Share your favorites on Show & Tell

Silver tray

In Silver > Silver Trays > Show & Tell.
Silver Trays1 of 72What is it?Large Footed Silver Tray
Love it
Like it

ho2cultchaho2cultcha loves this.
lugnutslugnuts loves this.
auraaura loves this.
vetraio50vetraio50 loves this.
fortapachefortapache loves this.
dav2no1dav2no1 loves this.
See 4 more
Add to collection

    Please create an account, or Log in here

    If you don't have an account, create one here.

    Create a Show & TellReport as inappropriate

    Posted 2 years ago

    (17 items)

    Fancy Footed Silver Tray. Appears to be very old. Marked "Black. Starr & Frost" . I looked that up and can see it was a silver company. The mystery is I don't see any other marks. Possibly could be worn out? I'm assuming it is silver and not silver heavy, no magnetic properties.

    Unsolved Mystery

    Help us close this case. Add your knowledge below.

    Silver Trays
    See all
    Wallace Sterling Silver Clam Shell Dish Tray # 4020 Great Condition No Monogram
    Wallace Sterling Silver Clam Shell ...
    Magnificent Victorian Solid Silver Sterling Salver Tray 581g London 1857 27cm
    Magnificent Victorian Solid Silver ...
    Antique sterling silver Tray / Salver . Sheffield 1927.By Walker & Hall
    Antique sterling silver Tray / Salv...
    Tiffany Sterling Asparagus Tray 1919 HAND DECORATED
    Tiffany Sterling Asparagus Tray 191...
    Wallace Sterling Silver Clam Shell Dish Tray # 4020 Great Condition No Monogram
    Wallace Sterling Silver Clam Shell ...
    See all


    1. lugnuts lugnuts, 2 years ago
      I'm pretty sure you are assuming correctly saying it's silver. The puzzling part is i can't see any stamps. There should be both a sterling and a identifying number around the edges but as you say maybe they're worn off.
    2. cohkee, 2 years ago
      Thanks lugnuts--if you are familiar with this company, where would any other marks typically be? I've looked and felt around, but haven't detected anything. There is some tarnishing, but I'm assuming I'd feel an etch or stamp. The "B" on Black is almost worn down though, so, who knows...
    3. lugnuts lugnuts, 2 years ago
      This is another type of dish but the markings are usually in the same places.
    4. cohkee, 2 years ago
      Thanks again lugnuts--the example you linked to is really useful.
      I examined again, and...nothing. The back is really smooth except for the Black, Starr & Frost, which is really small and almost gets lost too(The flat underside of the tray is 12" across). I'm going to swap in a full underside view of the back of tray in my photos--the co name is below and slightly right to the top foot.
      Would be nice to further identify but may not be possible.
    5. lugnuts lugnuts, 2 years ago
      I would polish it and see if you can find anything. Good luck.

    Want to post a comment?

    Create an account or login in order to post a comment.