The definition of a good shirt depends on where and how it will be worn. If you're getting in a round of golf with some friends, then a Burberry, Lacoste, or Izod polo shirt is probably perfect. Office attire may demand a handsome Thom Browne oxford or perhaps a tasteful print from Emporio Armani. And if you are just hanging around the house on the weekend, a vintage plaid or two-tone from Campus or McGregor is probably as formal as you want to get.

That said, when it comes to a good dress shirt, there are a few things to look for. Turndown collars should have removable bones, the yoke or back of the shirt at the neck should be split (this is a particularly costly detail if a pattern needs to be matched), and the sleeve should be pleated where it meets the cuff. Cotton is the favored fabric, and weaving styles include poplin, Oxford, and pinpoint, which is a combination of the two.

For the best suits, well-dressed Englishmen head to London’s Savile Row. For the best shirts, Jermyn Street is their destination. Turnbull & Asser requires a minimum order of six shirts, with a delivery time of 12 weeks. New & Lingwood is famous for its brightly striped shirts. And while the tailors at Harvie & Hudson can make you a jacket and pair of pants, they are best known for their shirts.

That’s the formal stuff. For casual wear, perhaps the most collectible category of vintage men’s shirt is the Hawaiian shirt, particularly those made during the 1930s, ’40s, and ’50s. Many were made of cold rayon, so-called for its cool, silky feel against the skin, but lots of Hawaiian shirts came in a more textural crepe de chine rayon, as well as cotton and silk.

Patterns ranged from vibrantly colored tropical floral prints to scenes of Hawaii to abstract, monochromatic designs. Vertical patterns that create a border at the buttons and buttonholes are especially prized, and collectible labels include Surfrider Sportswear, Catalina, Kahanamoku, Kamehameha, Kahala, Hale Hawaii, Royal Hawaiian, Duke of Hollywood, and (wait for it) J.C. Penney.

Rockabilly shirts from the second half of the Hawaiian shirt’s heyday are also sought after. Look for two-tone button-ups or pullovers, bowling shirts with the names of strangers stitched above the breast, or shirts in Mid-century Modern atomic-style prints.

Western shirts are cousins to rockabilly. Levi’s signature denim shirt from 1954 was called the Sawtooth, so named because of the jagged shape of the pocket flaps on the front of the shirt. With all dues respect to Levi’s, though, Rockmount Ranch Wear of Denver had been making similar shirts for years...

In fact, what Levi’s is to jeans, Rockmount is to the cowboy shirt. In addition to Sawtooth pockets, Rockmount also makes shirts with Quarter Horse pocket flaps and flapless pockets called Smiles, which should give you an idea of the shape. Rockmount is known also for the snaps on its shirts, which are mother-of-pearl in circles or diamonds, as well as its incredibly detailed embroidered shirts.

Like Levi’s, many Rockmount products are made out of denim. Chambray, which has that similarly blue, denim look, is also a favorite, as is gabardine and even traditional patterns and weaves such as tattersall. Other Western-style shirt makers include Wrangler and Dickies.

Of course some shirts are hot among collectors because they are favored by fashionistas. Robert Graham shirts, which have been around for barely a decade, took off when contestants wore them on “American Idol.” Shirts by motorcycle giant Harley-Davidson and venerable retailer Abercrombie & Fitch are always in demand, as are shirts by relative upstarts like Ed Hardy and Lucky Brand.

About our sources | Got something to add?

▼ Expand to read the full article ▼

Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

The Black Tie Guide

The Black Tie Guide

Peter Marshall became an authority on formalwear out of necessity — he needed a tux to wear on the maiden transat… [read review or visit site]

Fashion Columbia Study Collection

Fashion Columbia Study Collection

The Fashion Columbia Study Collection (FCSC) is the digital home of the Columbia College Chicago’s fashion archiv… [read review or visit site]

