Founded in 1949 by Charles Stuart, who named his costume-jewelry company after his granddaughter, Sarah Coventry did not follow the Coro, Trifari, or Miriam Haskell practice of producing the work of a strong in-house designer. Instead, Stuart purchased designs from freelancers, then hired firms such as DeLizza and Elster, whose house brand was Juliana, to create its chokers, necklaces, brooches, earrings, and bracelets.

Also unlike its competitors, Sarah Coventry did not focus on getting prime counter space in department stores, or selling its wares to Hollywood movie stars in order to move its inventory. Stuart’s approach was more grassroots, using house parties (a la Tupperware and Avon) to get people talking about his affordable jewelry. He also gave his costume jewelry away to contestants on game shows and at beauty pageants. The word of mouth that resulted from this marketing strategy made Sarah Coventry one of the most popular jewelry brands of the mid-20th century. Today, its pieces from the 1960s and ’70s are especially prized by collectors.

Even though Coventry lacked its own designer, many of the company’s signature pieces share stylistic characteristics. For example, Sarah Coventry costume jewelry tends to feature cabochons and marquise-cut rhinestones rather than densely packed grids or endless rows of smaller sparklers. Base metals were usually gold-tone or silver-tone, sometimes serving as openwork or filigree backgrounds for a handful of stones placed symmetrically upon them. And, above all, Coventry jewelry was fun, often ringed with eye-catching rhinestone-bead or enameled-metal fringe. Sometimes Coventry pieces even incorporated art masterpieces such as the Mona Lisa into their designs.

For much of its short history (the brand was sold in 1984, and enjoyed only a brief resurgence from 2002 to 2003), Sarah Coventry advertised its jewelry as being “for the woman who dares to be different,” even though the names it gave most of its products were plain and ordinary. A brooch from a line called Azure featured a faux turquoise cabochon set atop a spiral of gold-tone amid smaller stones. Wisteria is the word the company chose to describe a silver-tone setting featuring purple and pink rhinestones, even though the floral shape looked nothing like the famous flowers as depicted by, say, Tiffany.

Sometimes the names were more evocative, such as Acapulco, whose intertwined star-like and vaguely circular shapes were defined by their red-and-green cabochons, chosen, presumably, to echo the colors of the Mexican flag. Maharani was simply meant to sound exotic—its faux turquoise stones were paired with faceted emerald rhinestones, which were positioned like leaves on the line’s brooch and matching earrings.

And then there were names that suggest the company’s marketing division had simply run out of ideas. For no particular reason, a four-piece set that included a diamond-shaped brooch, with matching clip-on earrings and a stickpin, was called Remembrance, while Bittersweet featured faux coral teardrops attached to gold-tone leaves. Touch of Elegance treated its green rhinestones like pieces of fruit hanging from stems and secured by filigree settings. Fashion Splendor was the phrase used to describe an organic circle of openwork gold-tone decorated with opaque pink and white rhinestones, as well as clear marquise-cut green rhinestones. Better was Fashion Flower, which paired ruby and aurora borealis rhinestones on a filigree gold-tone setting (matching earrings came in two sizes, while the namesake brooch differentiated itself with the addition of a stem).

Color-based pieces are among the most collectible. Blue Lagoon pieces from the 1960s had aurora borealis rhinestones on them, alongside smaller blue and purple ones. The asymmetrical Mosaic combined solid-color and dappled cabochons on gold-tone. Strawberry Ice used silver-tone and strawberry shapes for its pins and earrings. And the gold-tone necklace-and-earring set called Golden Avocado riffed on the popular kitchen color of the 1970s.


Best of the Web (“Hall of Fame”)

Researching Costume Jewelry

Researching Costume Jewelry

Jewelry lovers, venture through this amazing database of vintage jewelry articles, catalogs, and brochures, as well… [read review or visit site]

Emerald City Vintage Costume Jewelry

Emerald City Vintage Costume Jewelry

It looks like we're not in Kansas anymore with Elizabeth Rowlands' site on vintage costume jewelry from the 1940s a… [read review or visit site]

Morning Glory Antiques and Jewelry

Morning Glory Antiques and Jewelry

Jewelry collectors, feast your eyes on this internet gem! It's a goldmine of jewelry information featuring all styl… [read review or visit site]

All About Jewels Dictionary

All About Jewels Dictionary

This incredible reference dictionary on jewelry, from Enchantedlearning.com, is both beautiful and comprehensive. S… [read review or visit site]

Cathy Gordon's Jewelry Gallery

Cathy Gordon's Jewelry Gallery

With its vast galleries featuring clear images of jewelry and style, this site really covers it all! Divided up by … [read review or visit site]



