Birds of a feather flock together. In this case, the cliché rings true, and Native Americans knew it. When the colonists first arrived in North America, they found that the natives were using mud, bulrushes, fowl carcasses, and other materials to create imitations of ducks and other fowl. These imitations attracted live birds, which the hunters would then kill or capture.

Native Americans had been successfully employing this practice for more than 1,000 years, so the colonists began to build on their techniques. Hunting had been rare among commoners in the Old World since most fields and pastures with game belonged to aristocrats, especially in England. Despite the novelty of hunting in the New World for the colonists, the word they eventually used to name their new lifelike lures—“decoys”—came from a Dutch word referring to the cages Old World hunters built to attract and tame wild birds.

By the mid-19th century, most decoys in the New World were made out of wood rather than mud, and commercial and sport hunters alike used them to help lure their prey. Although the style and construction of decoys varied by region and carver, the most common woods used were white pine and white cedar, which were both durable and buoyant.

A carver would craft the general shape of the decoy’s body using a hatchet and then fine-tune it with a long drawknife. He or she—a few carvers enlisted the help of their wives—would create the head separately from a smaller block of wood using an axe, rather than a hatchet; then, the carver would whittle the head down with a jackknife and attach it to the body using nails or long spikes.

Finally, the finished decoy would be sanded, primed, and painted in natural colors to lure fowl effectively. By the time of the Civil War, this technique had matured almost to an art form.

Commercial hunters often owned hundreds of decoys, which they would set out in large numbers to attract as many birds as possible. As sport hunting became more prominent among the wealthy, some carvers began making fewer decoys but of higher quality for this new clientele. Sport hunters wanted decoys that were beautiful, not just useful. Eventually, some carvers began making decoys for purely decorative reasons.

Decoys varied in style from region to region, as the environment and species of a given area dictated their design. Decoys in Maine, for example, were often tougher and more rugg...

Even within regions, decoys could take any one of a number of designs. Some were built to float, and these were generally intended to attract large fowl like ducks and geese. Within this group, some were hollowed out so they would be more buoyant, while others were solid.

Another group of decoys included the stationary “stickups,” which stood on legs in the ground. Still others were two-dimensional profiles that were also designed as stickups. Some of these stickups were nearly four feet tall; floating decoys could be just as long.

Although the carvers who made these decoys were considered craftsmen at the time, decoys have become collectible examples of folk art. The reasons for this change in perception range from the quality of the decoys to events that helped make them scarce.

By 1920, for example, Congress had passed the North American Wildlife Act and North American Migratory Bird Act, which limited hunting and banned commercial hunting of most species altogether. Overnight, the demand for decoys all but disappeared—commercial hunters had been by far the biggest decoy customers.

Decoys became even scarcer in the 1950s and 1960s when mass-produced plastic decoys became available. Because the plastic decoys were cheaper and lighter than wooden decoys (an important consideration when carrying many in a small boat), many hunters discarded or even burned their wooden decoys, which at the time seemed worthless. In recent decades, however, many of these vintage decoys have emerged as collectors’ items.

The value of a decoy depends on a variety of factors, including its condition (both of the paint and of the wood itself), its rarity, and the reputation of the carver. Decoys of some species—like wood ducks and teal—are rarer than others, as are decoys carved in unusual poses like sleeping, swimming, or feeding. Those never actually used for hunting, of course, tend to be in better condition and, thus, more valuable.

The list of carvers is literally endless, but some names stand out above the rest. Perhaps the most famous practitioner was Elmer Crowell (1862-1951), a masterful carver and painter who lived in Cape Cod, Massachusetts. His decoys generally have carved wings and glass eyes, and he often used a rasp to imitate feathers on the back of his decoys’ heads and on their breasts. In 2000, a preening Canada goose that he carved sold at an auction for $684,500, the current world record for a decoy.

