Share your favorites on Show & Tell

Hattie Carnegie Mermaid - True Vintage vs Reproduction

In Costume Jewelry > Hattie Carnegie Jewelry > Show & Tell and Costume Jewelry > Costume Brooches > Show & Tell.
amykathleen66's loves10 of 17My Great great grandfather's mugEgg with mouse and cat and topaz and amesyth
Love it
Like it

Ms.CrystalShipMs.CrystalShip loves this.
funbananaafunbananaa loves this.
tom61375tom61375 loves this.
fortheloveofdogfortheloveofdog loves this.
sarahoffsarahoff loves this.
Moonstonelover21Moonstonelover21 loves this.
amykathleen66amykathleen66 loves this.
lisalisa loves this.
jrfm410jrfm410 loves this.
clockermanclockerman loves this.
ivanb2kivanb2k loves this.
AmberRoseAmberRose loves this.
See 11 more
Add to collection

    Please create an account, or Log in here

    If you don't have an account, create one here.

    Create a Show & TellReport as inappropriate

    Posted 8 years ago

    (1 item)

    Lets share views on posted examples of Mermaid brooch, unsigned but attributed to Hattie Carnegie. Brooches in examples numbered 2-4 are clearly different from the first one, so basically we are looking at two types of this brooch. One is original vintage, the other one is a more or less recent reproduction - so which one in your opinion is vintage?

    Unsolved Mystery

    Help us close this case. Add your knowledge below.

    Hattie Carnegie Jewelry
    See all
    Vintage Hattie Carnegie Poured royal blue Glass butterfly Pin Brooch
    Vintage Hattie Carnegie Poured roya...
    Vtg Hattie Carnegie Lion Pearl Enamel Brooch/Pendant For Repair As Is
    Vtg Hattie Carnegie Lion Pearl Enam...
    VINTAGE Hattie Carnegie STYLE ladybug faux pearl head/wings-green eyes-NOS
    VINTAGE Hattie Carnegie STYLE ladyb...
    Vintage Hattie Carnegie Poured royal blue Glass butterfly Pin Brooch
    Vintage Hattie Carnegie Poured roya...
    See all


    1. Newtimes Newtimes, 8 years ago
      nr 1 is the original. It appears to have a better finish and more details than nr 2, 3 and 4. But I'm no expert.
    2. AmberRose AmberRose, 8 years ago
      Just for variety...because I don't know...I am going with 3 as the original.
    3. davyd286, 8 years ago
      If I wanted to buy one to wear, I would have picked #1 because it's more detailed, even though it looks to me most recent of the four. Could it be a museum store piece? The other three look like they may have come from the same mold but the back is finished differently on #2.
    4. kindy kindy, 8 years ago
      While #1 has more defined features, it also looks more recent and from cheaper materials. I honestly have no clue but I'm tossing up between #3 and #4. Don't leave us hanging too long, I'm keen to know... ;)
    5. ivanb2k, 8 years ago
      I had #1 brooch recently that I purchased from a women that had literally minimum 100 pieces.. Mainly Kenneth Jay Lane but also numerous Carnegie pieces.. I had listed this brooch on Ebay and had it knocked off twice.. The first time I had it listed as Unsigned Hattie Carnegie and the second time after speaking with Ebay and listing it per their suggestion had it knocked off again.. I will say that the detail is amazing as is the color.. I will have to say #1
    6. stefdesign stefdesign, 8 years ago
      I think #3 looks the most elegant, and all of the elements seem to fit together better than the others.
    7. ivanb2k, 8 years ago
      So when do you finally say which is the real one..??
    8. sammytheopulenthippo sammytheopulenthippo, 8 years ago
      Oooh, this is a tough one!
      I have never seen these pieces up-close, but I'd rule #1 out. From what I have seen so far, the Hattie Carnegie mermaid brooch does not have a well-defined facial features, and it does not hold a pearl.
      As for the other three, the gold plate finishing at the back of #2 and #4 looks rather rough while #3 seem to have the cleanest finish. I'd go with #3 as the original!
    9. vintagejewel vintagejewel, 8 years ago
      Number 2 or 3 as original
    10. jrfm410, 8 years ago
      don't u hate it when they don't post the answer! lol...even I want to know...which one is the REAL deal?
    11. jrfm410, 8 years ago
      I am guessing #4
    12. ivanb2k, 8 years ago
      Yes, I want to know too.. Will you answer which is real?? Or not..
    13. ivanb2k, 8 years ago
      Soooo.. Which one is the real one.. Or do you know???
    14. Wendep, 8 years ago
      I think it's # 3 or 4. To my knowledge the mermaid does not hold a pearl and her face is blank of expression. I'd like to be told as I am sure other's would which is the real.
    15. noliegirl, 8 years ago
      Look at the quality of #1. #1 has clear detail in the face, has strong detail in the hair, the fin and the shell. Now look at the backs. the back of #1 is consistent with signed brooches. And finally, look at the way the plastic components fit into the metal components. #1's components have a clean fit; the others do not. I believe that #1 is the original; it has a quality consistent with other marked Carnegie brooches.
    16. Ms.CrystalShip Ms.CrystalShip, 5 months ago
      A post such as this should be done on Weiss, with all the fakes out there.
      Also, one on contemporary vs. vintage KJL.

    Want to post a comment?

    Create an account or login in order to post a comment.