At the end of the Buffalo nickel’s 25-year run (1913-1938), the U.S. Treasury launched a competition to replace the popular coin with a portrait of Thomas Jefferson and his home, Monticello. Of the 390 entrants, Felix Schlag was named the winner. Nickels still bear Schlag’s imagery today—he was awarded only $1,000 for this enduring contribution to U.S. coinage.

The obverse of Schlag’s coin is just as he designed it, but the reverse was given a thumbs-down by the government’s Fine Arts Commission, even after Schlag had been given the commission. They did not care for Schlag’s side view of Monticello, and also required him to make room for the name of Jefferson’s home, since it was believed that many Americans would not make a connection between the two.

Today, of course, most Americans know that Jefferson lived at Monticello, but one could argue that this knowledge of U.S. history is due to the legend on the nickel as much as anything else.

Mintages before World War II were strong, peaking at more than 200-million coins in 1941. Of these prewar coins, collectors tend to seek out those with examples of doubling, as in the 1939 nickel.

During the war, in 1942, the Denver mintmark on some coins appears to have been struck twice, the first time sideways and the second time correctly. But the biggest thing to happen to nickels during World War II was the removal of nickel itself from the coins. Up to that point, Jefferson nickels had been composed of 75% copper and 25% nickel, a recipe that continues to this day. During the war, nickel was considered a strategic mineral, so the alloy was changed from 1942 until 1945 to 56% copper, 35% silver, and 9% manganese.

Wartime nickels were minted in plentiful numbers, so none are rare due to insufficient supplies. As with prewar nickels, collectors gravitate to the error varieties, such as the 1943 in which the 3 has been struck on top of a 2, the 1943 in which Jefferson appears to have two left eyes, and the 1945 with a doubled-die reverse.

Postwar coins of note include 1945 and ’55 Denver nickels in which the D mintmark has been struck over a San Francisco S, as well as those 1954 San Francisco nickels which displa...

While the Jefferson nickel continues to circulate today, the Westward Journey series of 2004 and 2005 tweaked the format a bit. In 2004, the nickel retained its Schlag obverse but featured two different reverse designs, both relating to the bicentennial of the Lewis & Clark Expedition. The Louisiana Purchase/Peace Medal design by Norman E. Nemeth was based upon a medal produced for the expedition, while Al Maletsky’s Keelboat nickel depicted the craft the Corps of Discovery used to transport themselves and their supplies—until they reached the Rockies, that is.

In 2005, Joe Fitzgerald created a new obverse based on a sculpture of Jefferson by Jean-Antoine Houdon. Jamie Franki designed one of the two reverses for the coin, American Bison, which was a nod to both the beasts Lewis and Clark documented on their expedition and the beloved Buffalo nickels of 1913 to 1938. The other reverse, Ocean in View, was the work of Donna Weaver and imagines the view of the Pacific Ocean the explorers must have enjoyed.

Since 2006, Jefferson nickels have gone back to the Schlag reverse of Monticello, but the coin’s obverse is the work of Franki, based on a painting by Rembrandt Peale. Schlag’s initials still appear on the coin, but they are now on the reverse alongside his Monticello.

About our sources | Got something to add?

▼ Expand to read the full article ▼

Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

Legendary Coins and Currency

Legendary Coins and Currency

This online exhibition from the Smithsonian's National Museum of American History is a great way to get an overview… [read review or visit site]

Society of U.S. Pattern Collectors

Society of U.S. Pattern Collectors

Home to the Society of U.S. Pattern collectors, this well-organized site provides in-depth information on pattern c… [read review or visit site]

