Share your favorites on Show & Tell

Mystery Art Pottery Vase / Still Needs an ID Help !

In Pottery > Show & Tell.
Pottery9858 of 12240maker ???Pottery signed by Hullow.
Love it
Like it

TreyTrey loves this.
PhilDMorrisPhilDMorris loves this.
antiqueroseantiquerose loves this.
ho2cultchaho2cultcha loves this.
auraaura loves this.
racer4fourracer4four loves this.
SEAN68SEAN68 loves this.
vetraio50vetraio50 loves this.
tom61375tom61375 loves this.
nldionnenldionne loves this.
Siren6Siren6 loves this.
miKKoChristmas11miKKoChristmas11 loves this.
AmberRoseAmberRose loves this.
See 14 more
Add to collection

    Please create an account, or Log in here

    If you don't have an account, create one here.

    Create a Show & TellReport as inappropriate

    Posted 10 years ago

    (1156 items)

    This is my prize find from our local Goodwill :
    The vase has a matte blue-green glaze almost turquoise ( not as dark as in the pictures) over a yellowish under glaze and stands 10 1/2" tall. The top is 6"in dia. and the base is 5"in dia. with small handles at the bottom.It doesn't seem to have any damage at all. There is a drip on the very bottom that looks like it's worn away,but it doesn't show. It's quite heavy and very smooth to the touch.The inside shows dripping were the glaze runs to the bottom with some of the under glaze showing through. There is no factory mark on the bottom just something that looks like three 1's ( 111 ) stamped into the clay. I've searched for a few days and have come up with nothing. It seems to have the looks of Rookwood, Roseville, Weller, McCoy, etc.but nothing I can pin down. I've had one opinion that it might be early Pfaltzgraff art pottery from the 1930's. Can anyone help me solve this mystery ?? Note: The Roseville "Baneda" vase sure looks similar (see new picture) !
    Thanks for any help or expertise.

    Unsolved Mystery

    Help us close this case. Add your knowledge below.

    See all
    Vintage Lady Head Vase Planter VELCO - 3747 JAPAN 6 1/2
    Vintage Lady Head Vase Planter VELC...
    Vintage Eldreth Art Pottery Salt Glaze Sitting Rabbit Bunny Signed
    Vintage Eldreth Art Pottery Salt Gl...
    Huge Weller Pottery Fruitone Antique Bulbous Vase Terra Cotta Blue Green N/Rsrv
    Huge Weller Pottery Fruitone Antiqu...
    Vintage Lady Head Vase Planter VELCO - 3747 JAPAN 6 1/2
    Vintage Lady Head Vase Planter VELC...
    See all


