The earliest cutters for pastries and cookies, or "biscuits" as they were called in England, imprinted designs on the surface of dough. These “imprint cutters,” first made in Italy, were used in England kitchens starting in the 1400s to make gingerbread figures in the shape of celebrities like Queen Elizabeth I or Lord Wellingtion the First. These were followed by outline cutters, made from a flat piece of bent wood like pear, walnut, or beech, with a cutting edge and handle.

Beginning in the 1600s, Dutch and German settler housewives in Pennsylvania were known for producing large batches of cookies around Christmastime. Their wide array of cookie shapes included doves, cockerels, human figures such as Belznickel (a pre-Santa character), and the bald eagle.

Pennsylvania Germans also brought their honey cakes, marzipan, and gingerbread to America. They patterned their cake dough and almond paste with “springerle” or hand-carved marzipan molds that are minor artworks in and of themselves. Cheaper handmade tin cutters were offered by rural tinsmiths in commons shapes of people, animals, stars, spades, and hearts. The more unusual the shape, the more collectible the cookie cutter, like those in the form of reindeer, mounted figures, and clowns.

Old tin can be identified from modern metals as it is relatively heavy and thick, usually darkened in color. These cutters make 3/4-inch to 1 1/8-inch deep cuts. The back of antique cutters are flat and may or may not have strap handles. Because tinsmiths tried to conserve every possible inch of metal they could, older backs are more or less cut to the shape of the cutting edge. These also have “air holes” or “push holes,” which helped detach the cookie dough from the cutter.

In the mid-19th century, metal cookie cutters were mass-produced, and by the mid-20th century, they were also made of plastic. Vintage cookie cutters from the last century may have handles made of wood, metal, or plastic. Aluminum cutters can date to 1900, but are far more common from the 1930s. Metal cookie cutters with “bullet” handles are especially sought after by collectors. In general, figurals like chickens and elephants tend to be more valuable than geometric shapes.

Cookie cutters in the shapes of the four suits of playing cards were often sold as sandwich cutters—which have deeper edges than regular cookie cutters—designed to add whimsy to a poker or bridge party. Some of the more clever cookie cutters, like the “In-Genia Rotating Cutter” from West Germany, made several different designs with one rotating tool.

In England, Tala first offered its pastry-cutter sets in the early 1930s in painted tins. These tins can be dated by their colors: In the 1930s, they came in pastels, while the o...

Plastic cutters from the 1940s make deep cuts and come in transparent red and green colors. Opaque plastic cutters didn’t really show up until the 1960s, and they tend to make shallower cuts. Shapes include Santas and bunnies for Christmas and Easter, popular cartoon characters, flags for the Fourth of July, and profiles of the Statue of Liberty. Licensed cookie cutters from more recent decades include Looney Tunes, Mario Brothers, Barbie, and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Top American makers of cookie cutters are Ekco, Midwestern Home Products, and Hallmark, whose cutters from the late '70s and early '80s are relatively collectible.

Recently, collectors have gravitated toward plastic cutters that advertise businesses. The vintage American cutters are marked “Made in the U.S.A.,” while new ones are generally made in Hong Kong.

About our sources | Got something to add?

▼ Expand to read the full article ▼

Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

Feeding America

Feeding America

This archive of 76 influential American cookbooks from the late 1700s to early 1900s, assembled by the Michigan St… [read review or visit site]

Tupper Diva

Tupper Diva

Kristian McManus’ fresh, airtight collection of Tupperware catalogs and related ephemera from the 1950s and 6… [read review or visit site]

