After the Liberty Head nickel was discontinued at the end of 1912, the Buffalo nickel (also known as the Indian Head) was released in February 1913. Designed by sculptor James Earl Fraser, it featured the head of a Native American chief with the word “Liberty” on the obverse and a buffalo (American bison) on the reverse.

The profile on the coin’s obverse is actually a composite of Cheyenne chief Two Moons, Kiowa leader John Big Tree, and Lakota chief Iron Tail, who rode against Custer during the general’s famous last stand. It was only the second time a coin would feature a Native American on either of its sides—the first depiction occurred in 1908 on gold Quarter Eagles and Half Eagles, which are also known as Indian Heads. The next coin to honor a Native American would not appear until 2000 with the Sacagawea dollar.

While the profile of the chief remained relatively consistent throughout the coin’s run until 1938, the coin’s reverse underwent numerous changes. For example, when the coin was first minted in 1913, the buffalo, whose likeness was based on a Central Park Zoo animal named Black Diamond, was depicted standing on a mound. It quickly became clear to mint officials, though, that the relief on this Raised Ground variety, as it is known, was too high, and that the words “FIVE CENTS” were destined to wear off quickly.

So, that same year, mint engraver Charles E. Barber took it upon himself to correct this oversight, placing the bison on a Straight Ground above a recess created for the name of the coin’s denomination. Much to the dismay of some contemporary coin experts, Barber also fussed with the animal’s hide and the chief’s face and feathers, removing details to give the images a more polished, if less realistic and gritty, appearance.

Another change to the buffalo occurred in 1937, when a production error at the Denver mint (a die was repaired incorrectly) caused a small-but-unknown number of nickels to be released into circulation with three-legged animals on their reverse. These 3-Legged coins, as they are called, are among the most collected by Buffalo nickel enthusiasts, though they are not as rare, or expensive, as coins from the same mint in the previous year, when the beasts on even fewer coins appear to have 3 1/2 legs.

Because of their size and thickness, Buffalo nickels were carved into Hobo Nickels, a form of American folk art in which artisans modified the pictures on the coins. For example, the Indian Chief’s head might be altered to depict a man wearing a hat, or the buffalo may be turned into a steam train. In most of these coins, a few remnants of the original coin are left intact—for example, the coin’s date and the word “LIBERTY” on the obverse.

In 1938, the U.S. Treasury launched a competition to replace the coin’s 19th-century imagery with icons of the 18th, namely, a portrait of Thomas Jefferson and his home at Monticello. Though they, too, have undergone numerous redesigns, Jefferson nickels remain in circulation to this day.

Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

The Original Hobo Nickel Society

The Original Hobo Nickel Society

Founded in 1992, The Original Hobo Nickel Society is mostly devoted to folk art derived from Indian Head or Buffalo… [read review or visit site]

Legendary Coins and Currency

Legendary Coins and Currency

This online exhibition from the Smithsonian's National Museum of American History is a great way to get an overview… [read review or visit site]

Society of U.S. Pattern Collectors

Society of U.S. Pattern Collectors

Home to the Society of U.S. Pattern collectors, this well-organized site provides in-depth information on pattern c… [read review or visit site]