Clubs & Associations

Other Great Reference Sites

Most watched eBay auctions    

15 Jefferson Proof Nickels1979 5¢ Struck On Cent Plan. Pcgs Ms-63rb 1944 Jefferson War Nickel - No P - The Henning Nickel - Rare Find1985-s Jefferson Ngc Pf 70 Ultra Cameo * Price Guide $650 Rare! *1950 Jefferson Nickel Pcgs Pr65 Light Rainbow Toned~colorful Toning~gem Proof1971 5c No S Jefferson Nickel Pcgs Pr68cam Ultra Rare Cameo Proof Error!1970 S Nickel Double Struck 2nd Strike 75% Off Center Ms64 Ngc Mint Error1989-s Jefferson Ngc Pf 70 Ultra Cameo * Rare! No Reserve! *1939-d Jefferson Nickel With Reverse Of 1938 Pcgs Ms63 ***we Conbine Shipping **1938 Jefferson Nickel Proof1938 To 1961 Jefferson Nickel Album Complete Set With 1950 D 65 Total Coins1999-d 5¢ Dramatic Lamination & Defective Plan 1939 Jefferson Nickel ProofRare Date 1950-d Jefferson Nickel Exact Coin Shown Opens At Only .99c1980-s Jefferson Ngc Pf 70 Ultra Cameo * Rare! No Reserve! *1939 D Jefferson Nickel Uncirculated1988-s Jefferson Ngc Pf 70 Ultra Cameo * Price Guide $500 Rare! *Silver War Nickels Bu Set-beautiful-toned Fs10 Original Unopened 1957-p Uncirculated Bank Wrapped Rolls Us Shipping Only2015 S Nickel Early Releases Ngc Pf70 Ultra Cameo (portrait Label)1939 D Jefferson Nickel Seven Piece Lot United States Five Cent Coins Nr2009-d Unc Roll 5 Cents Jefferson Nickle - Banked Wrapped$$$ Four Rolls 1961 P *unopened *federal Reserve Jefferson Nickel Bank Rolls $$$80 Coin Set, Lot, Collection Of Jefferson Nickels 1938 To 1971 W/ Bu 1950 D 1942 D/d Jefferson Nickel Pcgs Vf25 No Reserve Auction!1938-64 Complete Jefferson Nickel Set 71 Coins With 1950 D & Silver War Nickels.1939 D Jefferson Nickel Five Piece Lot United States Five Cent Coins No ReserveLot Of (100) Proof Jefferson Nickels 1958, 1979 S Type 2, 1970 S, 1960 1977 S 5cJefferson Nickel Set - 71 Coins - 1938 To 1964 In Whitman - No Reserve2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 S Jefferson Mint Proof Set 2 - 1959 D Obw Original Bank Wrapped Roll Bu Uncirculated Jefferson Nickels1939 S Jefferson Nickel Uncirculated1938-1961 Jefferson Nickel 5c Complete Set In Whitman Trifold 1950-d Bu100 Silver War Nickels Circulated Bullion Coins Mixed Dates Mint Marks Lot 21942-p Pcgs Jefferson Nickel Proof, Type 2, Pcgs Pr 65 ** Flashy Proof Surfaces!1951 Jefferson Nickel ProofJefferson Nickel Collection 1938-1977Roll Of 40 2009-s Proof Jefferson Nickels(11) Bu Jefferson Silver War Nickels - 42-s 43-p 43-s 44-p 45-p 45-d 45-s 1959 1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 Gem Proof Jefferson Nickels Blazing Lot Of 6 Coins1 One Roll Jefferson War Nickels Nickel 40 Circulated Us Coins 35% Silver2015 S 5c Jefferson Nickel Birth Set Pcgs Pr70dcam First Strike(11 Coins) United States World War Ii Silver War Nickels 1942-1945 Id# Dd8151996-s Jefferson Ngc Pf 70 Ultra Cameo * Rare! No Reserve! *2015 S Nickel Early Releases Ngc Pf70 Ultra Cameo (portrait Label)1997-s Jefferson Ngc Pf 70 Ultra Cameo * Rare! No Reserve! *1942 P Jefferson Nickel, Wartime Silver Alloy, Pcgs Ms651940 S Jefferson Nickel Uncirculated Full Steps10 Different Rolls =(400 Nickels) Of Jefferson Nickels = (1939 To 1959-d).no Res2015 S Nickel Early Releases Ngc Pf70 Ultra Cameo (portrait Label)Uncirculated 1939-d Denver Mint Jefferson Nickel Free Shipping1954-s/d Jefferson Nickel Ms64 Pcgs Fs-501 Overmintmark CherrypickerDansco 1938 - 2016 Jefferson Nickel Album 7113 - 165 Coins / Not FullKey Date 1950 D Jefferson Nickel In Bu Condition 1950-d Jefferson Nickel UncUncirculated 1950-d Denver Mint Jefferson Nickel Free ShippingCirculated 1939-d Denver Mint Jefferson Nickel Free Shipping2 - 1959 P Obw Original Bank Wrapped Roll Bu Uncirculated Jefferson NickelsAttractive Roll Of 1954-s Bu Jefferson Nickels! Gorgeous S-mint Roll (40 Coins)1938 S Jefferson Nickel Uncirculated