The earliest cutters for pastries and cookies, or "biscuits" as they were called in England, imprinted designs on the surface of dough. These “imprint cutters,” first made in Italy, were used in England kitchens starting in the 1400s to make gingerbread figures in the shape of celebrities like Queen Elizabeth I or Lord Wellingtion the First. These were followed by outline cutters, made from a flat piece of bent wood like pear, walnut, or beech, with a cutting edge and handle.

Beginning in the 1600s, Dutch and German settler housewives in Pennsylvania were known for producing large batches of cookies around Christmastime. Their wide array of cookie shapes included doves, cockerels, human figures such as Belznickel (a pre-Santa character), and the bald eagle.

Pennsylvania Germans also brought their honey cakes, marzipan, and gingerbread to America. They patterned their cake dough and almond paste with “springerle” or hand-carved marzipan molds that are minor artworks in and of themselves. Cheaper handmade tin cutters were offered by rural tinsmiths in commons shapes of people, animals, stars, spades, and hearts. The more unusual the shape, the more collectible the cookie cutter, like those in the form of reindeer, mounted figures, and clowns.

Old tin can be identified from modern metals as it is relatively heavy and thick, usually darkened in color. These cutters make 3/4-inch to 1 1/8-inch deep cuts. The back of antique cutters are flat and may or may not have strap handles. Because tinsmiths tried to conserve every possible inch of metal they could, older backs are more or less cut to the shape of the cutting edge. These also have “air holes” or “push holes,” which helped detach the cookie dough from the cutter.

In the mid-19th century, metal cookie cutters were mass-produced, and by the mid-20th century, they were also made of plastic. Vintage cookie cutters from the last century may have handles made of wood, metal, or plastic. Aluminum cutters can date to 1900, but are far more common from the 1930s. Metal cookie cutters with “bullet” handles are especially sought after by collectors. In general, figurals like chickens and elephants tend to be more valuable than geometric shapes.

Cookie cutters in the shapes of the four suits of playing cards were often sold as sandwich cutters—which have deeper edges than regular cookie cutters—designed to add whimsy to a poker or bridge party. Some of the more clever cookie cutters, like the “In-Genia Rotating Cutter” from West Germany, made several different designs with one rotating tool.

In England, Tala first offered its pastry-cutter sets in the early 1930s in painted tins. These tins can be dated by their colors: In the 1930s, they came in pastels, while the o...

Plastic cutters from the 1940s make deep cuts and come in transparent red and green colors. Opaque plastic cutters didn’t really show up until the 1960s, and they tend to make shallower cuts. Shapes include Santas and bunnies for Christmas and Easter, popular cartoon characters, flags for the Fourth of July, and profiles of the Statue of Liberty. Licensed cookie cutters from more recent decades include Looney Tunes, Mario Brothers, Barbie, and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Top American makers of cookie cutters are Ekco, Midwestern Home Products, and Hallmark, whose cutters from the late '70s and early '80s are relatively collectible.

Recently, collectors have gravitated toward plastic cutters that advertise businesses. The vintage American cutters are marked “Made in the U.S.A.,” while new ones are generally made in Hong Kong.

About our sources | Got something to add?

▼ Expand to read the full article ▼

Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

Feeding America

Feeding America

This archive of 76 influential American cookbooks from the late 1700s to early 1900s, assembled by the Michigan St… [read review or visit site]

Tupper Diva

Tupper Diva

Kristian McManus’ fresh, airtight collection of Tupperware catalogs and related ephemera from the 1950s and 6… [read review or visit site]