Other notable carvers include Lathrop T. Holmes, who used a limited but expressive palette of colors. “Gus” Wilson’s attention to detail was almost unrivaled, while many of the approximately 10,000 decoys in 50 years made by the Ward Brothers of Maryland were purely decorative. Charles Perdew and his wife, Edna, were a team—he carved and she painted. And Ken Anger perfected the technique of using a rasp to make his decoys look soft and realistic.

In addition to hand-carved decoys, some of the high-quality decoys produced in late-19th-century factories are also highly collectible. The main factories included Mason, Victor, Dodge, Stevens, Peterson, Evans, and Reynolds. Most of these factories used either a duplicating lathe, an assembly line, or both.

Although many of the more successful companies’ decoys were quite similar to one another, some particularly innovative examples are valuable today. One, for example, flapped its wings—a terrible failure for a hunter, but a great find for a collector. Another prize is a factory-made rubber decoy from 1867.

About our sources | Got something to add?

▼ Expand to read the full article ▼

Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

American Folk Art Museum

American Folk Art Museum

The American Folk Art Museum's website showcases current and past exhibitions along with their permanent collection… [read review or visit site]

The Wheelmen

The Wheelmen

This elegant tribute to turn-of-the-century bicycling includes memorabilia, photographs, and an index of 3140 bicyc… [read review or visit site]

National Carousel Association

National Carousel Association

Since 1973, the National Carousel Association has been dedicated to preserving and restoring carousels and carousel… [read review or visit site]

Anonymous Works

Anonymous Works

This blog combines American primitive folk art, vintage vernacular photography, outsider art, and other interesting… [read review or visit site]

The Outsider Art Pages

The Outsider Art Pages

A modern look at folk and outsider art with a focus on what people are doing to keep these traditions alive. The si… [read review or visit site]

Folk Art in Bottles

Folk Art in Bottles

Whether you call them Bottle Whimseys, Whimsey Bottles, Puzzle Bottles, or Whimsies, this site showcases great folk… [read review or visit site]

Index of American Design

Index of American Design

The Index of American Design project (1935-1942) was an effort to catalog American decorative arts objects from the… [read review or visit site]

Stoveburner.com

Stoveburner.com

A stunning collection of 162 images of stoveburners, those corroded cast iron elements that power stoves, broilers,… [read review or visit site]



