Steam engines were the backbone of railroading until the early 1950s. Little wonder, then, that most vintage model trains were based on real-life steam locomotives, even though very few of these toys actually ran on live steam. Early tinplate toy trains, for example, made largely in Germany by companies like Lehmann, Bing, Issmayer, Carette, Günthermann, and Märklin, ran on clockwork engines.

Around 1900, Märklin in Germany and Carlisle & Finch in the United States introduced the first electric train sets. Before long, German manufacturers like Bing and Karl Bub, as well as American makers like American Flyer, Ives, Lionel, and Marx, were selling electric toy locomotives alongside their clockwork ones.

Manufacturers in Great Britain, the country credited with inventing the railway, produced very few toy trains in the 19th and early 20th centuries, but the “learning” toys made there did run on live steam. Sold by specialist companies such as Newton, Bateman, H.J. Wood, John Theobald, Lucas, and Davis, these steam-power brass toy locomotives were known as “dribblers” or “piddlers” because they left a trail of water and alcohol as they ran across the floor. Heavy and expensive, these engines, branded with names like Stevens Model Dockyard and Clyde Model Dockyard, were offered with a just few pieces of rolling stock made out of mahogany.

Intended for young engineers, the toys were actually rather dangerous. Components of a dribbler included a boiler for the water, a kerosene or alcohol lamp that warmed the water, and a steam chest containing pressurized steam. In 1871, American Eugene Beggs introduced an safer live-steam toy train that dribbled significantly less. Then, in 1888, Weeden Manufacturing Company put out the elegant live-steam Weeden Dart locomotive, which was an instant hit.

European manufacturers quickly followed suit with better dribblers to sell in America, like the high-end O gauge Carette. In 1906 and 1909, Märklin made a live-steam train set, inspired by George and Robert Stephenson’s famous 1829 steam engine Rocket, but given the lack of examples on the market today, it seems few were sold or produced.

Around 1905, the Metropolitan Railway in London, now known as London’s Underground Metropolitan Line, was incrementally converted from steam-power to electricity. Hornby, the esteemed British toy train manufacturer that first debuted its clockwork locomotive set in 1920, made the brilliant move of patterning its first electric train set after the Metropolitan Line, an actual electric train.

However, steam trains had a devoted following among model-train enthusiasts—be they little boys or adults—and so toy train companies continued to churn models out. As most manufa...

After World War II, competition heated up between Lionel and American Flyer, as the companies vied to see who could come up with the most exciting features. Lionel led the way with two patents, a realistic knuckle coupler and an on-board whistle. But perhaps most thrilling of all was the appearance of real smoke coming out of the smokestack.

For the Lionel electric steam locomotive released in 1946, these puffs of smoke were made of nitrogen oxide, created by burning a pellet of ammonium nitrate. Breathing enough of this smoke could cause eye-watering and coughing, and when swallowed, the pellets caused dizziness, heaves, and diarrhea, but these dangers were considered a small price for realism at the time.

American Flyer’s 1946 locomotives, on the other hand, produced a more billowing effect with a “choo-choo” sound, using a petroleum-based cedar-scented liquid that was nontoxic. Quickly, Lionel scientists formulated an even less-toxic smoke pellet and a hot-wire smoking device.

Joshua Lionel Cowen was particularly fond of those smoking steam engines, so it was with great reluctance that he agreed to let Lionel reproduce the brick-like look of the new, modern diesel engines. These came styled as the Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Railway, which ran super-fast trains from Chicago to Los Angeles, and the New York Central Railway. To Cowen’s surprise, the diesel models were a big hit, particularly with kids on the West Coast who could finally get a toy of a train they were familiar with.

However, when Hornby introduced its English Electric Type 1 Bo-Bo Diesel Electric Locomotive in 1958, train hobbyists were more upset that it was modeled after the controversial diesel engine than the fact its body was made in plastic, not metal.

About our sources | Got something to add?

▼ Expand to read the full article ▼

Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

Airfix Model Railways

Airfix Model Railways

Dave McCarthy's Airfix Model Railway treasure trove is an in-depth archive of the company's plastic railway kits fr… [read review or visit site]

Gateway NMRA

Gateway NMRA

This great reference site for model railroaders, from the Gateway (St. Louis) division of the NMRA (National Model … [read review or visit site]

This site is a treasure trove of HO scale model railroad manufacturer catalogs and other reference information, inv… [read review or visit site]

Postwar Lionel Trains Library

Postwar Lionel Trains Library

Bernie Schulz’s Lionel Trains Library focuses exclusively on postwar Lionel trains and accessories. The site cont… [read review or visit site]

Eric's Trains

Eric's Trains

Eric Siegel's site displays his collection of O-gauge/O-scale trains, tracks, turntables, and other accessories. A … [read review or visit site]

Tech Model Railroad Club of MIT

Tech Model Railroad Club of MIT

MIT's model railroad club, as one might expect, has one of the best websites for learning about how people play wit… [read review or visit site]

