Vintage and Game Used Baseball Gloves

For guys of a certain age, there are few childhood memories fonder than that first new baseball glove. Kids who aspired to play infield chose gloves signed by Brooks Robinson, while future hall-of-fame outfielders begged their dads for mitts bearing the signatures of Roberto Clemente or Willie Mays, who remain two of the game’s best role models even today.

The first fielders played barehanded, and the early MacGregor Goldsmith, Spalding, Draper & Maynard, and Stall & Dean split-finger gloves that followed were not much better. They were more like leather or horsehide paws, with a perfunctory tangle of webbing or an unadorned flap of leather between the thumb and the index finger.

The signatures on many of these gloves from the early part of the 20th century are difficult to make out, but players like Edd J. Roush and Mel Ott won endorsement contracts, which makes vintage gloves bearing their signatures particularly collectible.

By the 1920s and ’30s, gloves had become specialized to a player’s position. Catcher mitts had extra padding, of course, to account for the 90-mile-per-hour fastballs that pitchers were hurling at them. The inside of the mitt had slots for the catcher’s fingers, but like a mitten, only the thumb was given freedom of movement. Similarly, first-base mitts were designed like giant scoops, since the position required accuracy when it came to catching a long throw from third.

By the 1940s, fielder gloves by Rawlings, Wilson, and MacGregor (the word “Goldsmith” had been dropped from the brand) were being designed to make it easier for infielders to pick up grounders and get the ball into the throwing hand quickly. For outfielders, gloves were designed to help the player snag a fly ball on the run, with deep pockets so the ball would stay put when the fielder inevitably hit the ground after making a diving catch.

Collectors of antique and vintage game-used mitts and gloves look for readable labels, leather that is supple rather than dry, and intact padding. An old glove is usually not that expensive, which means you can collect gloves from different eras and for different positions without breaking the bank. But for gloves that have been signed by a professional baseball player, the autograph is likely to eclipse the cost of the item itself, and then some.


Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

Old Cardboard

Old Cardboard

Check out this well-organized collection of 500 sets of baseball cards, each over 50 years old. Browsable by type a… [read review or visit site]

The Baseball Card Blog

The Baseball Card Blog

Ben Henry's lively vintage baseball card blog, started in January 2006, offers hundreds of great posts on (and pict… [read review or visit site]

Cardboard Junkie

Cardboard Junkie

Dave Campbell's in-depth blog on old baseball (and some football) cards lives up to it's motto: 'do cards, not drug… [read review or visit site]

Baseball Cards 1887-1914

Baseball Cards 1887-1914

Roll up your socks for this Library of Congress collection showcasing hundreds of players on colorful early basebal… [read review or visit site]

Baseball Hall of Fame

Baseball Hall of Fame

A home run for baseball collectors, this site features special online exhibits, ranging from a baseball-uniforms da… [read review or visit site]



