The earliest cutters for pastries and cookies, or "biscuits" as they were called in England, imprinted designs on the surface of dough. These “imprint cutters,” first made in Italy, were used in England kitchens starting in the 1400s to make gingerbread figures in the shape of celebrities like Queen Elizabeth I or Lord Wellingtion the First. These were followed by outline cutters, made from a flat piece of bent wood like pear, walnut, or beech, with a cutting edge and handle.

Beginning in the 1600s, Dutch and German settler housewives in Pennsylvania were known for producing large batches of cookies around Christmastime. Their wide array of cookie shapes included doves, cockerels, human figures such as Belznickel (a pre-Santa character), and the bald eagle.

Pennsylvania Germans also brought their honey cakes, marzipan, and gingerbread to America. They patterned their cake dough and almond paste with “springerle” or hand-carved marzipan molds that are minor artworks in and of themselves. Cheaper handmade tin cutters were offered by rural tinsmiths in commons shapes of people, animals, stars, spades, and hearts. The more unusual the shape, the more collectible the cookie cutter, like those in the form of reindeer, mounted figures, and clowns.

Old tin can be identified from modern metals as it is relatively heavy and thick, usually darkened in color. These cutters make 3/4-inch to 1 1/8-inch deep cuts. The back of antique cutters are flat and may or may not have strap handles. Because tinsmiths tried to conserve every possible inch of metal they could, older backs are more or less cut to the shape of the cutting edge. These also have “air holes” or “push holes,” which helped detach the cookie dough from the cutter.

In the mid-19th century, metal cookie cutters were mass-produced, and by the mid-20th century, they were also made of plastic. Vintage cookie cutters from the last century may have handles made of wood, metal, or plastic. Aluminum cutters can date to 1900, but are far more common from the 1930s. Metal cookie cutters with “bullet” handles are especially sought after by collectors. In general, figurals like chickens and elephants tend to be more valuable than geometric shapes.

Cookie cutters in the shapes of the four suits of playing cards were often sold as sandwich cutters—which have deeper edges than regular cookie cutters—designed to add whimsy to a poker or bridge party. Some of the more clever cookie cutters, like the “In-Genia Rotating Cutter” from West Germany, made several different designs with one rotating tool.

In England, Tala first offered its pastry-cutter sets in the early 1930s in painted tins. These tins can be dated by their colors: In the 1930s, they came in pastels, while the o...

Plastic cutters from the 1940s make deep cuts and come in transparent red and green colors. Opaque plastic cutters didn’t really show up until the 1960s, and they tend to make shallower cuts. Shapes include Santas and bunnies for Christmas and Easter, popular cartoon characters, flags for the Fourth of July, and profiles of the Statue of Liberty. Licensed cookie cutters from more recent decades include Looney Tunes, Mario Brothers, Barbie, and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Top American makers of cookie cutters are Ekco, Midwestern Home Products, and Hallmark, whose cutters from the late '70s and early '80s are relatively collectible.

Recently, collectors have gravitated toward plastic cutters that advertise businesses. The vintage American cutters are marked “Made in the U.S.A.,” while new ones are generally made in Hong Kong.

About our sources | Got something to add?

▼ Expand to read the full article ▼

Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

Feeding America

Feeding America

This archive of 76 influential American cookbooks from the late 1700s to early 1900s, assembled by the Michigan St… [read review or visit site]

Tupper Diva

Tupper Diva

Kristian McManus’ fresh, airtight collection of Tupperware catalogs and related ephemera from the 1950s and 6… [read review or visit site]

