewellery lovers.

    logo
    Brooches
    See all
    Antique Deco Diamond 18.81ct Aquamarine Platinum Gold Brooch Pin 13.7 Grams NR
    Antique Deco Diamond 18.81ct Aquama...
    $1,742
    Vintage Diamond 7.11ct Opal 18K Gold Flower Bouquet Cluster Pin 20.3 Grams NR
    Vintage Diamond 7.11ct Opal 18K Gol...
    $570
    Vintage Style Fashion Chameleon Brooch Rhinestone Party Pins Women Jewelry Gift
    Vintage Style Fashion Chameleon Bro...
    $4
    Vintage Jomaz Blue Green Rhinestone Domed Gold Tone brooch
    Vintage Jomaz Blue Green Rhinestone...
    $12
    logo
    Antique Deco Diamond 18.81ct Aquamarine Platinum Gold Brooch Pin 13.7 Grams NR
    Antique Deco Diamond 18.81ct Aquama...
    $1,742
    See all

    Comments

    1. jscott0363 jscott0363, 5 years ago
      Karen,
      They're both pretty amazing looking.
    2. mikelv85 mikelv85, 5 years ago
      Great A&C brooches Karen...I like both too. Cabachons are my favorite over faceted stones. Unless they're diamonds of course. Nice to see you're delving into jewelry. I haven't been finding much since my friend quit at Salvation Army. I have plenty already but things will still catch my eye when they show up. So I haven't given up entirely. :)
    3. Jewels1900 Jewels1900, 5 years ago
      Hi Karen, the brown stone is actually orange carnelian. Kyra will know for sure.

      The brooch with a single berry is german. I know because I have a lovely little ring with a domed lapis in it by the same maker with German stamped on it. It has the same leaves with the little curl at the end & same bezel setting (which is also often seen on English jewellery of the same period).

      Not sure about the carnelian one, but I am sure neither of them are Instone or Shiptons.
    4. Efesgirl Efesgirl, 5 years ago
      I love them. :-))))
    5. TassieDevil TassieDevil, 5 years ago
      I love them both Karen, beautiful!!
    6. racer4four racer4four, 5 years ago
      Many thanks, as always, Scott for your comment and love.
    7. racer4four racer4four, 5 years ago
      It must be such a difference for you Mike not seeing and buying good jewellery, and lots of it, from your op shops. I'm sure some will appear soon knowing your touch!
      Thanks for the love here - I too prefer a cab!
    8. racer4four racer4four, 5 years ago
      Thanks again Jewels. German! - so interesting to me as a newby.
      It just shows that styles are transferred from region to region and although similar they can actually be very different. It happens a lot in my usual world of art glass.
      I am not concerned about knowing who made my jewellery, just interested, so the info you give me is great thanks.
      Carnelian - that's probably what I meant.....lol.
    9. racer4four racer4four, 5 years ago
      Ohhh thanks Bonnie, oh Queen of Silvery Things!!
    10. racer4four racer4four, 5 years ago
      Thanks too Judy :)
    11. freiheit freiheit, 5 years ago
      I like to see the two brooches side-by-side. This way one can really make out the differences:)
    12. pebble pebble, 5 years ago
      They're lovely! Could the green stone be aventurine?
    13. Gillian, 5 years ago
      These are lovely. There's been a lot of A&C items here lately, which is just fine by me. The conversations about the items are really interesting. Reading Jewels and Jean's excellent knowledge, (and others of course-the Australian connections) and the questions posed are fascinating. Truly. Yesterday I went on a Shipton exploration - I enjoy learning about all the history, and the research being done here.

      Thanks for posting these racer4four.
    14. PostCardCollector PostCardCollector, 5 years ago
      mmmmmm.Those are GOOD!
    15. Jewels1900 Jewels1900, 5 years ago
      Hi Karen, the Germans were the powerhouse of art jewellery during this period. In addition to the schools & artist colonies who taught and made hand-made jewellery, they also had one of the larger jewellery manufacturing centres and also a major stone cutting & polishing centre.

      They exported jewellery and gems all around the world. They made Anglo-German jewellery for he English market, Nouveau jewellery for the French market and Jungendstil jewellery for the German market. In addition to producing a lot of non-art jewellery for those markets.

      Firms like Farhner had different departments or lines of jewellery. Hand-made art jewellery which was exhibited at the Paris Salons & other major exhibits, a machine-made (but artist designed) range for the art minded & emerging middle classes and a base metal line which was entirely mass produced (& often unmarked). They employed some of the best german designers of the period.

      Other German firms were like the Zara of the period. They subscribed to the catalogues of the Paris Salon exhibits and copied those artist designed pieces. No one knows if they actually bought the rights to them but it was not unusual for a french designer to have their designs made up by a well known french maker, then have variations made by German firms. Usually they are all slightly different variations of the same design. So I often see German jewellery misattributed as being French or, sometimes, English.

