Vintage and Game Used Baseball Gloves

For guys of a certain age, there are few childhood memories fonder than that first new baseball glove. Kids who aspired to play infield chose gloves signed by Brooks Robinson, while future hall-of-fame outfielders begged their dads for mitts bearing the signatures of Roberto Clemente or Willie Mays, who remain two of the game’s best role models even today.

The first fielders played barehanded, and the early MacGregor Goldsmith, Spalding, Draper & Maynard, and Stall & Dean split-finger gloves that followed were not much better. They were more like leather or horsehide paws, with a perfunctory tangle of webbing or an unadorned flap of leather between the thumb and the index finger.

The signatures on many of these gloves from the early part of the 20th century are difficult to make out, but players like Edd J. Roush and Mel Ott won endorsement contracts, which makes vintage gloves bearing their signatures particularly collectible.

By the 1920s and ’30s, gloves had become specialized to a player’s position. Catcher mitts had extra padding, of course, to account for the 90-mile-per-hour fastballs that pitchers were hurling at them. The inside of the mitt had slots for the catcher’s fingers, but like a mitten, only the thumb was given freedom of movement. Similarly, first-base mitts were designed like giant scoops, since the position required accuracy when it came to catching a long throw from third.

By the 1940s, fielder gloves by Rawlings, Wilson, and MacGregor (the word “Goldsmith” had been dropped from the brand) were being designed to make it easier for infielders to pick up grounders and get the ball into the throwing hand quickly. For outfielders, gloves were designed to help the player snag a fly ball on the run, with deep pockets so the ball would stay put when the fielder inevitably hit the ground after making a diving catch.

Collectors of antique and vintage game-used mitts and gloves look for readable labels, leather that is supple rather than dry, and intact padding. An old glove is usually not that expensive, which means you can collect gloves from different eras and for different positions without breaking the bank. But for gloves that have been signed by a professional baseball player, the autograph is likely to eclipse the cost of the item itself, and then some.


Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

Old Cardboard

Old Cardboard

Check out this well-organized collection of 500 sets of baseball cards, each over 50 years old. Browsable by type a… [read review or visit site]

The Baseball Card Blog

The Baseball Card Blog

Ben Henry's lively vintage baseball card blog, started in January 2006, offers hundreds of great posts on (and pict… [read review or visit site]

Cardboard Junkie

Cardboard Junkie

Dave Campbell's in-depth blog on old baseball (and some football) cards lives up to it's motto: 'do cards, not drug… [read review or visit site]

Baseball Cards 1887-1914

Baseball Cards 1887-1914

Roll up your socks for this Library of Congress collection showcasing hundreds of players on colorful early basebal… [read review or visit site]

Baseball Hall of Fame

Baseball Hall of Fame

A home run for baseball collectors, this site features special online exhibits, ranging from a baseball-uniforms da… [read review or visit site]



