Share your favorites on Show & Tell

Reticulated Canton Plate - one of two I found today.

In Asian > Chinese Plates > Show & Tell.
Chinese Plates3 of 244One of two reticulated Canton plates I found today.Shipwreck
16
Love it
0
Like it

Vynil33rpmVynil33rpm loves this.
fortapachefortapache loves this.
vetraio50vetraio50 loves this.
jscott0363jscott0363 loves this.
Merrill33Merrill33 loves this.
vinetiavinetia loves this.
prettymollieprettymollie loves this.
JJansenJJansen loves this.
GianaZGianaZ loves this.
chen50chen50 loves this.
sherilusherilu loves this.
NewfldNewfld loves this.
helsingerhelsinger loves this.
vcalvcal loves this.
LeelaniLeelani loves this.
BronmarBronmar loves this.
See 14 more
Add to collection

    Please create an account, or Log in here

    If you don't have an account, create one here.


    Create a Show & TellReport as inappropriate


    Posted 1 month ago

    ho2cultcha
    (5116 items)

    I found two reticulated Canton plates today at my local thrift. They are both large - about 11" or 28 cm across. I like the painting on this one. Lots of rocks, people talking in the temple yard, etc. This one has a mountain in the distance - opposite the pagoda - which looks like Mt. Fuji and it is erupting. Otherwise this one looks Chinese, but I'm not even sure that Canton plates were made in Japan too? There are quite a few similarities between this one and the other, although this one has a slightly grayish background and the other is whiter. The border designs are different too. Any info appreciated!

    Unsolved Mystery

    Help us close this case. Add your knowledge below.

    logo
    Chinese Plates
    See all
    Chinese Qing Jiaqing Famille Rose Porcelain Cabbage Pattern Plate 10.23 inch
    Chinese Qing Jiaqing Famille Rose P...
    $46
    View on eBay
    Chinese Qing Qianlong Famille Rose Porcelain Beast Birds Pattern Plate 10.2 inch
    Chinese Qing Qianlong Famille Rose ...
    $59
    View on eBay
    7.6
    7.6" Chinese Pink Famille Rose Porc...
    $67
    View on eBay
    Chinese Ming Chenghua Blue and White Porcelain Green Dragon Pattern Plate 8.70
    Chinese Ming Chenghua Blue and Whit...
    $99
    View on eBay
    logo
    Chinese Qing Jiaqing Famille Rose Porcelain Cabbage Pattern Plate 10.23 inch
    Chinese Qing Jiaqing Famille Rose P...
    $46
    View on eBay
    See all

    Comments

    1. ho2cultcha ho2cultcha, 1 month ago
      I'm curious as to what that smoking Mt. Fuji in the distance is all about. Any ideas?
    2. ho2cultcha ho2cultcha, 1 month ago
      I was assuming early 19th c, but there is some consensus on another group I belong to that both of these are Qianlong, 18th c.
    3. ho2cultcha ho2cultcha, 26 days ago
      This is definitely my favorite of my 2 new chargers. But I am still confused as to what that erupting volcano is in the distance. Usually in sansui, you see distant mountains, so i kind of think it is an erupting volcano. unless someone comes up with a more plausible idea!
    4. ho2cultcha ho2cultcha, 26 days ago
      note: brown dressing on edges.
    5. IgnizNests, 20 days ago
      Two things that help, and one that doesn't.

      Canton is a port name, not a factory: it left through Guangzhou, painted for the Western market, and the type has a documented date window. The Florida Museum's historical-archaeology type index gives Canton porcelain a range of 1790-1835; the Chipstone Foundation's study of Chinese export blue-and-white illustrates a Canton plate as 1785-1835.

      Japan: yes, Chinese-style blue and white was made there for Western buyers. Arita potters copied Chinese blue-and-white decoration in the 17th century to reach the Dutch trade, so "looks Chinese" settles nothing. Your greyish-versus-whiter pair is the best clue you already have. Turn both over in raking light and compare the paste at the foot ring, how cleanly the foot is trimmed, and any kiln grit. Patterns travelled between kilns; the body is harder to change.

      The mountain is the detail I would not read as Fuji and stop at. Peaks in these landscapes are often generic. If it really is Fuji, the Japanese question answers itself.
    6. ho2cultcha ho2cultcha, 20 days ago
      The footrims are almost the same, clean and neat. I'm able to see the carving / shaping marks a bit more clearly on this one. The other one has a smoother rim, but same color. They are both very similar. There's no kiln grit, but there is pitting on the bases of both. The footrims are pretty yellowish on both compared to the white glaze. What do you think?

      I was told that it is pre-Canton, Qianlong by a group of collectors on FB.
    7. IgnizNests, 20 days ago
      Two facts first, then what I would check next.

      Pitting does not move the date. The Florida Museum's historical-archaeology type index defines Canton as white or greyish white paste, slightly thicker than other porcelain, with a glaze that has an "oatmeal" texture and occasional pinholes, dated 1790-1835. Maryland's diagnostic essay, following Madsen, runs the same ware 1785-1853. So pinholes and a heavier body are the type, not age and not damage.

      "Pre-Canton, Qianlong" is not automatically a contradiction. Canton is a trade and quality word, not a kiln: the wares named for it were fired upriver at Jingdezhen, and period documents used the word for "common" blue and white as against the finer Nanking (Mudge, quoted in that Maryland essay). The published Canton windows open in the 1780s and Qianlong abdicated in 1796, so the last decade of his reign sits inside them. What separates the two in practice is the rim, not the foot. Canton carries a crisscross lattice band in a heavier blue with an inner border of wavy or scalloped lines. If yours has that band, it is Canton in the type sense whatever a dealer calls it, and the better question becomes which Canton period.

      The yellow foot: that is the unglazed ring, so you are reading paste, not glaze. Identical clean trims, same colour, one smoother, reads to me like consistent mass production more than an 18th-century workshop, but I would not date either plate on it.

      Next thing to check is the blue. A few bold washes of watery grey-blue with no careful outlining is Canton. A careful outline with graded shading, and a border that is a continuous diaper or a neat husk chain, keeps an earlier date alive, and the FB group could be right. Raking light shows more on the painting than on the foot.

      Happy to keep going if you post the rim in detail.
    8. apostata apostata, 17 days ago
      there is no broad time window , cause the window coincides with a obverse zongse rim

      i gonna end this, got some intramurals to take care of

      waki
    9. apostata apostata, 17 days ago
      there is no broad time window , cause the window coincides with a obverse zongse rim

      i gonna end this, got some intramurals to take care of

      waki
    10. ho2cultcha ho2cultcha, 3 days ago
      I am so confused!! What do I have? I'm having serious eye problems right now, so that is compounding my confusion.

    Want to post a comment?

    Create an account or login in order to post a comment.