Share your favorites on Show & Tell

Chinese Porcelain Ginger Jar with Lid and Tall Rouleau Vase / Real or Real Reproductions ??

In Asian > Ginger Jars > Show & Tell and Asian > Chinese Pottery > Show & Tell.
Thrift store finds155 of 169Vintage Matson "Winter Landscape" / Oil on Masonite Panel 24"x 24" / Circa 1960's-70'sChinese Hand Painted "Satsuma" Style Moriage Vase with Gilded Handles / Circa 1920 - 1930's
Love it
Like it

bratjddbratjdd loves this.
nldionnenldionne loves this.
Moonstonelover21Moonstonelover21 loves this.
Add to collection

Please create an account, or Log in here

If you don't have an account, create one here.

Create a Show & TellReport as inappropriate

Posted 4 years ago


(1129 items)

Found these two pieces today. They don't say made in China or Japan either. The 8 1/2" tall jar's mark I looked up and it appears to be the mark for "Chia Ch'ing" (1796-1820).These marks have to be exactly executed or they mean nothing. The 10 1/4" tall vase's mark has a Kangxi "artemesia leaf " mark (1690-1720) on it's bottom.There are several versions of these that I have seen, Again they can be put on any piece old or new. I'll be kind and I won't say they are "fakes". There are companies that make these as reproductions by students studying porcelain design. Frankly I think they are reproductions with reproduced marks but porcelain doesn't age like glazed ceramics or pottery. It can look like new even from a wreck at the bottom of the ocean ! The hand painting looks real enough but neither piece looks like it's 200 plus years old and for the five bucks I paid for both of them, wouldn't it be amazing if they were that old ! I'm not a antique porcelain expert so I thought it's better to be safe than sorry when I bought them. Yes, I want to be the next person to find that 2 million dollar piece for 3 bucks ! -Mike-


  1. mikelv85 mikelv85, 4 years ago
    I was reading that unlike "western" ceramic marks that easily and accurately identify pieces, dates and makers, import pottery and porcelain marks are not so accurate. They can be put on a piece for any particular reason and are not always date specific to the piece itself.
  2. mikelv85 mikelv85, 4 years ago
    Just to make sure if the mark on the jar was what I had looked up, I took the picture of the mark to my friend who runs the local Chinese buffet. He and his wife both speak and write Mandarin and a little Japanese. He looked at it and said "made in the reign of Emperor Chia Ch'ing." he also said that was 250 years ago ! So I guess it's a good copy and a good copy of the original mark. Interesting.....
  3. mikelv85 mikelv85, 4 years ago
    Bummer, Found 2 large hairline cracks in the tall vase from the neck half way through the body on both sides ! So if it's worth anything, now it's worth a lot less. They are practically invisible, but I was looking at the painting detail under a strong light with a magnifying glass and I found them. I wondered why it didn't have the same "ring" as the jar. So disappointed :(
  4. nldionne nldionne, 4 years ago
    Sorry for the cracks. On to the next!
  5. mikelv85 mikelv85, 4 years ago
    Thanks nldionne, it goes with the territory which I'm sure you've "been there done that" too. Need to find something today that's really great to make up for this. Seems to be a lull though, places are starting to look empty. Too many garage sales I think.
  6. nldionne nldionne, 4 years ago
    We have our trader days flea market this weekend, think I'll hit it today. There will be yard sales for about 5 miles on either side so maybe find something interesting. It's really cold here, had to cover as many plants as possible. Was at 32 degrees for an hour or so, now that's a bummer!

Want to post a comment?

Create an account or login in order to post a comment.