Other Great Reference Sites

Most watched eBay auctions    

2000's Montreal Canadiens J. Theodore Game Used GloveVintage Pee Wee Reese Split Finger Baseball Glove Trojan Pwr ModelVintage Rawlings Mickey Mantle Xpg 20 Baseball GloveSteiner Sports ~derek Jeter~ Autographed Signed 1st Gold Glove Baseball #9/22 Turn Of Century Crescent Pad Adult Leather Vintage Baseball Glove Catcher's MittBrad Radke Signed Game Used Minnesota Twins Wilson A2000 Fielders Glove W/coa!Pablo Sandoval Signed Game Used Batting Glove Auto Psa/dna Coa GiantsMint 1942-49 Spalding 133 Joe Dimaggio Glove & BoxPablo Sandoval Signed Game Used Batting Glove Auto Psa/dna Coa GiantsThree Vintage Antique 1920's-1930's Baseball Gloves/glove Free Shipping!Topp's Inception Le Veon Bell Rookie Auto Glove Insert 4/10Joey Votto Signed 2012 Game Used Batting Glove Auto Psa/dna Coa Cincinnati RedsVintage Trusport Edd Roush Baseball GloveBrett Gardner Signed 2013 Game Used Batting Glove Auto Psa/dna Coa YankeesRare Sidney Crosby In The Game Rookie Auto Autograph Memorabilia Glove Card ChlVintage Mystery Baseball Glove(30's Or 40's Era)Goldsmith Leather Baseball Glove - Vintage Antique Horse Hide 5 Finger Glove MitPablo Sandoval Signed Game Used Batting Glove Auto Psa/dna Coa GiantsTy Cobb Baseball GloveVintage Antique Base Ball GloveCollin Delome Game Issued Used Reebok Fielding Glove Houston Astros Round RockDerek Jeter Signed Game Model Baseball Glove & Museum Quality Case & Steiner CoaJeff Francoeur 2009 New York Mets Atlanta Braves Game Used Fielders GloveMiguel Cabrera Autographed Game Used Batting Glove Jsa Framed Matted Tigers RPackers Game Worn Glove (casey Hayward) AutographedAndruw Jones Baseball Card Lot, 47,3 Auto,44gu,dk 1/1,patch,glove, J/b,+ Braves Vintage Early 1940s Marathon Basemitt Baseball Glove Old AntiqueBrandon Phillips Signed Game Used Batting Glove Auto Psa/dna Sticker Only RedsVintage Baseball Glove Jc Higgins Enos SlaughterBcw #ad13 Deluxe Acrylic Gold Glove Baseball Holder Black Base Ball Display CaseVintage Rawlings Stan Musial Baseball Glove Tg 72 Trap-eze Model ~ Made In Usa! Vintage Baseball GloveRuben Sierra 2006 Signed Game Used New York Mets Bat & Batting Glove W Coa!High Grade 1960's Bob Purkey Model Wilson A2961 Baseball GloveAlex Gordon Authentic Game-worn Autographed Batting Glove & Picture W/ Mlb HoloRon Santo Model, Wilson A2170, Ball Hawk Baseball GloveAlex Gordon Signed Oml Baseball Mlb Coa Royals 2x All Star 3x Gold Glove2014 Immaculate David Ortiz Game Worn Batting Glove Card 8/8 Sweet!!Miguel Cabrera Autographed Game Used Batting Glove Jsa Framed Matted Tigers LWilson Glove A2000Vintage Baseball Glove. Old Baseball Mitt - U.s. NavyVintage Early Bill Rogell Baseball Glove 2014 Topps Prime Level I Aj Mccarron Book Auto Glove/wristband/ball/patch 7/10Antique Early Baseball Mitt Glove Split Finger Buckle Back 3962007 Ud Sweet Spot Hunter Pence Josh Hamilton Glove Dual Auto 09/102003-04 Itg Parkhurst Original Six Detroit Memorabilia#dm-24 Roger Crozier Glove1953 Mickey Mantle Card With Willie Mays Signature Baseball Glove2014 Inception Rc Jumbo Glove Patch Auto Dri Archer 09/10 Bgs 9.5 10 Steelers RbNew Sz Xlarge Mens Nike New York Giants Glove Lockup Shirt Tags Retail $32Johnny Manziel Cracked Ice Event Worn Glove 2014Yadier Molina Rawlings Gold Glove Award Mini ReplicaYadier Molina Gold And Platinum Replica Glove Award SgaJoey Logano 2011 Press Pass 4 Wide Firesuit Patch Tire Glove Sheet Metal 15/25Carlos Pena Signed Game Used Tb Rays Pants & Glove With Coa!Mlb Cardinals 2002 Gold Glove Scott Rolen BobbleheadVintage 1950s Geo A Reach 4 Finger Baseball Glove Old Antique Frank GustineVintage Wilson Harvey Kuenn A 2234 Baseball GloveCleveland Indians Detroit Tigers Victor Martinez Auto Catchers Mit Glove Sga NipFrank Robinson Signed Autographed Rawlings Full Size Glove Psa/dna CoaSeth Rollins Ring Worn Signed Tactical Glove ~ Under Armour ~ Wwe Live 9/28/14