The definition of a good shirt depends on where and how it will be worn. If you're getting in a round of golf with some friends, then a Burberry, Lacoste, or Izod polo shirt is probably perfect. Office attire may demand a handsome Thom Browne oxford or perhaps a tasteful print from Emporio Armani. And if you are just hanging around the house on the weekend, a vintage plaid or two-tone from Campus or McGregor is probably as formal as you want to get.

That said, when it comes to a good dress shirt, there are a few things to look for. Turndown collars should have removable bones, the yoke or back of the shirt at the neck should be split (this is a particularly costly detail if a pattern needs to be matched), and the sleeve should be pleated where it meets the cuff. Cotton is the favored fabric, and weaving styles include poplin, Oxford, and pinpoint, which is a combination of the two.

For the best suits, well-dressed Englishmen head to London’s Savile Row. For the best shirts, Jermyn Street is their destination. Turnbull & Asser requires a minimum order of six shirts, with a delivery time of 12 weeks. New & Lingwood is famous for its brightly striped shirts. And while the tailors at Harvie & Hudson can make you a jacket and pair of pants, they are best known for their shirts.

That’s the formal stuff. For casual wear, perhaps the most collectible category of vintage men’s shirt is the Hawaiian shirt, particularly those made during the 1930s, ’40s, and ’50s. Many were made of cold rayon, so-called for its cool, silky feel against the skin, but lots of Hawaiian shirts came in a more textural crepe de chine rayon, as well as cotton and silk.

Patterns ranged from vibrantly colored tropical floral prints to scenes of Hawaii to abstract, monochromatic designs. Vertical patterns that create a border at the buttons and buttonholes are especially prized, and collectible labels include Surfrider Sportswear, Catalina, Kahanamoku, Kamehameha, Kahala, Hale Hawaii, Royal Hawaiian, Duke of Hollywood, and (wait for it) J.C. Penney.

Rockabilly shirts from the second half of the Hawaiian shirt’s heyday are also sought after. Look for two-tone button-ups or pullovers, bowling shirts with the names of strangers stitched above the breast, or shirts in Mid-century Modern atomic-style prints.

Western shirts are cousins to rockabilly. Levi’s signature denim shirt from 1954 was called the Sawtooth, so named because of the jagged shape of the pocket flaps on the front of the shirt. With all dues respect to Levi’s, though, Rockmount Ranch Wear of Denver had been making similar shirts for years...

In fact, what Levi’s is to jeans, Rockmount is to the cowboy shirt. In addition to Sawtooth pockets, Rockmount also makes shirts with Quarter Horse pocket flaps and flapless pockets called Smiles, which should give you an idea of the shape. Rockmount is known also for the snaps on its shirts, which are mother-of-pearl in circles or diamonds, as well as its incredibly detailed embroidered shirts.

Like Levi’s, many Rockmount products are made out of denim. Chambray, which has that similarly blue, denim look, is also a favorite, as is gabardine and even traditional patterns and weaves such as tattersall. Other Western-style shirt makers include Wrangler and Dickies.

Of course some shirts are hot among collectors because they are favored by fashionistas. Robert Graham shirts, which have been around for barely a decade, took off when contestants wore them on “American Idol.” Shirts by motorcycle giant Harley-Davidson and venerable retailer Abercrombie & Fitch are always in demand, as are shirts by relative upstarts like Ed Hardy and Lucky Brand.

About our sources | Got something to add?

▼ Expand to read the full article ▼

Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

The Black Tie Guide

The Black Tie Guide

Peter Marshall became an authority on formalwear out of necessity — he needed a tux to wear on the maiden transat… [read review or visit site]

Fashion Columbia Study Collection

Fashion Columbia Study Collection

The Fashion Columbia Study Collection (FCSC) is the digital home of the Columbia College Chicago’s fashion archiv… [read review or visit site]

