Share your favorites on Show & Tell

New Collector - Are the Melon Vases Fake or Authentic?

In Glassware > Fenton Glass > Show & Tell.
Fenton Glass363 of 611Fenton Glassware Hand MadeIs This a FENTON or IMPERIAL Vanity SET?
Love it
Like it

AmberRoseAmberRose loves this.
aghcollectaghcollect loves this.
JewelsJewels loves this.
Add to collection

    Please create an account, or Log in here

    If you don't have an account, create one here.

    Create a Show & TellReport as inappropriate

    Posted 7 years ago

    (1 item)

    I just received the two melon vases from a seller on eBay. The color is significantly different from the other white I have (shown for comparison purposes). I have one older piece from my mother-in-law and the few pieces I have collected are similar in color, so I know those are authentic. Could someone tell me if these melon vases are a knock off or just a different type of white Fenton I am not familiar with. Thank you so much.

    Unsolved Mystery

    Help us close this case. Add your knowledge below.

    Fenton Glass
    See all
    Vintage Fairy Lamp Candle Light Fenton Orange / Amber Hobnail
    Vintage Fairy Lamp Candle Light Fen...
    Fenton Art Glass Aqua Blue-Green/Turquoise Hobnail Low Covered Candy 3883 - Rare
    Fenton Art Glass Aqua Blue-Green/Tu...
    Fenton Glass Rosalene Dealer sign/ Logo
    Fenton Glass Rosalene Dealer sign/ ...
    Vintage Fairy Lamp Candle Light Fenton Orange / Amber Hobnail
    Vintage Fairy Lamp Candle Light Fen...
    See all


    1. AmberRose AmberRose, 7 years ago
      Wow, those are really different! I haven't seen the pale version, ever. So now I'm concerned...however, I don't know. (They look suspicious).
    2. ola402, 7 years ago
      While it's hard to tell from a photo taken on a light colored background, your melon vases look like Fenton's Ivory Crest pattern. This pattern was only made for a year between 1940-41 due to difficulty in sourcing material during wartime. They could also be some of the early Fenton milk glass pieces before 1958 which were more opalescent, less opaque or less solid white. But I doubt it, they really look like Ivory Crest to me. They're really nice!
    3. Adelesm, 7 years ago
      Thanks to everyone for their comments. The pieces are also much lighter in weight for their size than any other pieces I have ever held. I have decided to return them to the seller. Again, thanks to everyone for their help, I truly appreciate it.
    4. TallCakes TallCakes, 7 years ago
      might help to see the ivory melon vases up closer and also a look at the bottom. I understand that Fenton may have used uranium salts to achieve the ivory color; so these may also fluoresce under black light.

    Want to post a comment?

    Create an account or login in order to post a comment.