Clubs & Associations

Most watched eBay auctions    

Vintage Rhinestone Brooches Necklaces Lot Of 15 Sarah Coventry #48Vintage Rhinestone Jewelry Lot. 17 Pieces. Sarah Coventry. Repair. See Desc. #63Vintage Rhinestone Brooches. Lot Of 5 Sarah Coventry Demi"s #49Vtg 65 Pc Bracelet Lot Charm Angel Rhinestone Heart Monet Lisner Sarah Cov Jj6Vintage Enamel Flower Pin Earring Lot Sarah Coventry Barclay RhinestoneVintage Retro Sarah Coventry Jewelry Lot 25 Pieces Assorted !31 Vintage & Modern Brooch Lot Rhinestone Flowers Coro Sarah Cov Wells 14k Gf Vintage Signed Sarah Coventry Lot 21 Pieces Faux Emerald RhinestonesVintage Rhinestone Brooches. Lot Of 4 Sarah Coventry #62Vintage Rhinestone Sarah Coventry Jewelry Lot Of 22 Pieces. #46Big Chunky Silver Tone Sarah Coventry Panel Link Bracelet Floral ReliefVintage Enamel Flower Pin Earring Lot Weiss Coro Sarah Cov Rhinestone ButterflyVintage Rhinestone Brooch Necklace Lot Of 8 Sarah Coventry Pieces. #47Beautiful 24 Piece Estate Brooch Lot Bsk Danecraft Trifari Monet Sarah CovVintage Sarah Coventry Faux Turquoise & Pearls Gold Tone Brooch/pendant Lot 822Fabulous Large Vintage Goldtone & Glass Stone Set Pendant & Chain Sarah CoventryGrandmas Estate Beautiful Sarah Cov Rhinestone Brooch 29 Vintage & Modern Brooch Lot Rhinestone Flowers Coro Sarah Cov Avon Gerrys Vintage "sarah Coventry" Black Stone Set, Bracelet, Pin & Clip EarringsVintage Sarah Coventry Jewelry Lot 20 Pieces Brooches, Necklaces, Earrings...Jewelry Lot Vintage-now 30pc Sarah Coventry Necklaces Brooches Earrings BraceletVintage Sarah Coventry Necklace And Earring SetSign Sarah Cov Vtg 30" Silver Tn Double Chain Necklace Tassel Pink Rhinestone...5 Piece Designer Necklace Lot * Trifari, Sarah Cov, Monet, Napier, AvonSigned Sarah Coventry Vintage Bracelet Lucite Silver Tone Panel Q180Lot Of 13 Vintage Costume Pins Brooch Coro Ajc Sarah Coventry Dm Unmarked Signed Sarah Cov Vintage Brooch Pin Flower Leaf Rhinestone Silver Tone J38Grandmas Estate Beautiful 1940's Rhinestone Big Chunky Sarah Cov BroochGorgeous Vintage Sarah Coventry "victorian -style Brooch Or Pendant"16 Vintage Signed Sarah Coventry Costume Jewelry Rings In Sarah Display BoxVintage Enamel Flower Pin Earring Lot Hollycraft Sarah Cov. Rhinestone Butterfly Lot Of 37 Vintage And Modern Pins And Brooches Variety Avon Sarah Cov ToledoFabulous Vintage 1960s Oak Leaf Garland Bracelet Signed Sarah Cov In BoxVintage Bracelet Clamper Bangle Sarah Coventry Huge Big Chunky Glass RhinestoneVintage Sterling Silver - Sarah Coventry Prong-set Red Crystal 2g - Ring (7.75)Vintage 6pc Lot Designer Rhinestone Glass Flower Costume Earrings Sarah CoventryStunning Vintage Estate Signed Sarah Cov Flower Rhinestone Adj Sz Ring!!! 3088yVintage Retro Signed Sarah Coventry Lot 24 Pieces !28 Vintage & Modern Brooch Lot Rhinestone Boucher Crown Trifari Monet Sarah CovStunning Vintage Estate Signed Sarah Cov Flower 2 3/4" Brooch!!! 3037aVintage Estate Jewelry Large Enamel Flower Power Pin Lot E 1 Art 1 Sarah CovVintage Estate Signed Sarah Cov Pink Enamel Flower 1 1/4" Earrings!!! 3053uStunning Vintage Estate Gold Tone Signed Sarah Cov Flower 1" Earrings!!! 3032aHi Quality Vintage Earring Lot Rhinestone Continental Sarah Cov 2 Lisner Q327Vintage D&e Juliana For Sarah Coventry Blue Rhinestone Brooch "blue Lagoon"72 Vintage To Now Costume Fashion Rings Rhinestone 925 Sterling Avon Sarah CovLot Of Vintage Costume Jewelry Krementz Sarah Coventry + 38 Pieces B10Vintage Sarah Coventry Sets15 Vintage Large Flower Floral Brooch Pin Lot Gerry's Capri Bsk Sarah CoventryVintage Sarah Cov Costume White & Blue Faux Pearl Bracelet Winter Wonderland VtgVintage Designer Necklace Lot Sarah Cov B David Napier Rhinestone ++Signed Sarah Coventry Vintage Set Brooch Pin Earrings Ab Rhinestone Q256Stunning Vintage Estate Signed Sarah Cov Gold Tone Flower 24" Necklace!!! 3074nStunning Vintage Estate Gold Tone Signed Sarah Cov Flower 2 1/2" Brooch!!! 3042vVintage Estate Signed Sarah Cov Peach Enamel Flower 1 1/4" Earrings!!! 3053wGrandmas Estate Beautiful Sarah Cov Brooch Vintage Jewellery Sarah Coventry Signed Goldtone Sunflower C1960s Brooch/pinVintage Designer Sarah Coventry Delicious Frosted Glass Apple Brooch Earring Set27 Piece Vintage & Modern Mixed Colorful Necklace Lot - Sarah Coventry, J. CrewVintage Goldtone Hinged Bangle Bracelet Versaille Sarah Coventry