Fishing lures have been around about as long as prehistoric humans have contrived ways to catch fish. The earliest, prehistoric lures were made of bone. China was the first civilization to make fishing lines (of silk, of course), to which they attached delicate bronze hooks.

One of the founding fathers of the nascent fishing-lure industry in the United States was the son of a furrier named Julio T. Buel of Whitehall, New York. Between 1852 and 1876, Buel won five patents for various stamped-metal "arrowhead" spinners and feathered "spoons," as they were called then and are known today. Some had tiny chambers that could be opened or closed to make the lure either a sinker or a floater.

Around the same time, a contemporary of Buel’s, fellow New Yorker Thomas H. Bate, produced a number of metal Serpentine Spinners. Bate’s single- and treble-hook spoons were similar in some respects to Buel’s except that Bate’s spoons often had a drop of brass in their centers to give the lure extra weight.

Riley Haskell of Ohio took a more realistic approach with his lures, which closely resembled minnows. Some were made of brass, others of copper, and the detail of Haskell’s minnows was so complete that his tiny metal fish often featured scales.

W.D. Chapman of Theresa, New York was another prominent late 19th-century producer of "trolling bait." While his early products had a lot in common with those produced by Buel, by the 1880s he was merging the Buel and Haskell styles to create lures such as the Kilby Brass Single. The nickel-plated, spiraling "Safe Deposit Minnows" of the 1890s are especially handsome examples of antique fishing lures.

The transition from fishing with metal to wood and other materials begins—by some accounts, anyway—in Michigan at the family home of James Heddon. Heddon came from a family of fisherman who had always made their own homemade lures—one fine example from about 1890 features four hooks on a broomstick body that has been painted to resemble a frog. A bottle cap works nicely for a head.

By 1902, Heddon and his sons, Charles and William, were making lures in their kitchen. The first of these were named after their hometown, Dowagiac. Some of these had sloped nose...

As Heddon grew and the 1920s dawned, the company produced lures with names like Tad Polly, Lucky 13, Basser, Luny Frog, Zaragossa, and Vamp (in Baby, Round Nose, Jointed, Musky, and Floating flavors), among others.

Another Michigan company from the same period was William Shakespeare. At the beginning of the 20th century, Shakespeare lures were somewhat abstract, composed of aluminum, acorn-shaped body sections that have an almost robot-like appearance.

Shakespeare was also an early champion of rubber lures, making life-like frogs that were painstakingly painted. Some minnows floated, others worked while submerged, and all were studded with nasty hooks (five trebles was not uncommon). In the 1920s and 1930s, Shakespeare also produced lures that resembled swimming mice, complete with tails.

Back in Ohio, Pflueger, which sometimes marketed its lures under the name Enterprise Manufacturing Company, was the other great 19th-century lure company. Its earliest minnow lures from 1899 had glass eyes, and some of its 1880s lures used luminous paint to help attract fish. Pflueger’s Kent Floaters were squat, acorn-shaped, and brilliantly colored; its Surprise Minnows featured deeply carved grins; and the O’Boy Minnows and Pal-O-Mine lures had metal mouths to catch and reflect light.

Creek Chub Bait Co. and South Bend Bait Co. were Indiana’s contributions to the world of antique and vintage fishing lures. In 1906, three fisherman friends founded Creek Chub to produce just one lure, the Wiggler. Other Creek Chub lures wagged their tails or flopped at their joints. The company also made lures that looked like bugs, as well as minnows that floated upside down to suggest they were injured and, thus, easy pickings.

South Bend’s first minnow lures used propellers supplied by Shakespeare. The hooks of its lures were secured to screw eyes set into deep aluminum cups, which gave South Bend lures a fancy, finished appearance. One of its most popular lures was the uniformly tapered, dual-propeller Surf-Oreno, which was produced from 1916 through the 1960s.

About our sources | Got something to add?

▼ Expand to read the full article ▼

Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

Joes Old Lures

Joes Old Lures

Joe Yates' website is a great showcase for hundreds of old fishing lures, providing high resolution photos and in m… [read review or visit site]

Mrlurebox.com

Mrlurebox.com

Take a big bite - you won't want to just nibble at Robbie Pavey's gallery of over 300 antique fishing lures, many w… [read review or visit site]

AntiqueLures.com

AntiqueLures.com

This extensive site features over 500 pages of information on pre-1940 wood fishing lures and lure boxes. Start wit… [read review or visit site]

Oldfishinglure.com

Oldfishinglure.com

This site is sure to snag you with its great collection of fishing lures from the early 1900s. Includes lures from … [read review or visit site]

Bob Vermillion - Folk Art Tackle

Bob Vermillion - Folk Art Tackle

Bob Vermillion started collecting lures at age 16. Accordingly, his handsome site is dedicated to his love of folk-… [read review or visit site]

The Wheelmen

The Wheelmen

This elegant tribute to turn-of-the-century bicycling includes memorabilia, photographs, and an index of 3140 bicyc… [read review or visit site]

TackleCollecting.com

TackleCollecting.com

Larry Nicholson's site dedicated to vintage fishing lures. Features beautiful images of lures and boxes from Fred A… [read review or visit site]



