Vintage Paw Paw and Moonlight Fishing Tackle

Horace Ball and Charles Varney founded the Moonlight Bait Company in Paw Paw, Michigan in 1908, selling handmade wooden lures (shaped, painted, and hooked to catch the biggest fish). Since they didn't have time to fish during the day, most of their lures glowed for better visibility at night. Some still even glow today. Product lines included 'Floating Bait,' 'Zig-Zag,' 'Wiggler,' and 'Dreadnaught.' The company was bought by the Paw Paw Bait company around 1928, and expanded into fly fishing lures. Look for lures in their original packaging, and be careful of imitations.

Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

Joes Old Lures

Joes Old Lures

Joe Yates' website is a great showcase for hundreds of old fishing lures, providing high resolution photos and in m… [read review or visit site]

Take a big bite - you won't want to just nibble at Robbie Pavey's gallery of over 300 antique fishing lures, many w… [read review or visit site]

This extensive site features over 500 pages of information on pre-1940 wood fishing lures and lure boxes. Start wit… [read review or visit site]

This site is sure to snag you with its great collection of fishing lures from the early 1900s. Includes lures from … [read review or visit site]

Larry Nicholson's site dedicated to vintage fishing lures. Features beautiful images of lures and boxes from Fred A… [read review or visit site]

Clubs & Associations

Discussion Forums

Other Great Reference Sites

Most watched eBay auctions    

Old Early Paw Paw Lure Bait Fly Rod Box With New Old Stock Flies Michigan MadeM27) Excellent Vintage Paw Paw Platypus 3500 Fishing Lure In Rainbow Trout NiceM30) Exceptional Vintage Paw Paw Trout Muddler On Card W Indian Sign Box NiceVintage Paw Paw Jointed Trout Caster Lure / 3 Hooks-5 InchesMoonlight #1009 Pikaroon Yellow Perch Mi 1920sMoonlight #1003 Pikaroon Moss Back Mi 1920sMoonlight #2009 Jointed Pikaroon Yellow Perch Mi 1920sMoonlight / Silver Creek Pikaroon Yellow, Black Accents Mi 1920sT12) Vintage Paw Paw Glass Eyed Crippled Minnow 3400 Series Fishing LureOld Early Paw Paw Caster Minnow Lot Trout Musky Carved Tail Michigan MadeMoonlight Special #1011 Pikaroon Black, Yellow Eyes Mi 1920sMoonlight #1004 Pikaroon White & Red Mi 1920sMint 1925 Vintage Moonlight Bait Company Moss Back Finish Antique Fishing LureM29) Very Nice Vintage Paw Paw Large Pike Caster C100 Fishing Lure & A Box6 Inch Moonlight #3104 Musky Special Jointed Pikaroon White & Red Mi 1920sMoonlight / Silver Creek Jointed Pikaroon White, Red & Black Back Mi 1920sMoonlight Special #2011 Jointed Pikaroon Black, Yellow Eyes Mi 1920sTough Paw Paw The Rat Lure Grey Pearl Mi 1930sMoonlight Pollywog Fishing LureMoonlight #2007 Jointed Pikaroon Gold Scale Mi 1920sMoonlight Jointed Pikaroon Special Small Golden Shiner Scale Mi 1920sMoonlight Bass Seeker 4 1/4" Nice Old LureMoonlight 99% Weedless Fishing LureLot Of (7) Vintage Lures Heddon Paw-paw Arbo-gaster Bud Stewart NormanVintage ~ Paw Paw Caster In The Large Size PerchVintage ~ Paw Paw CasterMoonlight #1003 Jointed Pikaroon Green Scale Mi 1920sSilver Creek (moonlight) Pikaroon.Vintage ~ Paw Paw CasterOld Wooden Paw Paw Croaker Frog Skin Lure Bait Michigan Tough 1920's First Version Paw Paw Bait Orange With Fish Border Lure BoxVintage Fishing Tackle Lot Lures Paw Paw Pflueger & More No Reserve Worth A LookNice Paw Paw Luminous Wilson's Wobbler Lure Mi 1930sTough Paw Paw Mouse Lure (shur Strike Style) Lure Grey Mouse Mi 1930sBox Only For Paw Paw 6400 S Small Pike Caster Lure Mi 1930sEarly Paw Paw Crawdad Lure Tan Crab Mi 1930sVintage Heddon Flaptail Creek Chub Pikie Paw Paw Plunker Fishing Lure LotMoonlight #1007 Pikaroon Gold Scale Mi 1920sVintage Lot Of "5" Heddon-paw Paw-millsite Assorted LuresT10) Paw Paw River Go Getter Series 800 In Uncatalogued Black White Head ColorVintage Paw Paw Shiner/tough Color!M28) Unused Vintage Paw Paw 200 Series Shore Minnow Fishing Lure W Correct BoxRare Vintage Lot Of 3 Paw Paw Moonlight Widget Wobbler Ultra Light Fishing LuresVintage Fishing Lure Paw PawVintage Antique 3.5" Wood Unknown Paw Paw ? Fishing Lure Plug Tackle Crank BaitRare Vintage Lot Of 2 Rush Tango ? Heddon? Paw Paw? Widget Wood Fishing Lures NrMoonlight / Silver Creek Babe-eat-us White, Red Accents Mi 1920sNice Moonlight #3302 Scoopnose Minnow Rainbow Mi 1920sVintage Antique 3.5" Paw Paw Flap Jack Fishing Lure Plug Tackle Tuff Color #2Hard To Find Limited Edition 1925 Moonlight Bait Company Fishing Lure CatalogVintage Antique Paw-paw Fishing Lure Rare L@@k!Vintage Paw Paw J C Higgins LureT11) Vintage Paw Paw Crippled Minnow 3400 Series Fishing Lure Tack EyesUncatalogued Paw Paw Small Flat Face Wobbler Lure Black & Yellow Mi 1920sVintage Paw Paw Old Faithful 1940 Michigan Fishing Lure. Bass-oreno Type BaitVery Rare Paw Paw Bait Company Advertising Display PieceVintage Antique 3.5" Paw Paw Flap Jack Fishing Lure Plug Tackle Tuff ColorMoonlight Transitional Surface Spinner Minnow White, Red Head Mi 1920sMoonlight Babe-eat-us White, Red Accents Mi 1920sT13) Vintage Paw Paw Dreadnaught 5100j Fishing Lure In White Red Head Color