The nickel was born out of the Civil War, when the hoarding of silver coins such as half dimes and quarters was commonplace. This prompted the creation of paper fractional currency, which just about nobody liked. After the war, in 1865, nickel mining interests successfully lobbied to get their metal included in the alloy for a new five-cent coin, which would be composed of 25 percent nickel and 75 percent copper.

Mint engraver James B. Longacre’s first nickel design was rejected because its obverse featured a bust of recently assassinated President Abraham Lincoln, who Mint Director James Pollock deemed too polarizing an image for defeated Southerners. Pollock also disliked Longacre’s George Washington designs, but he eventually settled on a mild variation of Longacre’s recent two-cent piece, which featured a bland shield crowned by the words “IN GOD WE TRUST” and a pair of droopy laurel branches.

When Longacre's nickels were circulated in 1866, they were promptly described as “the ugliest of all known coins.” The reverse was better, especially to contemporary eyes, but like the obverse it was not without controversy. Some said the rays—or bars, as they are also called—between the 13 six-pointed stars on the coin’s reverse were intended as a nod to Confederate soldiers. In fact, the rays were removed midway through 1867, but only because they made the coins difficult to strike.

Shield nickels were minted by the tens of millions, and many decent examples have survived to this day. Because shield nickels were only minted until 1883, they are a fairly easy coin to collect. Of the coins with rays, those from 1866 are most plentiful.

Beware of counterfeit coins dated 1871, 1874, and 1875. These coins circulated widely in the 1870s. No new nickels were minted in 1877 or 1878, although proofs were struck both years. Despite the limited mintages of these proofs (510+ and 2,350 coins respectively), the valuations on these nickels are not especially high since the quality of these coins is uniformly low.

Finally, because this coin was made using a nickel alloy, which is harder than alloys containing silver, completely-struck variations are difficult to come by. Collectors especially value Shield nickels in which all of the vertical lines on the obverse shield are fully-struck and distinct.

Shield nickels were followed in 1883 by Liberty Head nickels, which were struck for circulation until 1912.

Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

Legendary Coins and Currency

Legendary Coins and Currency

This online exhibition from the Smithsonian's National Museum of American History is a great way to get an overview… [read review or visit site]

Society of U.S. Pattern Collectors

Society of U.S. Pattern Collectors

Home to the Society of U.S. Pattern collectors, this well-organized site provides in-depth information on pattern c… [read review or visit site]

Clubs & Associations

Other Great Reference Sites

Most watched eBay auctions    

1874 Shield Nickel, Lustrous Bu Tougher Date, ** Free Shipping!Coins United States 5 Five Cents 1873 Km# 97 Union ShieldLot (5) Franklin Half Dollars 1950 1951 Pds Gem Uncirculated Acg Fbl Silver 50c1949 P D S Franklin Half Dollars Gem Uncirculated Acg Full Bell Lines Silver 50c1879 3cn (proof) Three Cent Nickel Pcgs Certified Pr 64•lot Of 7• Shield Nickels 1869 1874 1875 1882 •estate• You Grade Them! 5c Coins1948 P & D Franklin Half Dollars Gem Uncirculated Acg Full Bell Lines Silver 50c1953 P D S Gem Uncirculated Franklin Half Dollars Acg Full Bell Lines Silver 50cLot Of (3) Franklin Half Dollars 1952 P D S Gem Uncirculated Acg Fbl Silver 50c1873 Shield Nickel--uncirculated Details1866 Shield Nickel A Very Fine CoinRare: Wreath Reverse: Upside Backwards Five! 1866 Us Shield Nickel !!1 Of A Kind1869 Shield Nickel, Very Nice Choice Bu++ Tougher Date, ** Free Shipping!1868 Shield Nickel, Rpd 1868/68 Rev Of 68 5c, Better Variety, About Uncirculated1867 With Rays Shield Nickel1867 5c J-573 Proof Au Details Pattern Coin [very Rare]Lot (5) Franklin Half Dollars 1954 P, D, S, 1955 1956 Gem Unc Acg Fbl Silver 50c1869 Shield Nickel--attractive Original Extra Fine1872 Us Shield Nickel! Lower Mintage! Old Us Coins!1873 Shield Nickel - Fine 1867 5c Shield Nickel Rays Pcgs Genuine - Xf Details - CleaningReally Nice Lot Of 13 Cull Shield Nickels! See Photo.Lot Of Shield Nickel And Two Cents: 1883, 1886, 1887, 18881867 Gem High Grade Shield Nickel 1882 Shield Nickel *free Shipping After First Item*1867 Rays Shield Nickel 5¢- F/vf1868 Shield Nickel1868 Shield Nickel: Reverse Of '68: Icg 50: Fs-901 1 Broken Letter: No Reserve!1872 Shield Nickel - Good 1883 Shield Nickel - GoodDouble Die Date 1968 Five Cents Nickel1865 Shield Nickel With Rays Civil War Coin Estate Fine Free Shipping1872 Us Shield Nickel! Old Us Coins! Lower Mintage!1868 Shield Nickel Fs-05-1868-104 Double Die Obverse1867 W/ Rays Shield Nickel - Nice Circulated Condition - 32sa-21881 Shield Nickel - Key Date Hole Filler1868 And 1872 Shield Nickel No Reserve 1866 Shield Nickel - Good 1866 Shield Nickel ** Free Shipping!1866 Shield Nickel ** Free Shipping!1872 Shield Nickel ~ Vg+1869 Shield Nickel Super Rare Beautiful Coin Looks To Be Au ***** Take A Look***1867 5 Cent Shield Nickel With Rays1882 Shield Nickel - Good1867 No Rays Shield Nickel Au Details5 Cents Coin Post Civil War Year 1867 W/rays Shield Nickel 5 Cents Lot Here1868 Shield Nickel. Nice Detaile1876 Shield Nickel(8) Pc. Shield Nickel Collection !1883 Shield Nickel Pcgs Au55 30628701 2/2/20161867 Shield Nickel With Rays Has Die Breaks Almost Uncirculated Holed1867 Shield Nickel And 1868 3c Nickel1869 Shield Nickel1867 No Rays Shield Nickel Coin (xf-au) On Copper-nickel "" Pretty One """1866 Shield Nickel / Rays - About Good 1873 Shield Nickel1870 Shield Nickel Lot Of Nickels-1869 Shield,1924 Buff ,1958 Jeff Prf1874 Cupronickel 5 Gram Shield Nickel - Pm-0891867 Shield Nickel Almost Uncirculated Damaged