Clubs & Associations

Discussion Forums

Other Great Reference Sites

Most watched eBay auctions    

Early Shakespeare Revolution/very Rare Lure And Color!Vintage Creek Chub #2006 Darter In Ultra Rare Special Order Goldfish Color/nice!21" Walleye Ice Spearing Fish Decoy, Midwest Carver Mike SchaffnerHeddon Dowagiac Minnow #00 W/l- Rig Hardware Down Bass Box C.1915 Vgc Glass-eyesEarly Heddon Dummy Double/very Rare Lure/football Hardware!Vintage Heddon 100 Blended Red W/ Correct Wooden Box Tough ComboHeddon Dowagiac Musky Minnow # 300 In RainbowVintage Heddon #8369 Sp Rh King Zig Wag--correct BoxHeddon 150 L-rig Glass Eyes HpgmVintage Creek Chub #806 Deluxe Wagtail Chub In Rare Goldfish Color/very Nice!Vintage Fishing Lure Lot Heddon, South Bend, Arbogast, And MoreHeddon Tadpolly Early # 6009k In GoldfishEarly Heddon 300 Minnow W/blush Chin, Wood Lure W/glass Eyes, Green CracklebackVintage Old Wood Fishing Lure Creek Chub Beetle Red & White Ge Special OrderVintage Heddon Lucky 13 Spook In Color #xbwVintage Lot Of 6 Unknown Name Home Made Folk Art Fish Wood Lures Orig PaintVintage Hand & Painted Carved Wood & Tin Wooden Fish Decoy Lure Folk Art Nr Yqz[127] - Pflueger Box And Neverfail MinnowVintage 40's? Shakespeare Tantalizer 6638 Wr Lure In Box Minty From EstateVintage Heddon Dowagiac No. 150 Fishing Lure Possible Antique CollectibleHeddon Fly Rod Mouse Lure In Correct BoxShakespeare #42sf Wooden Minnow In Fancy Geen BackHeddon 1700 Near Surface Wiggler ~ Green Crackleback, Wood Lure W/glass EyesHeddon Wiggle King And BoxVintage Tough Point Jude Saltwater Striper Surf Plug Bait Fishing W/boxVintage South Bend Lure 958 Rh In Box Minty From EstateHeddon Dowagiac Minnow Surface Lure # 200 Rh With Correct Box Vintage 40's? Creek Chub Injured Minnow 702 Lure In Box Mint From EstateVintage 40's? Creek Chub Injured Minnow 3402? Lure In Box Minty From EstateVintage Creek Chub, Special #2214 Midget Pikie (yellow Spotted) Wood, Ges, ToughNice South Bend Surf Oreno Intro BoxVintage Old Wood Fishing Lure Creek Chub Baby Wiggler Goldfish Hpgm Dlt GeVintage Heddon 980sun Punkinseed Fishing Lure, Unused On Card In Original BoxVintage Antique Tackle Paul Bunyan Teardrop Musky Size Fishing Lure BaitHeddon 1600 Deep Dive Wiggler ~ Green Crackleback, Wood Lure Vintage Moonlight Pikaroon (perch), Wood, Ges, Creek Chub Wood Wigglefish Old Fishing Lure Glass Eyes + A BoxTuff 1925 Vintage Creek Chub Ge Baby Injured Minnow Lure Yellow Spotted-red RibsRare Mint Glowurm In Box With Papers Green And YellowLarge Lot Of Vintage Fishing LuresSouth Bend Surface Minnow Bings Hooks12 Vintage Wiggle Wart Crankbait Fishing Lures Heddon 150 Underwater Minnow ~ Green Crackleback, Wood Lure W/glass Eyes11 Vintage Bone Fishing LuresNice 5/8 Oz. Wood Fred Arbogast Jitterbug In Flo Red A Strong Ex-Vintage Heddon Spoon-y Frog #3200, Metal, 3", Includes Orig Box, Made 1928-1930South Bend 915 Panetella Gcb Gold BellyHeddon Dowagiac Minnow Surface Lure # 200 Rh With Box ( Early Version )Heddon Or Shakespeare 33 Sienna CracklebackPflueger Neverfail Underwater MinnowVintage Hand Carved Wood & Tin Fish Decoy Lure Folk Art Initialed "rld" #2 YqzVintage Old Wood Fishing Lure Creek Chub Wigglefish Pike Scale GeHeddon Fly Rod Punkinseed Punkie LureEarly Heddon Box Insert/ultra Rare!Nice Vintage Wooden Creek Chub Rainbow Color Glass Eye Pikie Fishing LureEarly Vintage Stan Gibbs Saltwater Surf Fishing Lure In Box Superb!Vintage Hand Carved Wood & Tin Fish Decoy Lure Folk Art Initialed "rld" #1 YqzVintage Hand Carved Wood & Tin Fish Decoy Lure Folk Art Initialed "rld" #3 YqzVintage Creek Chub Striper Pikie Fishing LureVintage South Bend Baby Pike Oreno 956 In Box Mint From Estate