Clubs & Associations

Most watched eBay auctions    

Vintage Domar Alice In Wonderland Cookie Cutter | 3 7/8" Clear Red PlasticVintage Domar Mad Hatter Cookie Cutter | 3.75" Alice In Wonderland Clear Red3 Lilly Pulitzer Tropical Cookie Cutters | Monkey Palm Tree Elephant Pink2 Vintage Mr. Peanut Cookie Cutters | W/card 5" Red & BlueMartha Stewart Copper Cookie Cutter Lg Oh Christmas Tree Baking Cooking 2 Copper Martha Stewart Living Chubby Pumpkin Big Tom Copper Cookie Cutter Mold4 Vintage Detailed Plastic Cookie Cutter | Scotty Rooster Star Gingerbread ManLarge Metal Snoopy Cookie Cutter | 6.5" X 5" X 7/8" PeanutsVintage 5-piece Domar Rudolph The Red Nosed Reindeer Cookie Cutter Set | In Box13" Effner Little Darling "cookie Cutters" 7-pc.outfit And Ooak Doll By KatieMartha Stewart Copper Cookie Cutter Lg Prancing Reindeer Baking CookingVintage Hallmark Easter Bunny Rabbit Cookie Cutter Birthday Greeting Card 1960'sVintage Metal Cookie Cutter Big Lot Green Knob Wood Handles Aluminum Rare Ones!Baby Sasquatch Burgerville Plastic Advertising Cookie Cutter | 2004 The HollandHallmark Ornament 2014 Cookie Cutter Christmas #3 Series NibLot Of 21 Very Old Tin Cookie Cutters19th C Tin Cookie Cutter, German Shepherd?, No Reserve *Lrg Lot Vintage Metal Cookie Cutters Biscuit Pastry Wood & Strap HandlesAnn Clark Geico Lizard Promotional Cookie Cutter | New W/card 4.5"Peanuts Cookie Cutters - Large Snoopy On The Great Pumpkin, Plus 3 Others!Martha Stewart By Mail Noahs Ark Copper Cookie Cutters Set 1 NewHallmark 2013 Koc Exclusive A Tropical Holiday - Cookie Cutter Ornament Series2-piece Nutbrown Astronaut & Rocket Cookie Cutter Set | W/card Made In EnglandAntique Tin Cookie Cutter Star W/ Crimped Center Folk Art Pennsylvania Copper Cookie Cutter Scary CatVintage 3-piece B & B Liqueur Advertising Cookie Cutter Set | In Box Bottle +4-piece Vintage Trump Aluminum Cooky Cutter Set | In Box Red & Green Wood HandleMartha Stewart Copper Large Cookie Cutters Man On The Moon & Star BrightAntique C.1870 Prancing Bob Tail Horse Tin Flatback Cookie Cutter Pa Folk ArtCookie Cutters Large Lot Of Mixed Characters - Plastic And Metal Primitive Antique Hand Shape Metal Cookie Cutter Index Finger & Thumb Point Out4 Vintage Lone Toy Tree Company Cookie Cutters | Owl Duck Pumpkin Bunny RabbitLot Vintage Aluminum Cookie Cutters Christmas Angel Large Gingerbread Boy Holly3-piece Flintstones Cookie Cutter & Recipe Card Set | New In Package Fred Wilma+Rare Large 10 Inch Primitive Tin Belsnickle Santa With Tree Cookie CutterQuickutz Metal Die Stamp Tag Christmas Set Lot Cookie Cutter DiesCookie Cutter-flatback- Trotting Horse2 Antique C.1850 Rooster Tin Flatback Cookie Cutters 19th C. Pa Dutch Folk ArtVintage Metal Cookie Cutters With Red And Green Handles & 2 Copper Lot Of 17Pair Vintage Large Copper Cookie Cutters Deer And Santas Sled Martha Stewart?Gingerbread Man W/ Crown Cookie Cutter | 4.75" Yellow (robin Hood Flour?)3-piece Harley Davidson Logo Nesting Metal Cookie Cutter Set | 2 7/8 3 5/8 4.5"Woodstock Metal Cookie Cutter | 3" Peanuts2013 Hallmark Koc Event Exclusive - A Tropical Holiday Cookie Cutter OrnamentVintage International Harvester Advertising Cooky/cookie Cutter | 3" DiameterSet Of 6 Copper Martha Stewart Fall Leaves/leaf Cookie Cutters For ThanksgivingLot Of 3 Martha Stewart Large Copper Seasonal Cookie CuttersMini Mcdonald's Mayor Mccheese Cookie Cutter Ring | 1.75" Green Plastic1996 Set Of 6 Wilton Disney Cookie Cutters~mickey & Friends~minnie Mouse, Pluto+ Primitive Antique Heart Shape Metal Cookie Cutter Late19th/early 20th CenturySet Of 8 Hallmark Christmas Cookie CuttersAsl Sign Language I Love You Cookie Cutter | New In Package Adco 4"Antique Tin Snowman Cookie Cutter By K. DunwoodyLg. Antique C.1830 Dark Tin Flatback Gingerbread Woman Cookie Cutter Pa Folk ArtSigned Country Living Christmas Ornament Copper Cookie Cutter Michael Bonne65 Vtg Red Plastic Hrm Cookie Cutters Craft Mold Christmas Thanksgiving ChildrenMartha Stewart Alphabet Cookie Cutters Complete Set New Large SizeAntique C.1850 Tin Flatback Crimped Edge Star Cookie Cutter Pa Dutch Folk ArtVintage Metal Angel Cookie Cutter | 4.5" X 3"Antique Gingerbread Cookie Cutter Brass W/wooden Knob 5-3/4" Long