    1. mikelv85 mikelv85, 10 years ago
      A lady on Ebay told me it is definitely not Roseville, so I guess I'm back to square one .
    2. mikelv85 mikelv85, 10 years ago
      Thank you BELLIN68 ! Not too bad for a $2.00 investment and the Goodwill. They have gotten pretty wise to marked pieces like Haeger and McCoy and price them higher, but this was just sitting there all by it's lonesome. I thought OMG ! When I picked it up and checked it for cracks or chips it was flawless. I paid for it and got out of there as quick as Now I just have to find out who made it and what it's worth. More than $2.00 I'm sure !
    3. nldionne nldionne, 10 years ago
      This one keeps catching my eye. Any luck yet? Have you tried rookwood and peters and reed? Reminds me of roseville egypto too. Problem, everyone made this color matte back then. Let us know if you find anything.
    4. mikelv85 mikelv85, 10 years ago
      No luck yet. It's even stumped Ervin. He said the glaze is similar to Roseville Rookwood and Weller but he didn't think it was any of those. He said try researching the glaze, but like you said everyone made a matte green of some type. I had someone tell me it might be Teco but the shape should be in their catalogs and why no mark ? I just don't know if have something of great value or just a minor piece. Sure would be nice to know ! - Mike -
    5. mikelv85 mikelv85, 10 years ago
      Just came to me. Maybe it's just someone's old cremation urn...LOL !
    6. nldionne nldionne, 10 years ago
      LMAO!!!! I know how frustrating it can be. Old pottery, gotta love it.
    7. nldionne nldionne, 10 years ago
      See in laughing so hard I hit the submit button twice!
    8. mikelv85 mikelv85, 10 years ago
      I had this picture (at top of page) of a Roseville vase from their "Baneda" line . Minus the decoration and flip the handles, it's the closest thing I've found so far. Maybe mines a blank or a factory Still looking -Mike-
    9. nldionne nldionne, 10 years ago
      Roseville did have some humdinger shapes. I have seen this shape somewhere but can't remember where. It's hell to get old:)
    10. mikelv85 mikelv85, 10 years ago
      Hmm.. don't know I suppose, although there doesn't seem to be any connecting lines top or bottom to complete the letters.Unless they didn't imprint. Maybe it's even roman numerals.
    11. mikelv85 mikelv85, 10 years ago
      That's why I thought they might be roman numerals too instead of a line across the top and bottom like 3 capital III.
    12. nldionne nldionne, 10 years ago
      You boys at it again? You'll find it! Gotta go mow.
    13. mikelv85 mikelv85, 10 years ago
      Yep, the wheels are turning on this My very first post. Think we might get it this time. Eye is on a roll !
    14. nldionne nldionne, 10 years ago
      He usually is and doesn't give up easily. It took months to solve my first post. It's out there somewhere.
    15. sarahoff sarahoff, 10 years ago
      It sure looks like Rosevilles "Baneda" series.
    16. mikelv85 mikelv85, 10 years ago
      I think it's a little heavier than Abingdon. They look kind of flimsy and light weight compared to mine. I had a lady on Ebay suggest it might be early Pfaltzgraff, but I never think of them as doing "deco" pieces.
    17. nldionne nldionne, 10 years ago
      Still looking
    18. mikelv85 mikelv85, 10 years ago
      Okey I've almost forgotten about this piece. It's been put away for months ! :)
    19. aeon aeon, 10 years ago
      I purchased a fake Roseville Montacello early this year and discovered how frequently a pattern of theirs would be mimicked, but with variations to the shape. It's my guess that's what's going on here as well, but I'm no expert.
    20. SEAN68 SEAN68, 10 years ago
      Your very welcome Mike:) great find!!!
    21. mikelv85 mikelv85, 10 years ago
      I've seen the Roseville fakes and they also have a fake Roseville script mark most of the time. A friend of mine here on CW collects and has a lot of Roseville. She even has a few fakes she bought on purpose for comparison. Usually if you're going to deceive you go all the way. This shape is pretty common for this era and most pottery companies have something similar. They copied one and other quite often. Mine seems to be too heavy for Roseville anyway. So many of these pieces aren't marked or had paper and foil labels. You just don't know or may never know who made them.
    22. SEAN68 SEAN68, 10 years ago
      im in all of agreement with you Mike!!!, they are just so hard to figure out.
    23. aeon aeon, 10 years ago
      I neglected to realize that the last photo of yours was only a comparison, not another angle of your vase. Yeah, it seems more likely than an attempt at a fake would have gone so far as to have the floral design as well.
    24. aeon aeon, 10 years ago
      *that* an attempt at a fake
    25. Greatsnowyowl Greatsnowyowl, 10 years ago
      its definitely NOT Roseville. absolutely isn't.
    26. mikelv85 mikelv85, 10 years ago
      I knew it wasn't Roseville from day one. The vase in picture four is the "closest" thing I found online shape and color wise and just posted for comparison. It's art pottery of some kind but it's still a mystery as to exactly what company made it.
    27. art.pottery, 9 years ago
      Stumbled on this vase pic doing an unrelated search. Ok, kind of late on the id but its Pfaltzgraff form a art pottery line they produced briefly circa the 30s (and possibly early 40s)
    28. mikelv85 mikelv85, 9 years ago
      Yes, it has been a long time since I even thought about this piece, art.pottery. It's been on the closet shelf for the past year. Someone had mentioned to me that it might be Pfaltzgraff on ebay back then, but I didn't realize they did art pottery. You always think of their Pennsylvania Dutch things and not art deco. Thanks for the confirmation. Wish I could find a catalog with this piece in it. Reminds me of Teco and Fulper as well. That's probably what they were aiming for and why the run was so short. -Mike-
    29. mikelv85 mikelv85, 9 years ago
      You know I actually find that a much more interesting possibility. This was my very first art pottery piece from well over a year ago. The mystery returns !
    30. upstatenycollector upstatenycollector, 9 years ago
      Could you post a closet pic of the decoration? Is it glaze only, or is it incised?
    31. upstatenycollector upstatenycollector, 9 years ago
      Closer, not closet... jeez! Fat fingers!!
    32. mikelv85 mikelv85, 9 years ago
      Sorry for the confusion upstatencollector......The fourth picture is a Roseville Baneda vase I posted it only for shape comparison. Mine is the first three pictures. Just a plain matte green glaze. No decoration at all.
    33. mikelv85 mikelv85, 9 years ago
      No problem id :)...... it's nice to have the help with the research. I've pretty much exhausted myself with this
    34. upstatenycollector upstatenycollector, 9 years ago
      That's what I get for not paying attention to detail. Thanks Mike!
    35. mikelv85 mikelv85, 9 years ago
      You know id I've been told everything from it's a Chinese fake and everything in between but there's still no definitive proof for any of it. This piece just refuses to be identified. It's very art deco in my opinion and the color is perfect for the era but the maker is the only piece of the puzzle that's missing. Sometimes there's nothing left to do but enjoy it for what it is. :)
    36. katherinescollections katherinescollections, 7 years ago
      You mentioned this post in your 1K thread, so I thought I would take a look at your mystery vase. art.pottery IDed it as Pfaltzgraff 30s Art Deco, I did a Google search and was amazed at the images, not at all what I associate with Pfaltzgraff, of course by the time I was buying that brand, it was all about brown stoneware.

      Anyway, as often happens, by learning something new on CW, not two days later I came across a Pfaltzgraff Art Deco vase myself! And the seller not knowing what she had sold it to me at a bargain price. So thanks, Mike! :)
    37. mikelv85 mikelv85, 7 years ago
      You're welcome Katherine :)...hope you'll post it I'm dying to see what you found. I'm still not 100% sure what this one is. Guess I'd need a catalog picture to convince me from back in the

    Want to post a comment?

    Create an account or login in order to post a comment.