When it comes to antique sterling silver flatware, age is not everything. For example, much of the flatware from the Victorian and Edwardian eras were mass-produced. For this reason, knives, forks, spoons, and serving utensils from these periods tend to be less collectible than handmade pieces, even those from more recent times.

A piece of flatware’s pattern and maker are generally more important than its age. Some patterns were meant to mimic the styles of earlier eras or places—Louis XIV-inspired patterns, evoking the opulent grandeur of 17th- and 18th-century France, are particularly common.

Other patterns are specific to a company. The 19th-century silversmith Wm. A. Rogers was known for his Elberon pattern, whose decorative edges extended all the way from the end of the handle to the base of the working part of the utensil itself. To prevent competitors from copying their patterns, many silversmiths actually patented their patterns in an attempt to make them immediately identifiable with their companies.

Most companies produced multiple patterns at a time, each with a descriptive or important-sounding name—from Buttercup, Daffodil, and Narcissus to Canterbury, Lafayette, and Duke of York. These patterns were often made continuously for decades, so the name of a maker and a pattern is not necessarily the best way to date a piece. To further muddle matters, companies such as American silver giant Reed & Barton made the same patterns in both silver plate and sterling silver, which, again, makes dating a particular piece of flatware difficult.

For collectors, the functionality of a piece of flatware is sometimes the most important consideration, especially if that functionality is archaic or obsolete. Serving pieces were the most specialized. Aspic slicers were designed exclusively for calves-foot jelly, cucumber and tomato-slice servers resembled tiny slotted hand mirrors, spinach forks had three wide-spaced tines to spear mounds of boiled spinach, and leaf-shaped ice cream ladles were meant to be used with a matching, dull knife—little wonder this combo was replaced by the ice cream scoop.

Sometimes the shapes of serving utensils didn’t tell you much about their use. A 19th-century sardine fork might reasonably be mistaken for a miniature lawn rake, while the cake servers from that era often look like hair combs. In other cases, the functionality of the serving utensil is clear, but the preparation of the food for which it was designed has fallen out of fashion—butter picks with fork handles and drill-bit-like ends do a fine job of stabbing chilled butter balls, but who eats butter like that anymore?

Aesthetics were the other major factor. Silversmiths such as Gorham, Georg Jensen, Tiffany & Co., Unger Bros., Oneida, and Shreve & Co. combined original designs with ones pulled from history, from the aforementioned Louis XIV to Art Nouveau...

For customers and collectors alike, settling on a pattern that is pleasing to look at is extremely important because with a complete silver service, you’ll be looking at that pattern a lot. A Gorham Chantilly service for 12, for example, may include two types of forks, three types of knives and spoons, and another half dozen serving utensils, for a total of 102 pieces. That’s a lot of Chantilly, so make sure you like it before you decide to bring it into your home.

About our sources | Got something to add?

▼ Expand to read the full article ▼

Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

Spoonplanet.com

Spoonplanet.com

Silver spoon collectors will eat up this site sponsored by the Spoon Collectors of Southern California. Here you ca… [read review or visit site]

Chicago Silver

Chicago Silver

Paul Somerson's incredible reference on handwrought metalwork from the American Arts and Crafts movement of the ear… [read review or visit site]

Feeding America

Feeding America

This archive of 76 influential American cookbooks from the late 1700s to early 1900s, assembled by the Michigan St… [read review or visit site]

Silver Marks Encyclopedia

Silver Marks Encyclopedia

An extensive reference guide to silver marks, hallmarks, trademarks and maker's marks found on antique and vintage … [read review or visit site]

Tupper Diva

Tupper Diva

Kristian McManus’ fresh, airtight collection of Tupperware catalogs and related ephemera from the 1950s and 6… [read review or visit site]

Silver at the Victoria and Albert

Silver at the Victoria and Albert

This is a great reference site on silver, courtesy of the Victoria and Albert Museum. You can view silver items acc… [read review or visit site]

The Gilbert Collection

The Gilbert Collection

The late Sir Arthur Gilbert's collection of European silver, gold, enamel, and other items is now housed at the Vic… [read review or visit site]

Delight in Design: Indian Silver for the Raj

Delight in Design: Indian Silver for the Raj

“Delight in Design: Indian Silver for the Raj” was the title of a 2008 exhibition at Columbia University’s Mi… [read review or visit site]

TheStieffCompany.com

TheStieffCompany.com

Scott Perkins is an enthusiastic evangelist for The Stieff Company, a significant Baltimore silversmith and maker o… [read review or visit site]