Clubs & Associations

Other Great Reference Sites

Most watched eBay auctions    

1937-d * 3 Legs Legged * Ngc Au58 * Buffalo Indian Head Nickel 5c * $1,750+ Coin1937 D Buffalo Nickel 3 Legs No Cleaning Full Mint Luster Scarce Mint Error1937 D 3 Legged Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Vf Details No Reserve1918-d Buffalo Nickel, Beautiful Key Date ** Free Shipping!1937-d 3-legged Buffalo Nickel - Great Coin - 1st Time Offered!!1913-s Ngc Buffalo Nickel, Type 2, Ngc F 12 ** Scarce First Year Issue!1918/7 D Buffalo Indian Head Nickel Very Rare Key Solid Example **pcgs Genuine**1915 S Buffalo Nickel Fine1926-s Pcgs Xf40 Buffalo 5c Nickel Id#k867Buffalo Indian Head Nickel Collection 1913 T0 1938 Whitman Folder. Lot Of 581918 S Buffalo Nickel Xf DetailUncirculated 1916-d Buffalo Nickel Free Shipping1914 D Buffalo Nickel Vg Detail1913 S Ty 1 Buffalo Nickel Au+1920 To 1938 Full Date Buffalo Nickel Lot / 600 Buffalo NickelsWhitman Folder Buffalo Nickel Collection 1913-1938 No. 9008..62 Coins..missing 2Set Of Buffalo Nickels 1934 To 1938 (12 Coins).. Au/bu1931-s Buffalo Nickel Au One Of Many Key Date Buffalo Nickels This Week1914 Buffalo Nickel Bu-1915-s Rare Grade Ms++++ Buffalo Nickel From Big Collection1913-s Buffalo Nickel, Type 2, ** Key Date First Year Issue! ** Free Shipping!1915-d Buffalo Nickel ** Great Date! ** Free Shipping!Choice 1913 American Buffalo Nickel Type 1 Bu/ms Pq Show StopperNice 1913 American Buffalo Nickel Type 1 Bu/ms Rainbow Toned1913 Buffalo / Hobo Nickel Item#hobo1 Nk1916 Buffalo Nickel1913 Buffalo 5 Cents Type-2 Icg Ms64Old Us Buffalo Nickels 5 Cent Coins Lot Of 1008 Coins1937-d Ngc Buffalo Nickel Ngc Ms 661938-d Pcgs Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms 65 ** Free Shipping!Ω 1913-s Buffalo Nickel Type 2 Vg, Spots1913-s 5c Type 1 Anacs Ms-62 Heavily Toned Big StrikeHigh Grade Collection Of 20 Buffalo Nickels 1916-s To 1937-s~ Nr1913 Pcgs Buffalo Nickel, Type 1, Pcgs Ms 65 ** Old Rattler Holder! ** Free S/h!1917 S G-vg And 1926 S G-vg Buffalo Nickel1915 D Buffalo Nickel Xf Detail1938 D Buffalo Nickel Icg Graded Ms 66 Mint State 66 Denver Minted Gr8 Patina1913-d Type 2 Buffalo Nickel Scarce!! Wowzer!!1921 S Good Detail And 1929 S Au Buffalo Nickel1936-d 5c Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms651916-d Buffalo Nickel Free ShippingBuffalo / Hobo Nickel Item#hobo2 NkUncirculated 1937-d Buffalo Nickel Free Shipping1913 Buffalo Nickel 5c Type 1 Gem Bu Uncirculated Great Coin Beautiful Gem1913 Type 2 Buffalo Nickel Free S/h!!1913 Type I Buffalo Reserve!Spectacular High Grade Ms+ 1938-d/d Buffalo Beautiful D Over D No Reserve1928-s Buffalo Nickel ** Scarce Date! ** Free Shipping!1917-s Buffalo Nickel Au+ Tough Date1938 D Buffalo Nickel From Estate Original Roll Pcgs Ms66 1913 Ty 1 Au, 1920 Au And 1928 D Xf Buffalo Nickel1923 Vf-xf, 1934 D Xf, 1930 Xf And 1935 D Xf Buffalo Nickel(33) Buffalo Nickels Mixed Lot - 1913-d T1- 1937-s - From Old Timers CollectionBetter Date! Original Very Fine 1921-s Buffalo Nickel ~ Free Shipping!1927 P Buffalo Nickel; Superb Gem BuNice 1930 American Buffalo Nickel Lustrous Full Horn***fast, Free Shipping!!1938-d 5c Buffalo Nickel Pcgs Ms 64 Old Green Label1929 Buffalo Nickel ** Free Shipping!1913-d Type 2 Buffalo Nickel___superb DetailOne Roll Buffalo Nickels 40 Coins Full Readable Dates On All Nice Mixed 1930's