Clubs & Associations

Other Great Reference Sites

Most watched eBay auctions    

O Scale 2-rail Brass Steam Locomotive & TenderAccucraft C16 2-8-0 Consolidation 268 Electric Steam Loco 1:20.3 G Scale GaugeHo Scale - Rivarossi - Union Pacific Big Boy 4-8-8-4 Steam Locomotive (no Motor)Prewar Lionel 226e Steam Locomotive & 2226w Tender, C-7 Ex+, Runs Great, No Rsv!S Gauge American Flyer 332ac 4-8-4 Northern Steam EngineLionel 265e Gray Commodore Vanderbilt Steam Engine 2-4-2 & 265w Tender Runs LookHo Precision Craft Models 582 Up #4022 4-8-8-4 Big Boy Steam Union PacificLionel Postwar 726 Steam Locomotive W/ 2426w Tender And Boxes - Excellent!Lionel 6-18009 Nyc 4-8-2 Mohawk Steam Locomotive, Railsounds,slLionel Standard Guage Original Prewar 392e Steam Engine Gunmetal Runs GoodLionel O 6-8307 Southern Pacific Daylight 4-8-4 Steam Locomotive Sp #4449Dorfan Prewar O 1920s/30s No. 55-r Red Dorfan Lines Steam Locomotive And TenderMth Premiere Norfolk & Western 4-8-4 Class J Steam LocomotivePostwar Lionel 726 Berkshire Steam Loco & 2426w Whistle Tender~nice Original!Lionel Trains O Scale Southern Pacific Legacy 2-8-4 Berkshire Steam LocomotiveHo Intermountain 59005 Sp #4292 4-8-8-2 Ac-12 Cab Forward Steam Southern PacificHo Scale Athearn Genesis G97221 Up #4007 4-8-8-4 Big Boy Steam Union PacificHo Scale Rivarossi R5471 Up #844 4-8-4 Fef-3 Steam Locomotive Union PacificHo Scale - Roundhouse - 2-6-2 Steam Locomotive & Tender Kit!Ho Athearn Genesis G9202 Up #821 4-8-4 Fef-2 Steam Union Pacific Dcc SoundRare Key Brass N Gauge Union Pacific Challenger Steam Locomotive 4-6-6-4 Brass Broadway Limited Ho 089 Pennsylvania I-1 Sa 2-10-0 Steam Engine & Tender SoundLionel 6-11210 Vision Line Union Pacific 4-6-6-4 Challenger Steam Locomotive LnLionel 6-18023 Western Maryland Shay Steam Engine & Tender Ex/boxPrewar Lionel O Gauge No.259e Steam Engine & Tender With BoxesNice Marx Smoking 333 Steam Locomotive For Train Set NycVintage Lionel Prewar Steam Locomotive #258 & #257t Tender W Ob Untested O GaugeLionel # 2026 Early Steam Engine And TenderSpectrum 11415 Ho Baldwin 2-8-0 Santa Fe Steam Loco Ln/boxPostwar Lionel 736 Berkshire Steam Locomotive & 2046w Whistle Tender~w/nice Ob'sDorfan Prewar O 1920s #55 Green Dorfan Lines Clockwork Steam Locomotive & TenderHo 2-8-8-2 Steam Locomotive & Tender, Santa Fe #1790 (proto 2000 Heritage)Ho Brass Hybrid Broadway Limited Bli 1296 Up #5509 2-10-10 Ttt-6 Steam Dcc SoundLionel 8206 New York Central 4-6-4 Steam Locomotive Engine & Tender With Sound.Vintage Prewar Lionel Train 262 Steam Locomotive Engine O Gauge Black X207 PfHo Athearn Genesis G9126 Up #3977 4-6-6-4 Challenger Steam Union Pacific Dcc SouLionel Chicago Cubs Steam Berkshire Locomotive, Tender, Passenger Car Train Set Proto 2000 67203 Ho N&w Heritage Usra 2-8-8-2 Steam Loco & Tender/boxLionel 6-11155 Santa Fe 2-10-10-2 Legacy Vision Steam Locomotive Ln/boxHo 4-6-2 Prr K4s Brass Steam LocomotiveLionel #6-28649 Polar Express #1225 Diecast Berkshire Steam Locomotive & Tender Mantua Vintage 4-6-0 Dixie Belle - Ho Steam Loco Mint! LocomotiveHo Scale Mantua Powered Steam Engines And Diesel. Needs Tlc. Good Running Cond.!Rivarossi Up Union Pacific 4-8-8-4 Big Boy Steam Locomotive 1406 Ho Scale EngineS Gauge American Flyer 343 Nickel Plate 0-8-0 Steam SwitcherHo Scale Rivarossi R5473 Up #840 4-8-4 Fef-3 Steam Locomotive Union PacificN Gauge Fleischmann 2-8-4 Tank Type Steam Locomotive #7065 New Old Stock No ResBachmann Ho Scale Trains Dcc Equipped Gs4 Steam Locomotive American Freedom NewLouis Marx Stream Line #25864 Steam Type Electric Train Set Original Box 1950'sHo Scale - Fujiyama Brass - Northern Pacific Class "l-9" Steam Locomotive Train!Ho Scale Rivarossi R5454 C&o #1633 2-6-6-6 H8 Allegheny Steam Locomotive N Scale Southern Pacific 4-8-4 Daylight # 4449 Steam LocomotiveAntique Live Steam Locomotive Train Live Steam Engine G Scale No Reserve O Gauge Railking 6-8-6 Bantam Turbine Steam R-t-r Train Set W/proto-sound 2.0Mth Railking O Gauge Pennsylvania 2-8-0 Steam Engine Loco Sounds Lionel 6-18001 Rock Island 5100 4-8-4 Northern Steam Locomotive & Chug TenderSunset Models Ho Scale Brass Prr M-1a 4-8-2 Steam Loco Kit Ln/boxLutz Hielscher Live Steam B4 Locomotive - Ho Scale Alcohol Powered - No ReserveRivarossi 5450 Ho Milwaukee Railroad 4-6-4 Hudson F-7 Steam Locomotive And Tende1950 Lionel #2035 2-6-4 Steam Locomotive With Whistling Tender