Most watched eBay auctions    

Vtg. Penney's Big Mac Sanforized Chambray Short Sleeve Work Shirt Versace Jeans Couture Great Shirt Logo Ittierre Cotton Sz M Medium Italy VgcSisters Of Mercy Shirt Jesus Mary Chain Sonic Youth Dinosaur Jr Bauhaus SiouxsieA Pair (2) Vtg. Penney's Sanforized Chambray Denim Short Sleeve Work Shirts Vintage Rap Shirt Baby Got Back Xl Hip Hop 80s 90s Rare Fred Perry Navy Button-through Pique Polo Shirt - M - Ska Mod Football CasualsFred Perry White Penny Collar Tape Trim Cotton Shirt - S - Mod Ska Scooter RareFred Perry Navy Tipped Knitted Cotton Slim Fit Polo - S - Mod Scooter Ska RareIron Maiden Shirt Vintage Original Xl TaggedFred Perry Navy Twin Tipped Pique Polo - S - Mod Ska Football Casuals VintageFred Perry Port Marl Twin Tipped Pique Polo - S - Mod Ska Football Casuals RareVtg 70s Levis Orange Tab Chambray Shirt Medium In UsaVintage Harley Davidson Shirt 80s Bike Week NosVintage Wrangler Denim Western Shirt Sanforized Pearl Snaps Cowboy Mens 36Vintage Harley Davidson Shirt Rare Eagle Proud 50/50Vintage Polo Sport Ralph Lauren Big Logo Spell Out Xl 1992 Sportsman Mens Vintage 1950s Rockabilly ShirtFred Perry Black Twin Tipped M3600 Slim Fit Polo - L - Ska Mod Football CasualsTommy Hilfiger Logo Shirt Cotton Sz Xxxl 3xl Check Rare Expensive VgcLot Of 40 Vintage 70s Shirts Disco Triumph Kennington Jantzen Dimension WranglerVintage 1940s Fancy Embroidered Grn/grey Western Cowboy Rodeo Shirt By H Bar CVintage Levi's Chambray Orange Tab Shirt 1960's Embroidered Bear-wolf-ram SmallVintage 1990s 1992 Ralph Lauren Polo Sport P Wing Bear Snowbeach ShirtVintage 80s United Colors Of Benetton Hip Hop Rap Striped Rugby Shirt Mens Large50's Vintage Kilohana Hawaiian Aloha Shirt Size M Rare OriginalVintage Early 1940’s Rayon Shirt By Clubman! Xl!Ralph Lauren 2016 Great Polo Shirt Rare Cotton Sz Xxl New Nwt £99Judas Priest Vintage Shirt Original 80s "defenders Of The Faith" (free Shipping)Fred Perry Prince Blue Oxford Madras Check Slim Fit Polo - L - Mod Ska ScooterPrimo Beer Hawaiian Warrior Shirt Collar Button Down Go Barefoot XlVintage Levi Strauss Short-horn Western Shirt Embroidery Sawtooth Pckts SnapsScully Western Shirt Cowboy Rodeo Snap Pearl Button Men 2xl Xxl Musical NotesVintage Polo Ralph Lauren Cookie Sweater Xl 90s Rare 1992 SportsmanVintage 1940’s Pale Pink Shirt By National! MSepultura Beneath The Remains Shirt 1990 Original VintageVintage Polo Ralph Lauren Uni Crest Vest Xl Badge 1992 Plate Vintage Polo Ralph Lauren Men's Long Sleeve Button Front Shirt Size Medium MRoper Western Shirt Cowboy Rodeo Snap Pearl Button Embroidered Men 2xl XxlVintage Harley Davidson Shirt 3-d Image 1987Dr. Dre Chronic 2001 Pushead Shirt In Bud We Trust LFred Perry Utility Blue Tipped Knitted Polo - S - Mod Ska Football CasualsVintage Nike Challenge Court Polo Xl Agassi 90s Rare 80s Tennis Vintage 1940's 50's Tem-tex "the Diamond Rose" Pearl Snap Satin Western Shirt SmVintage Shaheen's Men's Casual Hawaii Shirt Handprinted Chop Sticks Lg DragonsGant Great Shirt Polo Top Rare Sz L Cotton Logo Expensive Large CottonVtg Ralph Lauren Polo Blue Cardigan Red Band Sweater Letterman Winged Track RareRare Vintage 40's 50's Hawaiian Shirt Made In Japan Musa-shiya, HonoluluSpawn Hockey Jersey Spawn ShirtSuicidal Tendencies Vintage 90's Shirt "send Me Your Money" Vintage H Bar C California Western Shirt Size 15 Black Cowboy RanchwearVintage Wrangler Denim Western Shirt Pearl Snaps Dark Blue Cowboy Mens 401950's Rayon Western Shirt Cowboy Joe Rockabilly Vintage 50s Pearl SnapFred Perry Navy Chambray Trim Button-down L/s Slim Polo - Xl - Mod Ska ScooterVintage 1970's Levi's Chambray Embroidered Orange Tab Shirt Size L Mop Snap Ween Oneness Vintage Yellow Shirt Large BoognishVintage Hunting Shooting Shirt Chain Stitching Rifle Padding Continental Mens 42Vtg Nwt Penny's Blue Light Chambray Denim Shirt Men Sz 15 1/2Spawn Hockey Jersey, Spawn ShirtVintage French Farmers Shirt. Indigo. Darning. Folk. Medium.Vtg 1900's 1920's 30's Men's White E & W Tuxedo Dress Shirt W/arrow Collar