Antique and Vintage Heddon Fishing Lures

The oft-told Heddon fishing lure creation myth goes something like this: Once upon a time in the late 1800s, no one is exactly sure when, James Heddon was whittling by the side of a lake. Having had his way with the small piece of wood, he casually tossed it in the water where, to his surprise, it was attacked by a big, beautiful bass. Thus the idea of carving a piece of artificial bait, known as a plug, from wood was born.

It’s a nice story, but in an article from the 1921 issue of American Angler magazine, Charles Heddon, one of the sons of Dowagiac, Michigan’s famous James Heddon and Sons, confessed the following: "When asked who made the first wooden bait or plug, my father used to always exhibit two types of wooden minnows used by his grandfather… as far back as from 1850 to 1855."

Whether or not James Heddon was present at the moment of conception for antique fishing lures, he was a fishing-lure force to be reckoned with. The reason is the sheer inventiveness of Heddon plugs and lures, their craftsmanship, and, above all, the fact that they worked.

One of the earliest Heddon plugs was a hook-laden painted frog, carved from a broomstick, with a bottle cap for a head. That was in 1890. By 1902, Heddon was making lures for sale in his family kitchen. The first of these were named after his hometown, Dowagiac. The Dowagiac lures had sloped noses that were painted blue to contrast with the rest of the lure’s white bodies and red aluminum collars.

Perhaps the most interesting accident to come out of the Heddon kitchen was the crackled-paint effect, sometimes called "fancy back." To meet the demand of his customers, wet, freshly painted lures were often hurriedly dried in Mrs. Heddon’s oven. The resulting crackled surface of the lures was deemed a feature rather than a mistake.

Almost at the beginning, Will Heddon joined his father (the company’s 1903 catalog reads "James Heddon and Son" to reflect this change) and a few years later, Charles came on board (the 1909 catalog refers to the firm as "James Heddon and Sons").

By now the Heddons had moved their operation out of Mrs. Heddon’s kitchen and their lines of lures had grown to include the oval-shaped Dowagiac Underwater lures of 1904, with th...

For collectors of antique Heddon lures, the only thing more prized than one of these early lures, in good shape, is a lure in its original box, made of cardboard or wood. Rarer still is a lure in its box with the original information sheet describing the care and use of the lure.

Other rare lures from the first decade of the 20th century include the Underwater Expert with its exterior belly weight, the #450 Killer, the #50 Artistic Minnow (its tail was made of deer hair, and it was sold with a casting weight), and the #400 Bucktail Surface Minnow (it was only made from 1908 to 1909). At the end of the decade, Heddon introduced the #20, a series of smaller, squatter minnow lures.

The 1910s brought a bulbous-headed lured called Radiant Moonlight Bait; very few of these appear to have been made since they don’t appear in any of the old Heddon catalogs. This was also the decade of the Woodpecker, the #1300 Black Sucker Minnow, the #210 Dowagiac Minnows, and #1600 and #1700 Deep Diving Wigglers.

In the 1920s, Heddon expanded its repertoire to include bugs made out of wood, Weedless Pork-Rind lures made out of Bakelite and, later, of a plastic called Pyralin, Musky Minnows, Tad Pollys, Deep-O-Divers, Lucky 13s, Bassers, and Luny Frogs. Of particular to collectors are the #8500 Bassers from 1922 stamped with the words "Head-On Basser." Those are more rare than the later ones that were simply stamped "Basser."

Also popular in the 1920s were the various Vamp lures and the #8300 Zig-Wag lures. By the end of the decade, fly fisherman were hooked on Heddon’s Tiny Tease lures, which featured a single hook that dangled below the lure floating on the surface.

Other vintage Heddon fishing lures of note from the 1930s and 1940s include the River Runts, the #350 Musky Surface lures, the Flap-Tails, and the bird-like Crazy Crawlers.

After World War II, Heddon continued to innovate with bass lures, fly lures, and better rod technology. By the time the company was sold in 1951, it was producing as many as 15,000 lures a day.

About our sources | Got something to add?

▼ Expand to read the full article ▼

Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

Joes Old Lures

Joes Old Lures

Joe Yates' website is a great showcase for hundreds of old fishing lures, providing high resolution photos and in m… [read review or visit site]

Take a big bite - you won't want to just nibble at Robbie Pavey's gallery of over 300 antique fishing lures, many w… [read review or visit site]

This extensive site features over 500 pages of information on pre-1940 wood fishing lures and lure boxes. Start wit… [read review or visit site]

This site is sure to snag you with its great collection of fishing lures from the early 1900s. Includes lures from … [read review or visit site]

Larry Nicholson's site dedicated to vintage fishing lures. Features beautiful images of lures and boxes from Fred A… [read review or visit site]