Clubs & Associations

Most watched eBay auctions    

2013 Hallmark Koc Event Exclusive - A Tropical Holiday Cookie Cutter OrnamentVintage Mirro Cooky-pastry Kit Cookie PressAntique 19thc Tin Eagle Cookie Cutter Wings Spread! Aafa Folk Art PrimitiveNice 23 Pc Mirro Cooky-pastry Press & Decorator Set Box Instructions Recipes Retired Wilton Comfort Grip Angel Christmas Metal Cookie Cutter 4 1/2" X 5" EucAntique Hand Made Primitive Tin Chicken Cookie Cutter Rooster 6"l 1800s SolderedVintage Cookie Cutter Lot Peanuts Dumbo Winnie Pooh Hallmark Disney Xmas Plastic2012 Hallmark "cookie Cutter Christmas" Keepsake OrnamentLot 9-vintage Wood Handle Tin Cookie & Biscuit Cutters Old Metal Cut-out Cookies Mirro Cooky Pastry Press 12 Disks, 3 Tips, Rack, Booklet & BoxAntique Metal Cookie CutterMartha Stewart By Mail Noahs Ark Copper Cookie Cutters Set 1 New Never Used10 Pc Easy Bake Oven Lot:giftable Goodies! 3 Mixes/cookie Cutters/gift Bag/panAntique Hand Made Primitive Tin Cookie Cutter Fish 6.3"l 1800's Soldered Mold18 Lot Tupperware Tuppertoys Noah’s Ark Boat Animals Cookie Cutter Stencil CleanMirro-foley Cookie Pastry Press-aluminum- In BoxGirl Scout Cookie Cutters-lot/set Of 5-plastic-arts And Craft-baking Supplies Vintage Mirro Cooky And Pastry Press4 Vintage Metal Cookie & Biscuit Cutters Green Wood Knob Handles AluminumVintage Aunt Chick's Merry Xmas Cookie Cutters With Original BoxVintage Hallmark Gingerbread Family (dad Mom Boy) Cookie CuttersVintage Mirro Cooky Cookie & Pastry Press No 358 Am 15 Tips / Shapes & Book UsaVintage Mirro Cookie Cooky Press Cutter Pastry Press Aluminum Nip Wilton Flintstones 4 Pc Plastic Cookie Cutter Set Fred Pebbles Dino Bamm BamLot Of 25 Vintage Metal Aluminum Cookie Cutters Some With Wooden Handles.Antique Hand Made Primitive Tin Cookie Cutter Crow 6"l 1800's Soldered Vintage2012 And 2013 Hallmark Cookie Cutter Christmas Mouse Ornament #1and #2 Set Of 24 Pc Miniature Copper Christmas Holiday Cookie CuttersAntique Metal Cookie CutterLarge Land O' Lakes Hat And Mitten Copper Cookie CutterVintage Hrm Plastic Red Christmas Cookie Cutters~set Of 9~original Box NosLot Of 8 Cozy Mystery A Vintage Kitchen Cookie Cutter Shop Farmers' MarketVintage 22 Hrm And Domar 1950's Plastic Clear Red Cookie Cutters Holiday NurseryRare Antq/vtg Pennsylvania Dutch Heart Tin Cookie Cutter/c. 1800'sWilliams Sonoma Cars 2 Press And Stamp Cookie CuttersHallmark Keepsake Ornament 2013 Cookie Cutter Christmas86 Cookie Cutters Christmas & General Antique Metal Alum Copper Plastic SignedAntique Metal Cookie CuttersVintage Hallmark Snoopy Lying On The Great Pumpkin Cookie Cutter HtfVintage Man With Tree Wooden Carved Springerle Cookie Cutter MoldVintage Aunt Chick's Set Christmas Cookie Cutters SetComplete Mirro Cookie Pastry Press Recipes Included 12 Cooky +3 Decorator DisksCoolie King Cookie Press, Vintage Pritz30 Child's Toy Kitchen Utensils Aluminum Trays, Dishes, Bottles, Cookie CuttersVintage Lot Of 9 Miniature (toy) Cookie CuttersVintage 8 Cookie Cutters Wood KnobsSet Of 4 Star Wars Cookie CuttersCookie Cutter Christmas 1 - Hallmark Ornament 2012Antique Vintage 2 Large Metal Cookie CuttersVintage Tin W/ Soldered Handles Very Old Cookie Cutters, Christmas- Lot Of 6Large Land O' Lakes The Polar Express Train Copper Cookie CutterVintage Mirro Cooky And Pastry Press In Box With 15 Tips/shapes & Book No 358 Am4 Plastic Peanuts Colorful Cookie Cutters Snoopy Charlie Brown Linus Lucy VgcAunt Chick's Flower Garden Cookie Cutters 5 With InstructionsWilliams Sonoma Holiday Cookie Cutter 10 Christmas Lights Nib! Lot Aluminum Cookie Cutters Wood HandlesVintage Set Sun Giant Nestling Smiling Sun In Sunglasses Cookie Cutters! Sweet!Vintage Cookie Cutters Aluminum LotLot 69 Vintage Cookie Biscuit Pastry Cutters Metal Tin Baking Kitchen UtensilsVtg. Kid's Cooking & Baking Pans 16 Pc.cakes Pies Xmas Cookie Cutters Angel Food