Share your favorites on Show & Tell

Old Snake oil?

In Bottles > Medicine Bottles > Show & Tell.
Medicine Bottles419 of 449New to the collection.... My Barber Shop Bathroom
Love it
Like it

tom61375tom61375 loves this.
AboundingOdditiesAboundingOddities loves this.
geekasaurusgeekasaurus likes this.
See 2 more
Add to collection

    Please create an account, or Log in here

    If you don't have an account, create one here.

    Create a Show & TellReport as inappropriate

    Posted 11 years ago

    (21 items)

    On the left, and frankly I'm not even sure how to pronounce it, is something called McElree's Cardui, alcohol 19% by volume. It's an unopened bottle, screw on lid, complete with directions on how to take, and it's in great shape. On the right is a bottle of Lydia E. Pinkham "Vegetable Compound", with 13 1/2% alcohol. That bottle has been, uh, "sampled" at some point, and it also has a screw on lid. I've dug around on the internet but can't find anything exactly like either of these, hoping some of you out there can help me.
    Can anyone advise me on the "worth" of these? I bought them at an estate sale.

    Unsolved Mystery

    Help us close this case. Add your knowledge below.

    Medicine Bottles
    See all
    Vintage 4
    Vintage 4" Cobalt Blue Maryland Gla...
    Vintage Glass Medicine Dispense Pour Cup 2 Tablespoons 8 Teaspoons 30 ML 1 Oz
    Vintage Glass Medicine Dispense Pou...
    Scarce & Mint O.P.
    Scarce & Mint O.P. "DUTCHERS DEAD S...
    Exceptional Condition O.P. Medicine:
    Exceptional Condition O.P. Medicine...
    Vintage 4
    Vintage 4" Cobalt Blue Maryland Gla...
    See all


    1. LS3232 LS3232, 11 years ago
      Below pertains to your items.

      "in 1880, a menstrual relief product, Dr. McELREE'S Wine of Cardui was introduced. It was said that Cardui was created as a rival to Lydia Pinkham's Vegetable Compound, "Female Complaints," which was the top product in the North. Cardui was composed chiefly of potassium carbonate (51.9 percent), salt (16 percent), and alcohol (20.3 percent). Wine of Cardui instantly became successful when more than 6,500 women reported being cured. According to the company's historical information, customers were so pleased with the new products Black-Draught and Cardui that the Chattanooga Medicine Company quickly became the biggest producer in the Chattanooga area."

    2. geekasaurus geekasaurus, 11 years ago
      those are in fabulous condition! i want to fondle the boxes :P
    3. AboundingOddities AboundingOddities, 9 years ago
      LS...fantastic info

      Vegetable compounds were often used as laxatives, but that isn't sat in stone for products back then. With the screw on lid, it could range from late 30's into the 50's...placing all terms in a search engine, even one at a time or as groupings, could give you further info. Many times there is 100% NO info available for these medicines. This one, being "sampled", but with complete box in great condition, and any paperwork that some have and some don't, you're looking at anywhere from $20 on up in value. The more you can discover, the more it could be worth to the collector of these.

      The more valuable one would be the Car-duew. The paperwork sometimes gives dates, or old adverts showing the same bottle and box. It looks like a tin screw-on lid. Eventhough these normally were from the 1920's and forward, screw-on lids have been around quite awhile before then, but most meds and snake oils had cork stoppers when much older than the 30's. Because of the look of box, bottle, and insert, and the...ummmm...cureative aspect of it, the value wouldn't be below $30, and should range higher with the right collector...that, however, is a best guesstimate

      Cool pieces

    Want to post a comment?

    Create an account or login in order to post a comment.