      Collecting German jewellery of this period is really interesting, I've bought some beautiful pieces recently. I post them when I've got a mo.

      Also, I have some more info on your brooches which I will post later.

      PS, the enamel butterfly on my posts is German. I love plique (transparent) enamelling and while it is most commonly associated with French jewellery (the name plique-a-jour is French), it was mostly produced by German firms.
    16. racer4four racer4four, 5 years ago
      Freiheit, thank you. It is good to have a ready comparison!

      Pebble it may well be and I will look that up. I admit to huge gaps in my knowledge re stones. Thanks for that!
    17. racer4four racer4four, 5 years ago
      It's awesome isn't it Gillian to see so much and learn from generous people here on CW.
      All this jewellery is new to me so I'm learning from every comment.
      Thanks for your comment!
    18. racer4four racer4four, 5 years ago
      Jewels you are a generous sharer of your knowledge and an asset to us all here.

      I always thought your plique-a-jour brooch French.....I will now need to keep my mind more open. Fascinating info about the Germans and when I get more time (work is mad at the moment) I will read more. In the meantime I will enjoy the posts and comments from everyone.
    19. inky inky, 5 years ago
      These are lovely, so wearable...:-)
    20. racer4four racer4four, 5 years ago
      They are Inky! Thanks ;))
    21. NevadaBlades, 5 years ago
      Bet you look fabulous wearing these. [;>)
    22. kivatinitz kivatinitz, 5 years ago
      lovely broochs and very interesting comments
    23. kyratango kyratango, 5 years ago
      Whoaah! 2 brooches!!!

      The green stone is amazonite, and the red is indeed carnelian.

      I'd say Shipton for both, but Jewels1900 is the referee in this area of jewellery!!! :-)

      The design of setting and fittings evolved, Shipton still make a Arts and crafts inspired line, see there:
      http://www.shiptonandco.com/brooches-c10/arts-crafts-inspired-cornelian-brooch-p2655

      http://www.shiptonandco.com/brooches-c10/malachite-brooch-p2820

      Another amazonite so similar to yours (wrongly described as chrysoprase):
      http://www.ebay.fr/itm/302068416257?_trksid=p2055119.m1438.l2649&ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT

      I have a citrine one (marked silver too) that i'll post now for showing how versatile it can be :-)
    24. kyratango kyratango, 5 years ago
      Here it is!
      http://www.collectorsweekly.com/stories/205165-shipton-or-german-arts-and-crafts-inspir?in=user
    25. valentino97 valentino97, 5 years ago
      Great research on these 2 gorgeous pins.
    26. Jewels1900 Jewels1900, 5 years ago
      Ohh Kyra. That Shipton reference is a find. I think that answers the question as to why these brooches are so similar but slightly different. Looking at the new Shipton version, it is has a roll clasp. All period brooches have a c clasp. Also, malachite is not period.

      So, I'd say Karen's brooch with the ammonite is period (which has the same leaf as my ring). And the carnelian with the roll clasp is a modern Shipton version.

      It's interesting because I've not noted these brooches with the roll clasp. It's possible I've not looked at them more recently though.
    27. Jewels1900 Jewels1900, 5 years ago
      Karen, you're in luck. I got out my jewels today to consider something Paul recently told me so I dug out my German ring & some pieces of Shipton which I'll post for you so keep an eye out.

      Also my plique butterfly is a buckle. I also took some photos of my plique, keep an eye open for my new bit of plique which I'll post later tonight. I'll include a photo so you'll get an idea of how big it is.
    28. racer4four racer4four, 5 years ago
      Thanks KJ and Kivantiz for the love.

      Valentino I am awed at the knowledge and information shown here.
    29. racer4four racer4four, 5 years ago
      Kyra thanks so much for your searching and references, and it makes so much sense.
      So I have a vintage ammonite brooch from Germany, and a newer carnelian brooch from Shipton and Co.
      You and Jewels are fantastic!
      Thanks so much; so interesting!!
    30. racer4four racer4four, 5 years ago
      Thanks again Jewels. I'm looking forward to your posts!
    31. kyratango kyratango, 5 years ago
      Karen, the green stone is amazonite, ammonite is an opalised shell :-)
      Perhaps a auto correct bug ;-)
    32. racer4four racer4four, 5 years ago
      I hope it was Kyra, maybe just dopiness :)

    33. OneGoodFind OneGoodFind, 5 years ago
      You deserve all the loves and information here. You give so much to others. No doubt you will catch on quickly!! Smart as a whip you are. (Is that the right accent)? ;)
    34. racer4four racer4four, 5 years ago
      Yeah mate! All good. Thanks OGF for that lovely comment.
    35. antiquerose antiquerose, 5 years ago
      Wow Stunning post Karen .....and the Info !! Congrats to you
    36. racer4four racer4four, 5 years ago
      It's been a great response thanks Rose!
    37. sklo42 sklo42, 5 years ago
      These are simply beautiful, Karen.

    Want to post a comment?

    Create an account or login in order to post a comment.