Westinghouse Jr. Project Part 9

I'm curious now. TBGWC this question is for you most of all but please everyone feel free to give their opinion as well. The origional to this cooler bottle opener is pictured above (red, rusty one) along with a brand new in the box overstock vintage origional. Some people would love to have this new piece as a "glass case showpiece" or top shelf display. It's a box in my way at the shop to me and I want to use it on the cooler but I've been getting some flack from others. Which bottle opener would you use? Keep in mind that these ARE equivelant pieces for function. The last picture is of the bottom so you can see the modified base. The casters are removable and rubber cushions are there for countertop use.(as many of these Jr.s were cut off and used this way)