Clubs & Associations

Discussion Forums

Other Great Reference Sites

Most watched eBay auctions    

Heddon 400 Killer Fishing Lure Circa 1905 Rare*pflueger Neverfail Underwater 5 Hook Minnow*Creek Chub Beetle 1930s Canary Yellow/lime Green/dark Spots Box Intro Card Too!*heddon #00 Underwater Minnow 5 Hook Lure Painted By Dale Roberts*Heddon 210 Surface Dowagiac Minnow Colorful Correct Box Huge Foldout Paper Blue*heddon #400 Decoy Painted By Dale Roberts*Vintage Heddon 20 Fly Reel W/ Box, Paper, Dt5f Line1905 Heddon Dowagiac Killer White Picture Box No. 450 Aluminum (made One Year)Vintage Scarce Heddon 7409pas Baby Vamp Combo, Allen Stripey W/box And Catalog!!Vintage Heddon 7409j Baby Vamp, Frog Scale, L-rig, Nice Lure.tough Lure!Vintage Heddon 5 Hook Minnow Fishing LureHeddon Punkinseed 2nd 9630 Fishing Lure (12) Lure Box Set #21920s Lovely Dace Scale Heddon 7500 Series Dowagiac Vamp Antique Wooden LureOld Fishing Plug Heddon Flap-tail Jr Vintage Wooden Lure W/ Spoon & Glass Eyes Heddon Lure Dowagiac 5 Hook Minnow #150rb W/box Catalog Paper And TagRare 1918 Heddon Wiggle King Intro Box Basser Lucky 13 'wobble Makes Em Gobble"Heddon 260 Surface Minny Old Wood Fishing Lure Glass Eyes Minty !!Umco Fishing Tackle Box Full Of Lures Heddon Creek Chub Cordell Rapala Etc....Nicest Mint Paw Paw Wotta Frog I've Ever Seen New In Sears J.c. Higgins Box Heddon Punkinseed 2nd 9630 Fishing Lure (12) Lure Box Set #1 Antique Heddon Dowagiac Yellow Shore Punkinseed Fishing Lure > NiceHeddon Imperial Fly Reel 125 Correct Box Fishing ReelVintage Heddon 7402 Baby Vamp Combo, White W/red Eyes And Tail. Near Perfect!!!!1920s Heddon 210 Surface Bait Tough Solid Black W/ Red Stencil Uncatalogued?Vintage "excellent Condition! Ocean City No.76 Fly Reel!Contents Of A Tackle Box Filled With All Kinds Of Tackle, Heddon, Shakespeare...Heddon 350 Musky Surfusser Old Wood Fishing Lure Glass Eyes NiceHeddon Wounded Spook Lure- Rare ColorHeddon Hi-tail Fishing Lure On Display CardT8) Complete Set Of (12 Lures) Heddon Stingaree Fishing Lures:regular & TinyHeddon Wounded Spook Lure In Rare ColorFf9010sx Silver / Clear Fish Flash ... River Runt In Box .. Tough LureHeddon Spin Diver Lure Fishing Wood Vintage Old Antique Dowagiac Frog 3000Vtg Fishing Lure Lot Jitterbug Heddon Bomber L&s 100+ Baits & More! Vintage Antique Tackle Heddon 9630 Sun Punkinseed Fishing Lure In Box. ExcellentLot Of Vintage Fishing Lures Heddon And OthersVintage Heddon 7409rh Baby Vamp, Red Head Flitter, Toilet Seat, Tough Lure!!!!Vintage Heddon Tadpolly Lure 5000s Strawberry Spot With BoxHeddon Musky Crazy Crawler Lure Fishing Wood Vintage Old Antique Dowagiac 215026 Vintage Fishing Lures Lazy Ike South Bend Heddon Jitterbug Fred Arbogast WoodFishing Lures 3¾" Heddon Dowagiac Vintage 5 Hook Glass Eye Wood Minnow WeightedHeddon Vibra Flash Sonic, Super Sonic, Tiny Torpedo Fishing LuresHeddon Joint Vamp Strip Scale Pattern Vintage Lure Lot Of 50 Vintage Fishing Lures Heddon Wooden Rapala Rebel L & S Ike Bass TackleVintage 4-1/8” Heddon Luny Frog Fishing Lure Lot 4-131Vintage Heddon 7401 Baby Vamp Combo, Rainbow W/l-rig & Inline Stencil. Nice Set!Vintage Heddon 2-3/4” Wooden Crazy Crawler Lure 2120-ybh W/ Box Lot 4-152Mint In Box Creek Chub 701 Pikie Minnow Name Stencil & Brushed Gills Old StockT2) Vintage Heddon Ace #190 Weedless Pork Rind Minnow Lure W Downleap Box7 *new* Original Heddon Zara Spook LuresHeddon Punkinseed 2nd 9630 Fishing Lure (12) Lure Box Set #4Vintage Fishing Lures And Tackle Lot. Heddon, Creek Chub, Herters, JitterbugVintage Wood Fishing Lure - Heddon Lucky 13 In Perch Scale Old Glass EyesOld Wooden Heddon 5 Hook Dowagiac Minnow LureMixed Box Lot Of Lures Heddon, Bomber, Etc.Heddon Punkinseed 2nd 9630 Fishing Lure (12) Lure Box Set #3Heddon Underwater Minnow Lure Fishing Wood Vintage Antique Solid Red 100 Vintage Heddon Dowagiac Meadow Mouse Glass Eyes L-rig Vintage Heddon Dowagiac Minnow Wooden Fishing Lure Glass EyeHeddon 210 Surface Lure Early Fishing Wood Vintage Antique Dowagiac Wood In Box