Other Great Reference Sites

Most watched eBay auctions    

1909-11 T206 Cy Young Glove Shows Psa 3 Vg, Psa 4? Look!Vintage Baseball Catchers Glove Stall & Dean 0392Mike Piazza Autograph, Signed Baseball Catchers Glove Rawlings Mlb Mets DodgersPanini Flawless 13/14 Gary Payton "the Glove" Sonics Triple Clr Patch Auto 22/25John Tavares Fleer Showcase White Hot Glove Patch Sp /9 Islanders 2014/2015 Josh Thole Ny Mets Rawlings Heart Of The Hide Pro301-6jb Baseball Catcher Glove2014 Mike Evans Topps Supreme Jumbo Glove Rookie Relic #1/12011-12 Itg Between The Pipes Carey Price Glove And Auto / 52007 Sweet Spot Classic Willie Mccovey #12/44 Auto Black Glove Silver Ink Giants2011-12 Itg Between The Pipes Carey Price Glove And Auto / 5Jimmy Rollins Bobblehead Bobble Head Phillies Silver Slugger Golden Glove NibSt Louis Cardinals Yadi Molina Gold Platinum Glove Bobblehead Sga 2015 Presale14/15 Fleer Showcase Hot Prospects Red Glow Autograph Glove Aaron Ekblad #1/18Vintage Rawlings Usa Mm5 Professional Baseball Glove Mitt Mickey Mantle2014-15 Fleer Showcase Derrick Pouliot Red Glow Rookie Auto Glove #07/27Gordie Howe Itg Superlative The First Six Auto Glove Gold Plus /5 Vault 1/112-13 Itg Between The Pipes Carey Price Glove And Auto Sp /5 Vintage Spalding 42-205 Personal Model 12" Baseball/softball Glove - MagnificentVery Rare Mickey Mantle Vintage Baseball Glove Rawlings Mm10 Correct Hand Baseball Glove / Mitt Leather Left Hand Bill Dickey? Antique VintageOld Vintage Pepper Martin Rawlings 1920's Baseball Glove/collectible11-12 Itg Between The Pipes Carey Price Glove And Auto Sp /5 Sick 3 ColorKevin Youkilis Game Used Rawlings Procmhcbt Model Glove Boston Red SoxJacoby Ellsbury Game Used Rawlings Proje-46 Model Glove Boston Red Sox2007 Sweet Spot Classic Auto Mike Schmidt #13/15 Brown Glove Gold Ink PhilliesRawlings Pro-h Baseball Glove - Heart Of The Hide14/15 Fleer Showcase Hot Prospects Red Glow Autograph Glove Curtis Lazar #11/27Antique Vintage James Brine Buckle Back Tunnel Loop Baseball Glove Circa 1928Wilson A2000 Game Used Baseball Glove Pro Stock "ed-12" Japan "b-21" Rht 12.5" Jarvis Landry 2014 Panini Immaculate Rookie Jumbo Glove Logo Patch /30 DolphinsJets Tajh Boyd Immaculate Glove Patch Nike Swoosh #/102006 Sweet Spot Signature Glove Ryan Howard Auto/autograph Phillies 4/5 Cal Clutterbuck Game Used, Autographed Glove! Team Issued Coa! Wild! Islanders! 2014 Immaculate Gloves Carlos Hyde Glove Card #'ed 1/7Sandy Koufax And Andre Ethier Autographed Batting Glove Jsa Letter2014-15 Fleer Showcase Derrick Pouliot Red Glow Hot Prospects Auto Glove # 23/27Rawlings Rfm9 Keith Hernandez Baseball Glove First Base Mitt 13" Pg36 Parker RfmPaige☆ring Worn☆raw Worn Glove☆signed☆coa☆proof☆wwe Diva☆1/1☆ Vintage Wilson Two-finger Baseball Glove Ball Hawk Professional 636 LhtSt Louis Cardinals Yadi Yadier Molina Gold Glove Bobblehead Sga 2015 Presale 2012-13 Itg Between The Pipes Carey Price Glove And Auto / 52014 Inception De'anthony Thomas Jumbo Game Worn Glove Auto 05/10!! Super Rare2007 Sweet Spot Classic Auto Dave Winfield #14/15 Brown Glove Gold Ink Padres 1960's Hof Mickey Mantle Xpg26 Rawlings Fielders Baseball Glove Rh Usa 2014 Immaculate - Khalil Mack Nike Swoosh Glove Patch Rc - Raiders 8/10 Sick!!!Yasiel Puig Signed Auto Batting Glove W/coaVintage Roger "doc" Cramer Splitfinger Baseball Glove Mitt OldOld Vintage Buckleback Baseball Catchers Mitt GloveBrett Wallace Rawlings Gold Glove Heart Of The Hide Pro301-6jb Baseball Glove09-10 Itg Between The Pipes Jacques Plante Complete Package Glove Stick Skate1909 T206 Sweet Carporal Cy Young (cleveland Glove Show) David Ortiz Boston Red Sox Signed Batting GloveMiguel Cabrera Signed Batting Glove/not Game Used W/gai Coa Antique Vintage 1950’s Sonnett J3f Pete Runnels 3 Finger Baseball Glove Vintage Bobby Mattick Hutch Model Splitfinger Baseball Glove OldVintage Rawlings Rh Leather Baseball Glove Mitt "brooks Robinson"Vintage Baseball Glove/preferred G 18/gene Moore Insignia/nice ConditionDerek Jeter Signed Rawlings Baseball Glove Global CoaItg Superlative Vault 1/1 Bleu Blanc Rouge Rafters Memo Glove Bernie GeoffrionRafael Palmeiro Game-used Jersey, Bat, Glove, Autograph, Patch Lot 27 Cards