Share your favorites on Show & Tell

Three Face Cake Stand Pedestal Details - Duncan vs. Imperial MMA

In Glassware > Early American Pattern Glass > Show & Tell.
Early American Pattern Glass167 of 185Rustic - Boy Holding Basket Statuette Stem - Crystal w/Frosted Stem by GillinderCrown Jewel - Crystal Cake Stand by O'Hara Glass Company, ca.1888
23
Love it
1
Like it

mcheconimcheconi loves this.
antiqueroseantiquerose loves this.
mikelv85mikelv85 loves this.
RadegunderRadegunder loves this.
AimathenaAimathena loves this.
cindyjunecindyjune loves this.
pops52pops52 loves this.
SEAN68SEAN68 loves this.
Moonstonelover21Moonstonelover21 loves this.
sarahoffsarahoff loves this.
inkyinky loves this.
smiatasmiata loves this.
musikchoomusikchoo loves this.
freiheitfreiheit loves this.
nldionnenldionne loves this.
ho2cultchaho2cultcha loves this.
epson233epson233 loves this.
NootchNootch loves this.
miKKoChristmas11miKKoChristmas11 loves this.
toolate2toolate2 loves this.
antiquesareamazingantiquesareamazing likes this.
wolcott1wolcott1 loves this.
thriftfanthriftfan loves this.
winglettswingletts loves this.
See 22 more
Add to collection

Please create an account, or Log in here

If you don't have an account, create one here.


Create a Show & TellReport as inappropriate



Posted 3 years ago

Email

TallCakes
(27 items)

This post is to show the detail of various 'Three Face' pedestals from cake stands. This first image is from a 10 1/2" Duncan cake stand. The other 3 images are side-by-side comparisons with 9 1/2" Imperial MMA and original George Duncan Glass stands. The GDG original is slightly more substantial than the MMA reproduction, but that is a bit hard to see in photographs. The detailing in the face of George Duncan and Son's (GDG) has more refined details compared to the MMA reproduction by Imperial Glass; notice differences in the overall shape of the face, as well as jaw line, nose and mouth. The profile images also show the differences in the nose and chin. Also notice braids between the faces on the side views. The frosted finish of the original GDG pieces fade due to the fuming process used whereas the MMA reproduction pieces have more of a defined line from an immersion process. Another useful test is the 'black-light test'; the original GDG pieces will have a soft yellow glow that is not present in reproduction pieces. Another detail is that the plate of the GDG original has a shallow scalloped skirt, whereas the scallops in the MMA reproductions are incorporated into the gallery and there is no skirt.

The 9 1/2" cake stand was reproduced and has a smaller stem than the 10 1/2" stem shown in the first image.

I have added additional comparison images at my website:
http://www.tallcakes.com/CakeStands/DuncanMillerGlassCo/ThreeFaceCrystalwFrostedStem.aspx

Comments

  1. wingletts wingletts, 3 years ago
    That is very interesting...love this...
    hey check this out...thought of you when I was searching
    http://www.ebay.com/itm/Imperial-Glass-CANDLEWICK-CLEAR-Birthday-Cake-Plate-/310333598349?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item484152ea8d
  2. TallCakes TallCakes, 3 years ago
    thanks! The b'day cake plate actually has 72 indentions/holes around the edge for placing candles around the cake; I have one of them. It is made by Imperial aslo; the same company that made the MMA 3-Face here.
  3. wingletts wingletts, 3 years ago
    It is beautiful, I am sure your afraid to use it at times. thought you might like to see this on web.
  4. Paul71 Paul71, 3 years ago
    Great pics of the Three Face stems, TC. They are not the easiest to photograph, believe me, I know. I wrote an article for the Early American Pattern Glass Society that was published in their Newsletter in the spring that gives some guidelines to tell the repro Three Face pieces from the old.
  5. TallCakes TallCakes, 3 years ago
    @thriftfan: thanks for the love

    @Paul71: Thank you. Is there anyway to get a copy of your article; is it online? I did this to help an eBayer who has an unmarked IG piece.
  6. Paul71 Paul71, 3 years ago
    I think the only way to get it is through the EAPGS
  7. Paul71 Paul71, 3 years ago
    There was no toothpick made in the original issue of "Three Face." All toothpicks are reproductions.
  8. TallCakes TallCakes, 2 years ago
    thanks for the loves!
  9. TallCakes TallCakes, 2 years ago
    thanks bellin68! this is one of my favorite groupings of EAPG cake stands.
  10. epson233 epson233, 1 year ago
    very classy and unusual tallcakes -- interesting information -- thanks for sharing and the tips -- have a great week
  11. TallCakes TallCakes, 1 year ago
    many thanks epson223. Here's a direct link to more pics on these cake stands. The satin finish is very hard to photograph, so I still need to work on that, but the differences of originals and reproductions are evident.
    http://www.tallcakes.com/CakeStands/DuncanMillerGlassCo/ThreeFaceCrystalwFrostedStem.aspx
  12. TallCakes TallCakes, 1 year ago
    many thanks to all of you for the loves as well :)
  13. TallCakes TallCakes, 12 months ago
    TY Moonstoneloner21 :)
  14. SEAN68 SEAN68, 12 months ago
    AND AGAIN , I STUNNING:) AKA:BELLIN68:) SEAN68:)
  15. TallCakes TallCakes, 12 months ago
    Thanks Sean : )
  16. TallCakes TallCakes, 12 months ago
    TY pops52 : )
  17. TallCakes TallCakes, 8 months ago
    Thanks cindyjune : )
  18. TallCakes TallCakes, 4 months ago
    thanks Aims..... : )

Want to post a comment?

Create an account or login in order to post a comment.