Clubs & Associations

Discussion Forums

Most watched eBay auctions    

Sterling Silver Alvin Chateau Rose 94pc Flatware Serving Place Set W Chest Gorham Strasbourg Sterling Silver 14pc Setting Service For 8 Flatware Set 112pcsLarge Wallace Grand Baroque Sterling Silver Flatware Old Set Servers Heavy GreatAntique Hester Bateman British Sterling Silver England Long Soup LadleVictorian Cased Set Of 12 Antique Sterling Silver Teaspoons - Tilden ThurberFine Antique Sterling Silver Antler Horn Handle Vtg Wine Bottle Corkscrew Opener72pcs 1966 Lunt Delacourt Sterling Silver Cutlery Silverware Set Service For 12Large Old Sterling Silver Reed Barton Francis 1 Flatware Set Servers Old MarksVintage Blackinton Co. Sterling Silver Bon Bon Nut 4 3/4' Inch Pierced Spoon12 Antique Russian 84 Sterling Silver Matching Teaspoons Or Demitasse EngravedAntique Gorham Buttercup Sterling Silver Flatware 6 Demitasse Spoons 2.1 OzAntique Lunt Sterling Silver Figural Bunny Rabbit Nursery Rhyme Baby Childs Fork1950s Vintage Mid 20thc, American Web Sterling Company Poultry Shears, NrAntique Pr. Sterling Silver 84 Russian Serving Spoons Mint Condition No ReserveAntique Sterling Silver Reed & Barton Floral Harlequin Spoons DemitasseWallace Rose Point Sterling Silver Flatware Service For 6.Nice Reed & Barton Sterling Silver Sugar Shell Spoon * Francis I Pattern 1907Antique Sterling Silver Gorham Colonial Soup Or Punch LadleWestmorland Sterling Silver George And Martha Flatware Set Serves 8 63 PiecesSterling Silver Lot,bon Bon Spoon,salt Spoons, Pickle Fork Etc $9.99Xxl Service For 18 **wallace Sir Christopher Sterling Flatware Set *no Mono**S. Kirk & Son Sterling Set Of 8 Round Bowl Soup Spoons In The Repousse Pattern Antique Sterling Silver Decorative Serving Cake/pie Knife 5.8 Oz 11.5" Long!!Xl **old Mark **gorham Buttercup Sterling Flatware Set *no Mono**Set Of 5 Sterling Silver Ice Cream Forks By Wallace In The Washington PatternAntique Sheffield Sterling Silver & Mother Of Pearl Fish Set For Six In Case!Towle Sterling Candlelight Group Of 8 Dinner ForksS. Kirk & Son Sterling Set Of 8 Teaspoons In The Repousse Pattern S. Kirk & Son Sterling Set Of 9 Salad Forks In The Repousse Pattern (3) Piece Reed & Barton Sterling Silver Handled Knife Lot * Francis I 1907Georg Jensen Denmark Old Marked 925 Sterling Silver Acorn Serving 9" ForkSet (6) Antique 19thc Aesthetic Twist Handle Sterling Silver Demitasse Spoons NrSet Of 8 Alvin Sterling Southern Charm Pattern Sterling Silver Soup SpoonsHeavy Whiting Sterling Master Butter Knife In The Lily PatternSet Of 6 Antique Sterling Silver Dominick And Haff Mazarin Demitasse SpoonsAntique Alvin Sterling Melrose Pat. 1910 Cold Meat Fork 2.25 Troy Oz No MonoAntique 19thc, Sterling Monogrammed, Royalty Crown Fish Sever Pierced Design6pc Set Antique Sterling Silver Gorham Flower Bouquet Demitasse Spoons TeaspoonsAntique 19thc, Norwegian Sterling Silver Sugar Sifting Spoon, Monogrammed CrownAntique Gorham Buttercup Sterling Silver Flatware 6 Tea Spoons 5.46 OzAntique Sterling Silver Watson John Alden Asparagus TongsVery Rare Minty Tc Shop Hand Hammered Kalo Employee Sterling Silver Salad SetAntique Gorham Buttercup Sterling Silver Flatware 6 Iced Tea Spoons 6.4 OzSet Of 8 Alvin Sterling Southern Charm Pattern Sterling Silver Iced Tea SpoonsExquisite William Spratling Mexico Hand Hammered Sterling Silver Wood Ladle Rare Set Of 12 Gorham Sterling Ice Cream Forks In The Etruscan Pattern, No Mono1870 Victorian Gorham Sterling Silver Swiss Pattern Fish Pie Pastry ServerAntique Sterling Silver Wallace Washington Tomato ServerFrancis I Sterling Silver Sardine Server-fine/rare 1907 Reed & BartonAntique Victorian Sterling Silver Nut & Bon Bon Spoon LotSet Of 3 Gorham Etruscan Pattern Sterling Silver Forks 7-5/8" *greek Key Design*Durgin Co. (6) Pieces Sterling Silver Tea Spoons - Shreve, Treat & Eacret GorhamAntique Gorham Buttercup Sterling Silver Flatware 8 Butter Knives 7.6 OzAntique Gorham Buttercup Sterling Silver Flatware 4 Dinner Forks 5.6 OzTowle Sterling Candlelight Group Of 9 Small ForksAntique Coin Silver Knife With Rams Head HandleSet 6 Boxed Georg Jensen Acanthus Sterling Silver Vermeil Demitasse SpoonsJ.s. Macdonald Early 1900's Sterling Silver 5 Piece Dinner Spoon Set 3742-16 Sterling Reed & Barton Tea Spoons Francis Pattern Not Scrap Lot 2Gorham Versailles Sterling Silver Flatware Set 116 Pc