Most watched eBay auctions    

Vtg 50s 60s Penneys Towncraft Shadow Plaid Rayon Shirt L Hollywood Chevella ModVtg 50s 60s High Rockabilly Gradient Psychobilly 100% Loop Collar Shirt Size M Vtg 1930's 40's Levi Strauss Longhorn Authentic Western Big E Gabardine Shirt MdVtg 50s 60s Penneys Towncraft Shadow Plaid Rayon Shirt L Hollywood Chevella ModVintage 50s High School Graffiti Shirt Off White Cotton Long Sleeves Large / Xl Fred Perry Navy Patterned Button-down Slim Fit Shirt - M - Ska Mod Scooter Rare[nv9] Vintage 70's Levi's L Orange Tab Chambray ShirtVintage 1980s Fashion Shirt Crazy Pattern Nature Hippie Print XlNapalm Death Og Sweatpants 1992 Tour Shirt Entombed Dismember Demolition HammerVtg 50s 60s Brent Shadow Plaid Rayon Shirt Sz L Hollywood Chevella Vlv Mod RareCarhartt Great Shirt Top Cotton Sz Xl Ex Large Jeans Expensive Denim Logo VgcOriginal Ww2 U.s. Army Wool Trousers (34wx35i) And Sz 44 ShirtVintage 60's Men's Cotton Shirt By Catalina, MintVintage Polo Ralph Lauren Usa Hooded Sweatshirt Sz L Mint! Shirt Stadium P-wingFred Perry Vertical Striped Button-down Slim Fit Shirt - Xxl - Ska Mod ScooterLot Of 50 Vintage 70s Shirts Disco Groovy Campus Towncraft Hippie HipsterVintage Marilyn Manson 1996 Authentic Rock Retro Shirt Tour Goth Sweet Dreams XlRalph Lauren Mens Check Polo Shirt Sz Xxl Custom Fit 100% Cotton Gingham VgcTrue Vintage 1960s 1970s Check Flannel Shirt Jacket Pendleton Medium LumberjackLot Of 59 Vintage Western Shirts Pearl Snaps Rockabilly 70s 80s 90s Large XlLot Of 31 Flannel Shirts Vintage & Modern 70s Though Current Plaid Med Large XlVintage 50's Loop Collar Long Sleeve Shirt Mens M Rust Stitch Detail RockabillyFred Perry Laurel Wreath Button-down Check Work Shirt - M - Ska Mod Vintage RareVintage Ramones "i Wanna Be Well" Shirt J. Holmstrom Punk Rare Medium Large ArtVintage 90s Shirt Crazy Print Pattern Fashionista Party MediumVintage Polo Ralph Lauren Plaid Wool Hunting Shirt Jacket Mens 2xl UsaVintage 90s Shirt Pattern Geometric Crazy Print 2xlVtg Fred Perry Polo Shirt Indie L Large 43"chest Weller Knit Oi Ska Mod PunkVintage Bowling Shirt Vintage 60s Rayon Jewler Print - Distressed - Medium Vintage 1990s Shirt Beatnik Boho Crazy Pattern Print SmallVintage Rare 80s Harley Davidsons 3d Emblem Hog Shirt 50/50 Very Good ConditionVtg 1950's Pilgrim Blue Loop Collar Rayon Flannel Camp Shirt Rockabilly L 16 33Mens Vtg Gant The Hugger Tapered Body Sanfordized Cotton Shirt Ls 15 X 35Vintage 1990s Pattern Shirt Southwestern Native American Fashion XlVintage 90s Shirt Pattern Hawaiian Red Geometric Crazy Print 2xlVintage 80s Shirt Crazy Print Typography Pattern MWwii -3rd Infantry Division- Vintage Us Army Officers Wool Uniform Shirt W/patchVintage 90s Shirt Crazy Print Geometric Brand Beatnik LargeVintage 1990s Shirt Crazy Pattern Print Psychedelic Floral XlRetro Ralph Lauren Designer Check Preppy Smart Shirt Xl WearVintage 1990s Pattern Shirt Fashion Clothing XlVtg Lot Of 9 Ac/dc The Who Pink Floyd Stones Grateful Dead Concert Tour T-shirtsVintage Distressed Bob Marley Mosquitohead Shirt All Over Acid Wash 90s Reggae Vintage 80s Shirt Crazy Print Pattern Party Oversized Large TallVintage 1950's Cone Sanforized Farm Work Shirt 16 1/2Vintage Unworn 1950s Sanforized Work Shirt - Blue Bell (wrangler) - Small - RareVintage 50's Towncraft Cotton Blend Loop Collar Plaid Rockabilly Shirt Xl-lVintage 1990s Grunge Alternative Shirt MediumVtg Unworn Dee-cee Short Sleeve Chambray Style Work Shirt Sz SmallVintage 1980s Shirt Medium Make And MendLot Of 7 Vintage 70s Denim Chambray Work Shirt Embroidered Novelty Cat Sunset Vintage 90s Shirt Fashionista Hawaiian Holiday Crazy Print Pattern LVintage 80s Shirt Crazy Print Pattern Alt-paisley Floral L WearVintage 1990s Shirt Crazy Pattern Holiday Indie Print XlVintage 70s Levis Denim Work Shirt L Orange Tab Indigo BlueVtg 50s 60s Beige Safari Loop Collar Jacket Shirt Belted Buzz Rickson MilitaryVintage 1990s Shirt Rockabilly Poker Beatnik Fashion MediumLot Of 13 Pendleton Wool Shirts Vintage 50s Though 90s High Grade Western LargeVintage Vtg 1950/60s Hilton Loop Collar Bowling Shirt Size 16-l-16.5Vintage Vtg 1950/60s Mark Twain Loop Collar Bowling Shirt Size M