Clubs & Associations

Other Great Reference Sites

Most watched eBay auctions    

Scarce -superb Lake St. Clair C1939 Jim Kelson "redhead" Sleeper Wood Duck DecoyAntique Shorebird Hunting Decoy Decoys Wooden Vintage Duck Old CarvedEarly Antique Vintage Old Wooden Virginia Nc Nj Ira Hudson Brant DecoyAntique **wood Decoy Set** Reynolds Factory Blue Wing Teal Trifold Stunning Hooded Merganser Hen Carved Wood Decoy Decoys John Mullican 1975Beautiful Pigeon Hunting Decoy Decoys Wooden Vintage Duck Old Carved ShorebirdBeautiful Morning Dove Hunting Decoy Decoys Wooden Vintage Duck Old Carved CaCommon Eastern Eider Duck Decoy Tuckerton School Rick Brown Brick Township NjFolding Tin Shorebird Hunting Decoy Antique 1890 Strater & Sohier Golden PloverHollow Mallard Duck Hunting Decoy Decoys Wood Antique Vintage Original 1930sHarlequin Duck Decoy Matched Pair Tuckerton School Rick Brown Brick Township NjRare Superb 100% Orig Paint C1962 Wildfowler ~pt. Pleasant Brant Wood Duck DecoyAntique Canvas Feeding Goose Decoy By Mannie Haywood Of Kill Devil Hills, NcLarger Vintage Decoy Duck Hand Painted OldVintage ~very Early St. Clair Flats C1930 "ben Schmidt" Wood Duck Decoy MichiganRedhead Duck Decoy By Charlie JoinerCharlie Perry Kitty Hawk Nc Antique Redhead Duck DecoyMason Premier Grade Blue Bill Duck Decoy Decoys Restored HollowDucks Unlimited Big Sky Mt 1991 Special Edition Decoy 21" Wood Pintail DuckMason Premier Grade Canvasback Duck Decoy Decoys Restored Hollow2 Decoys Found In The French Man's Bay Area OntarioAntique Duck Hunting Decoy Decoys Solid Carved Coot California Redwood 1930sDucks Unlimited Big Sky Mt 1993 Special Edition Decoy 16" Wood Red Mallard DuckVintage Antique Wood Brant Goose Duck Decoy - Charles Pete Wilbur Ducks Unlimited Big Sky Mt 1998 Special Edition Decoy 16" Wood Brown DuckRare ~superb Orig Paint C1941 Wildfowler ~old Saybrook Goldeneye Wood Duck DecoyAntique Mason Detroit Grade Wood Blue Bill Drake Hunting Decoy Glass Eyes 1920'sAntique Ira Hudson Blackduck DecoyBig Sky Carvers Red Breasted Merganser Duck Decoy Signed K. BastaSuperb Wood Duck Drake Taxidermy Bird Art Decoy Hunt Decor Wildlife WaterfowlMadison Mitchell Duck Decoy CanvasbackBig Sky Carvers Harlequin Duck Decoy SignedVintage Flat Bottom Wood Duck Decoy With Original Paint Found Madison Wisconsin1983 Series Hersey Kyle & Tom Taber Wood Duck Decoy1983 Series Hersey Kyle & Tom Taber Wood Duck DecoyHerb Miller Black Duck Decoy 1993 Delaware River StyleVintage Wood Hunting Hen Blue Bill Decoy By Miles Pirnie,michiganHerters 1893 Model Ruddy Duck DecoyDucks Unlimited Big Sky Mt 1996 Special Edition Decoy 16" Wood DuckCarved Wood Grouse Decoy Chris Olson Ducks Unlimited Bird Carving 93-94Ducks Unlimited Big Sky Mt 1997 Special Edition Decoy 16" Wood DuckDucks Unlimited Duck Decoy Special Edition 1991-92 # 2694 Randy Tull Pre OwnedJules Bouillet Delta Waterfowl Green Mallard - 1997 Duck Decoy Limited Edition Vintage 30s Soules & Swisher Decatur, Illinois Paper Macha Owl Decoy Glass EyesScarce 1925-30's Bufflehead Drake Delaware River Working Decoy 100% Orig. PaintEarly & Fine Clark Madera Pitman, New Jersey Hollow Black Duck Decoy Mixed PaintVintage Rare Pigeon Duck Decoy By R. Madison Mitchell S&d 1977 O.p.Vintage "pair" Canvasback Duck Decoys By R. Madison Mitchell S&d 1976 O.p.Vintage "pair" Goldeneye Duck Decoys By R. Madison Mitchell S&d 1974Vintage! Handpainted Carved Wood Goose Decoy Hunting Decoy Canada Goose ??Vintage "pair" Highhead Canvasback Duck Decoys By Dan Carson S&d 1992 O.p.Woodcock Woodcarving, Duck Decoy, Game Bird Carving, Casey Edwards Vintage Widgeon Drake Duck Decoy By R. Madison Mitchell S&d 1979 O.p.Antique Daddy Holly Canvasback Hen DecoyVintage "sleeper" Blackduck Duck Decoy By Clarence Fennimore O.p. SignedMint 1925 Frank Schmidt Black Duck Decoy Rigged (brother Ben) W/papers DetroitDucks Unlimited Black Duck Decoy By Pat Godin 2017 Special Du Medallion Edition Ducks Unlimited Mallard Duck Decoy Of The Year 2017 By Jett Brunet, 80th Yr, NibDecoys Duck Decoy Vintage HuntingVintage White Pigeon Duck Decoy By Jim Pierce Signed O.p.