Clubs & Associations

Most watched eBay auctions    

Martha Stewart Cookie Cutter Oh Christmas Tree 7.25" Copper Flat Back Retired Vintage Domar Alice In Wonderland Cookie Cutter Very Rare Still On Card UnusedAmerican Girl Today Hand Mixer Baking Kit Cookie Cutters Icing Bag SprinklesVintage Moose Cookie Cutter | Clear Plastic Trapezoid Handle 4" X 3 7/8" No Id12-piece Homepride Flour Fred Cookie Cutter Set | Spillers 1978 Made In UkAntique Tin Cookie Cutter "odd Fellows" Heart In Hand DesignAerosmith Wings Cookie Cutter | 1999 Concert Promo Green Plastic | 2" X 4.75"Vintage Kool-aid Man Cookie Cutter / Jello Mold | Red 2 7/8" X 3.5" Oh Yeah!Lot Of Seven Instant-pix Cookie Cutters | Donald Duck Native Kids Ice Skater +Williams Sonoma Star Wars Cookie Cutter Set NibVintage Hallmark Peanuts~snoopy On Great Pumpkin~ Cookie CutterChristmas Wilton 18 Holiday Shape Stainless Steel Cookie Cutter Set NipRare Antique Soldered Tin "peafowl" Cookie Cutter. Good Early Tin Cookie Cutter3-piece Silver Spoon The Lion King Cookie Cutter Set | New In Package8-1/2" Large Copper Christmas Tree Cookie Cutter Michael BonneAntique Soldered Tin Cookie Cutter Handle Flat Back Man In Top Hat On Horse 6" W4 Wilton Double-sided Christmas Cookie Cutters | 1983 Santa Sleigh Reindeer +Copper Pot Crate And BarrelBachelorette Party Penis Cookie Cutter & Ice Tray MoldLot 5 Snoopy Charlie Brown Cookie Cutters Heart United Feature 1950 Free Us Ship3-piece Vintage Cookie Cutter Set | New On Card | Education Products Co. Santa +4-piece Snoopy & Woodstock Cookie Cutter Set | New On Card Peanuts Mi Japan6 Vintage Mini Green Metal Animal Cookie Cutters | Lion Horse Rooster Dog Cat +Williams-sonoma Kids Twist & Press Robot Cookie Cutter | In Box 2008 64 Molds4-piece Wilton School Days Cookie Cutter Set | New In Package 1990 | Bus Apple +Vintage Patriotic Cookie CuttersVintage Over 115 Pc Lot Of Cookie Cutters Holiday Christmas Halloween Etc.Car Cartoon 4 Shape Plastic Stamp Cookie Cutter Mold Set6-piece Mother Goose Hrm Set | New On Card 1951 | Humpty Dumpty Muffin Man +Hello Kitty Cookie Sandwich Toast Cutter Mold Japan Made Genuine Product A336-piece Vintage Educational Products Co. Cookie Cutter Set | New On Card Drum +40 Vintage Cookie Cutters Red & Yellow Plastic Hrm Aunt Chicks Amscan BrandsVintage Lot 3 Peanuts Charlie Brown, Lucy, Linus Christmas Cookie CuttersAntique & Vintage Huge Lot Of Cookie Cut Cutters & Strainer & GratersCool Collection Vintage Antique Holiday Cookie Cutters (12) Plus Egg Beater1988 - Brown Bag Cookie Art "hearts" Stoneware Shortbread Pan/mold/cutter8-1/2" Large Copper Lighthouse Cookie Cutter Michael Bonne6 Alphabet Letters Number Mold Fondant Cake Cookie Craft Cutter Decorating FrillDisney World Cookie Cutters Nib Mickey Mouse Ears-glove-star From Theme ParkVintage Halloween Tin Trick Or Treat Cookie Cutters With Box!7 Disney Cookie Cutters-2donald Duck&2mickey Mouse Figures Are Eagle, 3 Are WdSet Of 5 Round Circle Stainless Steel Biscuit Cookie Cutters 1" 2" 2.5" 3" 3.5"12 Vintage Hrm Red Clear Plastic Cookie Cutters Christmas Thanksgiving Turkey4-piece Wilton Nesting Dinosaur Cookie Cutter Set | 1994 Green PlasticPampered Chef Mini Cookie Cutter SetVintage Hallmark Gingerbread Twins Cookie Cutter Set | New On Card 1973 5"Vintage 5-piece Texas Cookie Cutter Set | In Box | Texas Imagineering Longhorn +Copper Pot Crate And BarrelSuper Huge Lot Vintage Cookie Cutters All Holidays, Characters, Animals15 Vintage Tin Aluminum Cookie Cutters Wood Handles~gingerbread ManVintage Aluminum Green & Red Wooden Handled Cookie Cutters (lot Of 10)Hallmark Ornament 2014 Cookie Cutter Christmas #3 Series NibPfaltzgraff Village Copper Cookie Cutter Pig Vintage Children's Miniature Cookie Cutters ~ 11 Doll - Toy Pieces, Nice!Vintage Mirro Aluminum Cooky Christmas Cookie Cutter Set New In Package Hallmark Peanuts Christmas Cookie Cutter Set Of 4 Snoopy Charlie Lucy Linus-1975 Vintage Hallmark Green Dudley Dragon Cookie Cutter-very Hard To Find-1979Lot Of 5 Vtg 1950's Childs Toy Aluminum Miniature Cookie Cutters, AnimalsMickey Mouse And Winnie The Pooh Metal Cookie Cutters! Disney Baking Goods!Mickey Mouse And Minnie Mouse Cookie Cutter With Stamp 4 Pieces Set.